banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Art progression

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #543879
user avatar
Member

4:40 am, Apr 4 2012
Posts: 409


Ah! My Goddess

user avatar
Member

6:10 pm, Apr 4 2012
Posts: 15


Flame of Recca
Gokusen

user avatar
chasing oblivion
Member

8:47 pm, Apr 4 2012
Posts: 1366


Usually any long-running series is going to have art progression, but a few more examples

Rave
3x3 Eyes
Beck
Battle Angel Alita atleast between the first series and the second one.

________________
Sarcasm just doesn't work over the internet.
Post #544020 - Reply to (#543858) by lalalarry
user avatar
Manga Eater
Member

9:19 pm, Apr 4 2012
Posts: 442


Quote from lalalarry
Quote from lihmao

Fruits Basket


seconded


Am I wrong, or wasn't Fruits Basket regression??

Cheese In the Trap has improved a bit, if I recall.

________________
Go to work, send your kids to school;
Follow fashion, act normal;
Walk on the pavement, watch T.V.;
Save for retirement, obey the law.
Repeat after me: I am free.
user avatar
Pew pew
Member

9:37 pm, Apr 4 2012
Posts: 883


Stray Love Hearts! can't say there's progression for the story but the art improves. :I People squealed about the art but I say in the first few chapters it was pretty bad.

Post #544165 - Reply to (#544020) by Saons
user avatar
 Member

5:03 pm, Apr 5 2012
Posts: 1021


Quote from Saons
Am I wrong, or wasn't Fruits Basket regression??

I think there was a definite improvement. At the start, it looked like their heads were too small for their faces. It's just that the style changed later on, and I've heard many don't like it. I'd say that the skill level improved by the middle, then the style changed too (for better or for worse).

user avatar
Member

6:45 pm, Apr 5 2012
Posts: 114


D.Gray-Man Allen started out pretty cute as the story goes on.....just wow (as well as the several other attractive characters-guys and girls alike)!! eyes Also Hoshino is amazing at drawing scenery (especially in the latest chapters) and is SUPER detailed, plus the plot is incredible and there are several chapters (213).
Also Kateikyoushi Hitman Reborn! has significantly evolved as well.

Last edited by blackcatmaniac_01 at 6:52 pm, Apr 5 2012

user avatar
Hum
 Member

6:50 pm, Apr 5 2012
Posts: 365


Gokusen

The progression was noticeable, no?

________________
"Shouldn't be alive but the condom broke."
Post #544193 - Reply to (#544165) by Blique
user avatar
Manga Eater
Member

7:59 pm, Apr 5 2012
Posts: 442


Quote from Blique
I think there was a definite improvement. At the start, it looked like their heads were too small for their faces. It's just that the style changed later on, and I've heard many don't like it. I'd say that the skill level improved by the middle, then the style changed too (for better or for worse). ...


I own volumes 1-12, and I think it was around volume three that the author injured her hand, I seem to recall the "margins" of the manga stating. I don't know if it's true, but it seems unlikely that it was the cause of the change since the transition wasn't that dramatic. Still, the style is very, very different from volume one to twelve. In my opinion, the style went from stylized and structured (meaning one that had been gained through practice) to a style that seemed simplified, blocky, and unemotional, and it seemed "forced" as if the author purposely meant to draw differently.
Either way, I mean, there was definitely a change. I guess it's just up to what peoples tastes are.

________________
Go to work, send your kids to school;
Follow fashion, act normal;
Walk on the pavement, watch T.V.;
Save for retirement, obey the law.
Repeat after me: I am free.
Post #544309 - Reply to (#544193) by Saons
user avatar
 Member

5:39 pm, Apr 6 2012
Posts: 1021


Quote from Saons
I own volumes 1-12, and I think it was around volume three that the author injured her hand, I seem to recall the "margins" of the manga stating. I don't know if it's true, but it seems unlikely that it was the cause of the change since the transition wasn't that dramatic. Still, the style is very, very different from volume one to twelve. In my opinion, the style went from stylized and structured (meaning one that had been gained through practice) to a style that seemed simplified, blocky, and unemotional, and it seemed "forced" as if the author purposely meant to draw differently.
Either way, I mean, there was definitely a change. I guess it's just up to what peoples tastes are.

I own volumes 1-23. Early art, middle art, end art samples.

I agree that the beginning art was stylized, but it looked far from structured in the practical sense. The faces floated around as if there was no consideration to underlying bone or muscles, and anatomy is how you make a style consistent. It's the common case of having a pretty style but not knowing the basics. Regardless of how stylized something is, all art is based off of real life; it builds a foundation that you can then stylize off of, and it won't look off like it does here.

Towards the middle, Takaya-sensei got a good grasp of anatomy and proportions, though it was still a little bumpy in places. This was probably her experimenting stage, where she tried to weave a proper artistic foundation into her usual style but was reluctant to leave her old habits (also a common problem, but it's better for the art in the long run).

At the end, her foundation is very strong, her anatomy is solid, and her proportions are perfect. The only downside is that her style changed a lot during the experimenting stage, and it looks simpler and blander now.

I think if she revisited her initial style now that she has a good grasp of the basics, it would look wonderful. But as things are now, I very much prefer her end style that has a strong foundation instead of her beginning style that was pretty but anatomically off.

Last edited by Blique at 5:46 pm, Apr 6 2012

user avatar
Member

6:42 pm, Apr 6 2012
Posts: 113


seconding rave master

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Mishy
Member

6:43 pm, Apr 6 2012
Posts: 1737


Hunter x Hunter

The art got better and then worse.

________________
Nulla in mundo pax sincera
"Always go too far, because that's where you'll find the truth." - Albert Camus
user avatar
Member

6:59 pm, Apr 6 2012
Posts: 716


Seconding Id
Ubel Blatt gets better but its not very noticeable

________________
Is this me in a nutshell?
Pretty much.
User Posted Image
Member

7:38 pm, Apr 6 2012
Posts: 70


Ingenuo Progression is clearly evident however in every chapter, last 2-3 volumes the art regressed, no idea what happened. Not sure if you'd like the genre either bigrazz

Post #544512
user avatar
Apostle of Cock
Member

5:37 am, Apr 8 2012
Posts: 234


Magic Kaito or anything by Gosho Aoyama for that matter.

________________
Being alone is only lonely if you want it to be.
Staying in lucid delusion for an eternity.
Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next
You must be registered to post!