banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Do you judge a manga by its cover?

Poll
Well do ya?
All the time
Sometimes
Only if it looks really cool/horrible
I read descriptions
You can't judge a manga by its cover, must be read a bit first
You must login to vote.

Pages (13) [ 1 2 3 4 5 6 Last ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Member

7:23 am, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 47


Well I use the description mostly and the year it was made (can't stand art before the 90's).

For shoujo I just steer clear of that genre unless the plot is really interesting, then I would skim through the first chapter to see if the art was a typical shoujo art style.

user avatar
Lurker Queen.
Member

11:58 am, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 779


Almost all the time. Shame on me. >_>

Post #201192
user avatar
Curious
 Member

12:30 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 596


I usually read the summary first then read the reviews although most of the times the reviews are misleading. It has happened a few times though that upon looking at the cover I immediately deduce that it's not for me...

________________
To see everything from the perspective of eternity
user avatar
Crazy Cat Lady
Member

1:47 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 1850


First - read summary
Second - if summary leaves me ambivalent, check reviews (if it's here) or check out the beginning of the manga (if I'm in a book store)

The cover doesn't really have much to do with it for me, except for helping me quickly avoid stuff I'm just not interested in (i.e. if the cover makes it clear that it's your basic shounen fighting manga, or yaoi, or it's *extremely* fan-servicey, etc. then I don't waste time reading the summary).

________________
"[English] not only borrows words from other languages; it has on occasion chased other languages down dark alley-ways, clubbed them unconscious and rifled their pockets for new vocabulary."
-James Nicoll, can.general, March 21, 1992
Post #201212 - Reply to (#201091) by sljo
user avatar
Member

1:52 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 2342


Quote from hyery
Ya know, there's a good reason why they made up the saying "don't judge a book by it's cover" and that is, well, to not judge a book by it's cover duh... i mean, there's like a gazzillion manga out there with good story but poor cover. But then again, to read a discription you'll always look for the cover which caught ur attention(good art or eye catching) bigrazz

That saying was one of my reasons for making this topic.

Quote from sljo
One good example was the cover of I's, which got my attention immediatly.

I's had a winning formula when it came to covers. Not too much going on with a great amount of detail, love 'em.


user avatar
Herder of Pigeons
Member

2:19 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 132


A lot of the covers of my favourite manga are incredibly inferior to the art inside, so I have learnt not to.

For one thing they are often in some cheesy pose that's completely out of character, and for another it's rare that a manga artist has time to get good at working in colour. The Bleach colours for example always look to me like they were coloured in by a kid with their first pack of felt pens, which considering how classy the chapter title pages are in that manga is a bit silly.

It is a pity though, cos when your mates who dont read manga come round and see them all lined up they think you're reading complete shite...

Post #201230 - Reply to (#201218) by centzon totochtin
user avatar
Member

3:51 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 2342


Quote from centzon totochtin
A lot of the covers of my favourite manga are incredibly inferior to the art inside, so I have learnt not to.

For one thing they are often in some cheesy pose that's completely out of character, and for another it's rare that a manga artist has time to get good at working in colour. The Bleach colours for example always look to me like they were coloured in by a kid with their first pack of felt pens, which considering how classy the chapter title pages are in that manga is a bit silly.

It is a pity though, cos when your mates who dont read manga come round and see them all lined up they think you're reading complete shite...

I always found that weird, compared to western style comics that had covers that are so well done.

Post #201242
user avatar
Member

5:01 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 50


I've always read the description and sometimes judge just it by it's cover but I've been good about getting away from that. I also take in account heavily what others thought of it, read a fair share of manga that I wasn't feeling the description or something but people highly recommended it, would read it and be like wow, why did I not want to read this is in the first place. A good example of a manga like that for me is Angel Densetsu

________________
"I came to laugh at you!" - Chars Aznabal
user avatar
Member

7:47 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 51


Sometimes if it looks really weird I won't read it but usually I give it a try first or read the description on the back.

________________
"Great things come in small packages."
Post #201320
 Member

7:57 pm, Sep 11 2008
Posts: 1063


When looking at unscanlated manga, yes, I do.

When looking at scanlated manga, I pay attention to genre, people's comments, reviews (if any) and whatever.

user avatar
Madame Red
Member

8:37 am, Sep 12 2008
Posts: 2172


well i shouldnt judge just by cover but mostly i do that. and when i started to read it, mostly all i have is big disappointment. i just dont learn dead

Member

3:52 pm, Sep 15 2008
Posts: 245


I tend to read everything I lay my hands on, although, obviously, if a manga has a really super cool cover than I'll probably start reading it the minute I see it. But, yeah, if I judged a manga by its cover, I definitely never would have read Hana Yori Dango, for instance (I didn't like the art of the first covers at all!)... thank goodness I did, though!

user avatar
unknown species
Member

10:52 am, Oct 19 2008
Posts: 909


if i take a liking to the cover, then i will read the description. but i normally like whats on the cover so i mostly judge it on that the story is about

user avatar
Lowly Member
Member

7:49 pm, Oct 22 2008
Posts: 3888


Gotta be honest. All the time.
Well, when all I see is the cover, and no description, what else am i supposed to judge it with?
Art is an important factor for me to read a manga, no doubt, I won't touch a manga with horrible art unless the plot is uber amazing.

________________
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ
Post #218472 - Reply to (#218453) by StarlightDreams
user avatar
Semi-Active
 Member

8:02 pm, Oct 22 2008
Posts: 884


Quote from StarlightDreams
Gotta be honest. All the time.
Well, when all I see is the cover, and no description, what else am i supposed to judge it with?
Art is an important factor for me to read a manga, no doubt, I won't touch a manga with horrible art unless the plot is uber amazing.


Seconded, I look at the art to draw me in.

________________
Forever lurking...
Pages (13) [ 1 2 3 4 5 6 Last ] Next
You must be registered to post!