Quote from spikebaby
Quote from sandman1008
Quote from MewMan
Shawshank Redemption
Black Hawk Down, Saving Private Ryan,....
Anyone see
Inception? I read some comments saying that this movie has its story from
Paprika?
I saw Inception. I can't speak for Paprika, but supposedly, Christopher Nolan had been working on the script for 10 years, or something like that, and first pitched the idea to Warner Bros in 2001
The book Paprika was written in 1993 I believe. The movie was made 2006.
A lot of Nolan fans argue that he did not copy off Paprika, because he's been working on the script for apparently 10 years. He might have, or he might just be making it up. Even though they are both good movies in their own right, I believe he did copy off the movie, because quite a few scenes and motifs were the same. (ie, reality shattering like a mirror or glass)
A lot of Paprika fans think it's all ripped off, but Nolan did change the story and made an almost entirely different movie. Sadly know one will call him out for plaigirism because Paprika isn't that popular with Westerners compared to Ghibli films.
They're similar in their concepts, presentation, and some scenes, but Inception is more serious, and it's basically a heist movie or similar to one.
Well, all of those things you just listed means it's not plagiarism. Plagiarism is not simply the copying of an idea, but the copying of how an idea is presented. He may have copied the basic concept of Paprika, but he took the concept and did something almost entirely different (your words). That means it's not plagiarism.
And this is just my point of view, but I hate using the word "copying" for anything. Copying is made to imply the same thing as plagiarism. If you "copied" the other, I don't think it's copying at all. I think it's just inspiration. One person saw, or read, someone's idea and used that basic idea to create something original. Like how some people criticize The Rolling Stones for copying other people's music, when all they really did was take inspiration from others music to make their own. Maybe Nolan thought of the idea first, and Paprika took inspiration from it, or maybe it was the other way around. Or maybe two innovative minds thought of the idea on their own and we're drawing connections that don't exist.