Considering the votes.. it is unwise for people to jump to the conclusion that this is shoujo just because THEY feel like it is... as far as i see.. its almost 50 - 50 ... and its not like this is a MANGA its a MANHUA! just get the damn idea, there is no specific definition that says that it HAS to either shoujo or shounen. It can be both. Did you totally ignore what i wrote in my last reply? even forgetting the freaking action theres loads of things that qualify this as a shounen [shoujo also] - read what i write before. Btw just because it has prince, its shoujo? omg... so "Prince" of Tennis is shoujo too?

If you feel this is shoujo fine, just don't throw away new shounen readers who would have enjoyed this manga and thought it was shounen because you need to prove your point... As far as i can see the genres are there so people who pick up the new manga can understand what they get into. At the moment 14 shoujo; 22 shounen. There are many that feel this is shounen as well as many that think this is shoujo.. if you went and looked at a similar topic in mangafox about 62% thinks this is BOTH!! Stop being selfish and scaring away shounen readers by labelling it as shoujo just because "YOU" think so. Just leave the genre as they were without the damn shoujo / shounen tag


Last edited by noobzilla at 2:27 pm, May 9 2009

It is Shounen.
You guys should really learn what a demographic is...
It's based on the magazine it's serialized in, and it just happens that its magazine is a shounen magazine, therefore, it is shounen.
Just because it "feels" like shoujo doesn't mean it is.

________________
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ

I'll just say i agree with the above poster... i was reading tokyo innocent... it totally feels like a shoujo.. but its definately a shounen considering the growing feeling of a harem. It would be really nice if people stopped messing around with the genres, and leave the shoujo/ shounen out of the genre... I'm pretty sure its unclear

By the way Starlightdreams, whats the magazine called? [i am interested for reasons otehr than this genre crap]

Last edited by noobzilla at 2:24 pm, May 9 2009

exactly as what the person with lolita avatar said.

This is a manhua not a manga. Chinese comics aren't divided in the same demographics as Japanese ones:
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=11742&pa ge=1#post284758

Since there's no shoujo/shounen in manhua anyways, why not just leave it tagged as both? Doesn't do any harm and MU's policy doesn't require a single demographic, AFAIK.

Discussing whether this comic is shoujo or shounen is kinda pointless since you try to adapt Japanese terms on a Chinese media.

Last edited by eni at 2:28 pm, May 9 2009

________________
Sorry, I'm Late.
But I Got Lost On The Road Of Life.

<off-topic>Technically, every product on
the market has a demographic.</off-topic>

That's besides the point though, and I don't
know where I want to go with this. *leaves*

________________
source: animenewsnetwork

Join SRoMU Scanlations or visit #SRoMU at IRCHighWay.

i keep hearing about "oh this magazine is shounen" so its shounen, so which magazine is it? and where does it say its shounen? From what i heard, manhua's are't divided like that.
And art style? well art style nor bishounen mean a thing since the whole story is from a novel... the art was just the mangaka bringing the characters to life.

Some points from MF




Anyways ... leave the genre as it was before this topic was made... aka without shoujo or shounen; or just INCLUDE BOTH!. The story is from a novel and it says the following


If this isn't aiming for gender equality i don't know what is...

Last edited by noobzilla at 3:04 pm, May 9 2009

This was all said and explained in earlier posts.

The problem when you take out the demographics (shoujo, shounen) here at MU is, that the series won't be filtered. It won't pop up at all when I use the genre search with the shoujo/shounen terms to look for e.g. an adventure teenie manga.

Thus, although it's technically wrong to call this manhua a shoujo/shounen, will lead to the sad result that this series won't be found as often as demographically tagged manga. That's why I would recommend to tag it with both - shoujo and shounen - to have it found properly within the filter function of MU.

________________
Sorry, I'm Late.
But I Got Lost On The Road Of Life.

It's hardly believable to get the impression that Basara is a Shoujo Action. It's one of my most fav. manga to date!

But based on my general interests, I prefer Seinen romance than Josei/shoujo romance. But I GENERALLY avoid Seinen/Ecchi combo.

I usually read Historical/Sci-fic --> if combined with shoujo/Josei

Edit: ack crap! I thought this is a thread in the Manga discussion thread!! So it's all about 1/2 prince related discussion. xD;;; oh my.

Last edited by Hermit-chan at 3:02 pm, May 9 2009

________________

The Hidden Agenda=Gol.D.Ace

This Week's favourite:
DoLL (Okado Tatsuya)
Xp

Eni has a good point there... people who can't agree on this... can u please leave both genres on.. it won't hurt you. It will serve to bring in more readers. Ultimately better for you since more popularity = higher chance of animes, english license etc etc... i'd want my fav manhua to be known by more ppl, im sure you people do too..

As of right now, both "shonen" and "shoujo" are being used under the genre tags for this manhua. Leave it how it is guys, OK?

Also, since the artwork is a factor for some people wanting to label this series as shoujo, let me point out that ALL the other series that the artist, Choi Hong Chong has worked on prior to 1/2 Prince are martial arts action manhuas. In other words, stuff that would undoubtedly be labeled "shonen."

It doesn't make sense to have a shonen-only artist drawing a shoujo series unless the editors of the magazine 1/2 Prince appears in wanted a shonen demographic as well, now does it?

So the "shonen" label absolutely applies here. As does the "shoujo" label. So I repeat: keep both genre labels.

Alright, so I added both demographics to the genres area.
Someone put shoujo in there and not shounen with it.
And sorry for not knowing about Chinese manhua magazines, anyways, the magazine is Dragon Youth by the way.

And does it really matter?
No, it doesn't...


________________
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ

shoujo mode when feng lan in real world
and shounen mode when she in the game.

Both

Now go away

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants