banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

New Poll - Unrelated Series Oneshots

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar


5:42 pm, Jun 22 2019
Posts: 9912


This week's poll was suggested by juliarox214. You know how some series have a oneshot at the end of the volume that are totally unrelated to the main series itself? They might have unique characters, or it's just a previously published oneshot that they're packaging in this volume. What's your feeling about those?

You can submit poll ideas here
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=3903

Previous Poll Results:
Question: Humanity and/or the world is about to end. What is the cause?
Choices:
Rogue AI, robots, or other technological rampancy - votes: 144 (3.9%)
Global warming - votes: 752 (20.4%)
Zombies - votes: 74 (2%)
Alien or monster invasion - votes: 47 (1.3%)
Super virus, bacteria, or illness - votes: 302 (8.2%)
Eruption of super volcano - votes: 90 (2.4%)
Planet, moon, or meteor collides with Earth - votes: 101 (2.7%)
Nuclear war (i.e., we all kill each other) - votes: 900 (24.4%)
Black hole near Earth, Sun blows up, giant solar flare, or gamma-ray burst - votes: 128 (3.5%)
God - votes: 259 (7%)
Lack of resources or ecological disaster - votes: 810 (22%)
Intelligent animals - votes: 77 (2.1%)
There were 3684 total votes.
The poll ended: June 22nd 2019

I just finished watching the HBO Chernobyl show. If they hadn't gotten the divers to open the sluice gates to pump out the water, that would've been crazy...

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
Post #769944
Member

7:07 pm, Jun 22 2019
Posts: 337


No option for "no preference"/"don't particularly"?

Post #769946 - Reply to (#769944) by zarlan
user avatar
Member

9:12 pm, Jun 22 2019
Posts: 1010


Quote from zarlan
No option for "no preference"/"don't particularly"?

Ditto on this.

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT
 Member

10:09 am, Jun 23 2019
Posts: 2133


Yes, even if these are usually of middling quality. It´s interesting to read how an author started, as these tend to be earlier or debut works. Or even better, the original pilot chapters. Kenshin had 2 of those. Stuffing a volume with random crap to get to 180 or 200 pages sucks on the other hand.

________________
I also read EU/US comics and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists + Imdb
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

1:31 pm, Jun 23 2019
Posts: 549


I just hate not knowing that the oneshot is unrelated to the series. A lot of times I've read manga and think I have one more chapter left only to be disappointed that the chapter is completely unrelated to the original story.

user avatar
Member

8:07 pm, Jun 23 2019
Posts: 135


I read a lot of oneshots anyway... If I finished the series I probably like authors storytelling, so might as well read that oneshot...

________________
I am envoy from nowhere in nowhere. Nobody and nothing have sent me. And though it is impossible I exist. © Trimutius
user avatar
Member

5:13 am, Jun 24 2019
Posts: 585


I don't mind reading them. Though usually I'll read them after I've read the entire main series.

user avatar
Member

3:20 pm, Jun 24 2019
Posts: 403


Where's my "sometimes" option?

Post #769988
user avatar
Member

3:07 am, Jun 25 2019
Posts: 531


As a general rule if I like a series enough to read it I would be open to reading other stories from that mangaka, so sure, I like them.

Post #770027 - Reply to (#769955) by residentgrigo
Member

3:03 am, Jun 27 2019
Posts: 42


I voted No for this reason. I was thinking about Manga I've bought where there's only around 130 pages of the main story and then there is a sub-par oneshot added in at the end to reach the minimum page count. It feels like being ripped off. If it's at least related to the story somehow (prequel/side characters) or there's already 180 pages of the main title, I don't mind the oneshots.

You must be registered to post!