banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

New Poll - Colored Series Re-Release

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar


2:35 pm, Nov 2 2019
Posts: 9853


This week's poll was suggested by Nekomikoto. If they started releasing a color version of a series that you previously read and liked, would you read it? Personally, I don't have time for that...

You can submit poll ideas here
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=3903

Previous Poll Results:
Question: What would you consider to be "too many chapters" for a series you'd otherwise be interested in reading?
Choices:
There is no such thing as "too many" - votes: 1906 (44.4%)
1000 Chapters - votes: 621 (14.5%)
500 Chapters - votes: 567 (13.2%)
300 Chapters - votes: 713 (16.6%)
100 Chapters - votes: 246 (5.7%)
50 Chapters - votes: 100 (2.3%)
I prefer reading short series (so 25 chapters or less) - votes: 136 (3.2%)
There were 4289 total votes.
The poll ended: November 2nd 2019

Time is precious. And you can't spend all of it in manga

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT
 Member

3:03 pm, Nov 2 2019
Posts: 2108


Maybe when the full color version is completely released. The quality of the coloring is the key deciding factor for me and not the length but my interest in an unfinished new release is limited. That´s why I am waiting on the current From Hell colorization to finish to bring up a non-manga example and Japan is hardly the only country to do this. All sorts of comics that were colored before the standards rose in let´s say the mid to late 90s get facelifts. Sandman is a pretty famous example.

Marvel´s colorization of Akira is still the golden standard when it comes to full-color manga. Steve Oliff changed the industry with his endeavor.

________________
I also read EU/US comics and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists + Imdb
User Posted Image
Member

3:17 pm, Nov 2 2019
Posts: 116


No, that would be too much work. In my opinion, part of the enjoyment was choosing the colors for myself.

________________
Internet Lurker At Heart
Post #772731
user avatar
mmm...
 Member

3:34 pm, Nov 2 2019
Posts: 248


No.
I even rarely watch the anime unless the animation done by incredible studio like Madhouse or Ufotable mmm...

________________
I will change this world mmm...
So the world can change me mmm...
user avatar
Member

3:42 pm, Nov 2 2019
Posts: 971


No.
A lot of subtleties are lost when ANYTHING goes from monochrome to technicolor.

________________
User Posted Image
Post #772735
user avatar
Member

4:44 pm, Nov 2 2019
Posts: 520


No, colour doesn’t improve it IMO.

Post #772741
Member

9:31 pm, Nov 2 2019
Posts: 325


No. When something is originally made in black-and-white, colouring it will pretty much always result in nothing other than it looking terrible.

Last edited by zarlan at 9:36 pm, Nov 2

user avatar
Lone Wanderer
Member

6:49 am, Nov 3 2019
Posts: 2091


No. I have no interest in coloured manga in the first place.

________________
User Posted Image
Member

2:35 pm, Nov 4 2019
Posts: 29


Officially? Full color? I think that's very unlikely, at least i've never seen that happen.
Also i don't think it would add much unless the series was initially supposed to be in full color anyway. Adding flat colors to a perfectly fine B/W image doesn't do anything for me.

Member

5:59 pm, Nov 4 2019
Posts: 285


Quote
Time is precious. And you can't spend all of it in manga


YOU'RE LYING D:

But like actually, if it's good, and I notice, I have to read it 🙂 I don't really like hobby activities besides video games and manga, and reading manga is easier than playing video games 😛

Post #772780
Member

7:56 pm, Nov 4 2019
Posts: 101


I voted no, I'm more likely to reread the black and white than the color one

Post #772788
Member

6:01 am, Nov 5 2019
Posts: 423


Colorized stuff is usually bad.

Member

6:07 pm, Nov 5 2019
Posts: 45


Super tiny maybe, I'm not going to reread it if it's a few volumes. That alone can take a while to get recolored and if there are some changes it would take even longer to get edited and that is only if you are allowed to use existing translations. If it was a good 1 volume perhaps but for most not worth it.

Post #772857
Member

6:41 pm, Nov 10 2019
Posts: 144


depends on original art quality, genre and style
Some manga is originally released with incomplete art due to scheduling issues (i.e. Hunter x Hunter), or is released in black and white due to being published in black and white magazines despite actually having been drawn in full color.
Later re-release in color can thus bring forth something that has been missing.
Some genres (i.e. hentai) also can win quite a lot from being released with prettier full color art, while for others (i.e. some shoujo) it is not that important.

You must be registered to post!