manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
Try out our new iPhone application!
Manga Poll
New series you're trying. You dislike the story but like the characters. Continue reading?
Yes, the characters are more important to me
Stop reading, as this just ruins it for me
Unlikely, as I can't fully enjoy the series
I'll keep trying in hopes that the story improves
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates

RSS Feed
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Site Poll - Chat Box 64 - Many Groups, One Series

Back to Chatter Box

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Post #297961
user avatar

6:57 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 9129

So what's your view on tons of groups doing the same series? (typically with the shounen series...)

Question: Multiple groups scanlating the same series?
Good for different standards (speed, quality...) - votes: 2525 (21.5%)
Competition is always good - votes: 1077 (9.2%)
One group should be enough - votes: 865 (7.4%)
They should just combine their efforts - votes: 5077 (43.2%)
I don't care, just give me manga - votes: 2205 (18.8%)
There were 11749 total votes.
The poll ended: June 20th 2009

Last edited by lambchopsil at 2:57 pm, Jun 20

A just ruler amongst tyrants
Post #297963
user avatar

6:59 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 3342

Competition brings the best out of everyone.

Collaborative efforts are beneficial... but having 100 people doing the same thing is just gonna be a mess.
Especially if its non-profit.

"“That's the difference between me and the rest of the world!
Happiness isn't good enough for me! I demand euphoria!” "
Post #297964
user avatar
Mad With a Hat

6:59 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 4767

I think they should go work on other stuff...

They usually go for speed over quality.
Then they release more versions...
Quite pointless I think.

And while they do that, there are many titles that are just pushed aside since they're less popular.
Other manga just wait unscanlated... Why not work on those?

Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
User Posted Image
And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.

Click 'n Play!

If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.
Post #297965
user avatar

7:02 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 1705

I chose Competition is Always a Good Thing... bigrazz

I mean, I hate to use this an example, but it was obvious that was the main force driving groups like The Little Corner and the 1/2 Prince releases... -_-;;

User Posted Image
Post #297966
user avatar

7:04 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 3503

I think it's good for different standards, but I guess it's somehow a complex matter.

This week's favorites:

- Golden Kamui

ççççççç[Ô .Ô] tsutopodus© will eat your manga and steal your cats!
Rainy Days
Post #297967 - Reply to (#297964) by NightSwan
user avatar
it's a boy

7:04 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 2954

Waste of time, really.
You might argue the difference of qualities.
But, just look at Naruto.
It's too much.

Oh, and this.
Quote from NightSwan
I think they should go work on other stuff...

Post #297968

7:04 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 1764

I think it's good for different standards. As long as no more than two or three groups are doing them and it's a popular manga. Any more than that, it's ridiculous and a waste of effort.

Post #297970
user avatar

7:09 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 1977

there are so many other series that are waiting to be scanlated.why not work on those instead of fuzzing over one?

but a little competition ain't that bad bigrazz
and i'm emphasizing 'a little'

Last edited by Yenoh at 7:24 pm, Jun 13

Post #297973
user avatar

7:22 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 105

I voted that i don't care, as long as i get to read i'm cool.

Anyway, there is so much manga out there not being scanlated that are good, it makes me really sad. There is like 20 groups doing Naruto alone, why the hell do we need so many? Groups who are doing the same series should just take up other projects that are not getting any love, the community would be better for it. biggrin

Everything has a price.
Post #297976

7:45 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 122

Here are opinions of some scanlators/translators:

1. Question 6 from
2. Question 6 from
3. Question 6 from
4. Question 6 from
5. Question 6 from
6. Question 8 from
7. Question 7 from
though not entirely related
8. Question 6 from

(Seems like a regular question in MH interviews)

Most of scanlators seem to support the idea of joining efforts.

Identity Crisis
Post #297981
user avatar
Somewhat dead
Super Mod

8:07 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 4915

Working together is nice, but as Caliber said, its not gonna work with alot of people on the same thing.

So instead of working on the same project, why not just branch out?

Post #298003

9:11 pm, Jun 13 2009
Posts: 5

Working together is good as long they dont repeat scantalations that have already been done. I think it just waste their efforts to do so.

Post #298085
user avatar

2:26 am, Jun 14 2009
Posts: 7777

Waste of resources.
It's not like scanlations have
any novelty value. Scanlate
stuff that hasn't been scanlated or
join forces to get the shit done faster.
Nobody rememebers who scanlated
chapter 47.

Post #298119

5:18 am, Jun 14 2009
Posts: 11

I'd rather see that one group is for me I don't really care that much about the quality, as long as I can get the story in my head it doesn't matter, and there's so many good manga out there having no scans, kinda surprises me when you see 20 groups doing the same manga, like, what's the point?

Post #298139 - Reply to (#297965) by CatzCradle
user avatar

6:13 am, Jun 14 2009
Posts: 267

Quote from CatzCradle
I chose Competition is Always a Good Thing... bigrazz

I mean, I hate to use this an example, but it was obvious that was the main force driving groups like The Little Corner and the 1/2 Prince releases... -_-;;

You... <_< Since i bought those raws and was involved in every release... ;O I'd have to say i know a bit more about what was going on with those two groups.We released it fast out of annoyance(from various sources) and to get rid of the raws. Also, those raws weren't bought till around mid January, so it's not as if we were delaying the series on purpose ;(

Competition, really? Multiple groups doing the same project is just plain retarded. Spending time on a release just for someone else to spam one isn't good for anyone involved. Competition is good for the economy, but for scanlators who spend valuable time for greedy people who need their "fix"... gtfo~ We don't get paid, practically no love and at most a "Good job, keep up the good work"; which by the way, is amazingly annoying.

I don't think any respectable group or scanlator supports multiple same chapter releases. On that same token, no respectable group or scanlator will do that on their own after someone has started it.

This is all volunteer work for fans by fans. If the people involved actually cared they'd help each other out to speed up releases.

Remind me to smack the person who linked this post. Can't stop the urge to respond to these things and have other things to do... like preparing my mass release <_<;

Final Rant/My pick:
Combine efforts if there are a lot of chapters left and the group is going slow. Usually there is a reason for it, though it seems new "groups" and leechers don't care.

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Chatter Box  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
Manga Search