banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Is it okay to add scott pilgrim graphic novelsi nthis website

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #791053
Member

10:35 am, Jun 5 2021
Posts: 17


Since avatar the last airbender graphic novels,the Norwegian graphic novels like Nordlys have been added to mangaupdate is it time to add the Scott Pilgrim graphic novels in this website since it's influenced from shonen manga along with fighting video games form the 90s including Goldie Vance and other western webtoons?

https://onipress.com/collections/scott-pilgrim

Post #791058
Member

3:42 pm, Jun 5 2021
Posts: 6


Even on the website you linked it refers to it as a graphic novel so probably not. When it came out it was marketed as a comic if I recall, not "manga" or oel or "amerimanga" etc, in my opinion it has no business being added to this website no matter whatever influences there are.

Post #791081
Member

12:11 pm, Jun 6 2021
Posts: 17


Yeah, why they include avatar the airbender graphic novels in this site if they are not ,"manga" or oel or "amerimanga especially those Norwegian graphic novels

Post #791086 - Reply to (#791081) by trover2345325
Member

7:41 pm, Jun 6 2021
Posts: 6


Avatar was marketed as manga when it came out through Tokyopop. I don't get why this is such a difficult thing to understand. I don't know Nordic but my searches really don't bring back much besides the literal description for the company in mangaupdates, so perhaps the amount of Nordic manga is suspect especially since its 2018+. Nowhere can I find on the company's website that they consider or are trying to appeal to the same kind of people that buy manga etc.

Post #791139
Member

4:45 pm, Jun 8 2021
Posts: 17


Good point, I suggest we tell the administrators to remove the Norwegian graphic novels from the site including the avatar books that doesn't come from tokyopop

You must be registered to post!