banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Why the heck is Kimi ni todoke on top??

Pages (4) [ 1 2 3 4 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #337984
Member

8:42 pm, Nov 27 2009
Posts: 165


So I've been noticing for the past few weeks that KNT has been in the top ten... but why?? It's just another regular girl loves beautiful boy shoujo.. is it coz of the anime which is airing ?

Post #337986
user avatar
Hime-chan~♥
Member

8:52 pm, Nov 27 2009
Posts: 672


Why shouldn't it be on top? I mean, it's not even as cliche as you make it out to be. Kazehaya is a normal, but popular boy. He's not the sparkly bishounen you find in most shoujo cliche's.

I for one am very glad that it is in the top ten. A somewhat refreshing yet adorable heroine is what every shoujo fanatic needs.

The anime is another thing. I find it quite lovely, especially since there's motion and sound.

________________
User Posted Image

*__* I'll have what she's having... please~♥
Post #337987
user avatar
Member

8:59 pm, Nov 27 2009
Posts: 50


It is probably because of the anime that is out and people who were watching the anime decided to pick up the manga.
[" looks at self"]

Personally have no problem with it being in the top 10, I been pleasantly surprised by the anime and it's charm and reading the manga hasn't been a disappointment either.

________________
"I came to laugh at you!" - Chars Aznabal
Post #337988
user avatar
Narutos my Nympho.
Member

9:36 pm, Nov 27 2009
Posts: 496


its kinda like this years "the wallflower".

the animation in the anime is really nice.

________________
User Posted Image
Post #337996
user avatar
Member

10:29 pm, Nov 27 2009
Posts: 2964


In shoujo terms, it's not a bad series.

Post #338002
user avatar
Sorinozuka
Member

10:45 pm, Nov 27 2009
Posts: 321


Kimi ni Todoke is actually very cliche, and it's very shoujo.

But it's a refreshing series, and I do know for a fact that most who read shoujo mangas really like KnT especially now that an anime is airing.

Post #338044 - Reply to (#338002) by ---nica
user avatar
Mome Basher
Member

1:50 am, Nov 28 2009
Posts: 3380


Quote from niiica
Kimi ni Todoke is actually very cliche, and it's very shoujo.

But it's a refreshing series, and I do know for a fact that most who read shoujo mangas really like KnT especially now that an anime is airing.

Heh, I dunno, I read many shoujo's and I don't find it to be very cliché :\

The anime is brilliant, so it's probably attracting some manga attention as well...and by the looks of it, a whole lot of attention laugh

And btw, yuri999, Kimi ni Todoke is not "another regular girl loves beautiful boy shoujo". Sawako isn't really in love with Shouta at the start. Saying that would imply that she was going for him way at the start - which she didn't. She only admired him for being able to socialize well. She only realizes that she likes him later on.

________________
User Posted Image
Everyday I'm tumblin'
Post #338046
user avatar
Lowly Member
Member

2:11 am, Nov 28 2009
Posts: 3888


When you look at it from the outside, it's really cliche.
But once you read it, it has a lot of differences from normal shoujo manga.
First of all, the heroine isn't that pretty. No, we're not talking about the ridiculously cute shoujo heroine who thinks she's ugly.
This heroine actually tries to change and has CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT.
The main guy character is not some little prince bad boy either, like most shoujo manga. He's a nice guy who actually does like the girl.
It's been what, 6 volumes? They're still not together yet. That is amazingly different in itself. laugh
So you can say that it has a cliche story, but the way it's being told and developed isn't.
It's a good manga.

________________
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ
Post #338065
user avatar
Member

3:43 am, Nov 28 2009
Posts: 79


its at the top because up until about a month ago when the anime came out, there had been no groups actively scanning it.

thus as the anime came out there was a bigger demand for it, so it road that wave and more people became interested in the manga aswell

________________
“The ability to speak does not make you intelligent.”
-Qui-Gon Jinn
Post #338074 - Reply to (#338044) by Scyfon
user avatar
Sorinozuka
Member

4:22 am, Nov 28 2009
Posts: 321


Quote from Scyfon
Quote from niiica
Kimi ni Todoke is actually very cliche, and it's very shoujo.

But it's a refreshing series, and I do know for a fact that most who read shoujo mangas really like KnT especially now that an anime is airing.

Heh, I dunno, I read many shoujo's and I don't find it to be very cliché :\

The anime is brilliant, so it's probably attracting some manga attention as well...and by the looks of it, a whole lot of attention laugh

And btw, yuri999, Kimi ni Todoke is not "another regular girl loves beautiful boy shoujo". Sawako isn't really in love with Shouta at the start. Saying that would imply that she was going for him way at the start - which she didn't. She only admired him for being able to socialize well. She only realizes that she likes him later on.


I guess not. eyes

But I really do find the series to be very nice, I've only read to about... uhm, volume 7? And keeps on getting interesting by the volume. laugh

Didn't Fateful Encounters (now Loyal Kiss) release KnT? I mean, yeah... they didn't release every week, but at least they did it with not that long of a gap.

Post #338184
user avatar
Member

6:37 pm, Nov 28 2009
Posts: 79


FE didnt pick it up til about summer 09 which was when it was announced that it would be an anime in the fall 09, (at which point i had been missing for nearly a year since fall 08)

________________
“The ability to speak does not make you intelligent.”
-Qui-Gon Jinn
Post #338422
Member

8:48 pm, Nov 29 2009
Posts: 13


So what if it's a regular girl likes boy story?
So what if it's cliche?

Do those matter if you enjoy reading/watching it?
I think people here are making too much of a fuss.

Take for example, Gundam SEED and Code Geass. Uses a lot of similar themes:

-mecha
-rebellion and war
-friends on opposing factions.
-female leads that have a high social status
-the male leads have some sort of power.
-and the list goes on

Despite of these cliches. Although Code Geass uses a lot of cliche's, it's the way that Code Geass is told that makes it great.

Post #338489 - Reply to (#338065) by Zaub
user avatar
forum bunny
Member

4:48 am, Nov 30 2009
Posts: 510


Quote from Zaub
its at the top because up until about a month ago when the anime came out, there had been no groups actively scanning it.

I think a big part of the reason was 'cause the groups that had been scanning it (entropy and dragon voice) dropped it 'cause it got licensed, and nobody wanted to delve into that.

I agree with everyone else: the really solid development beats out the cliches, which are only problematic when the author tries to make them (instead of character development and plot) the driving force in the story.

Post #340417
user avatar
Member

5:32 am, Dec 8 2009
Posts: 323


Kimi Ni Todoke is a pretty amazing story imo. I guess it's the simpleness, the character designs and the art that put me at calm. I really enjoy reading the series. It's very soothing.

Kimi Ni Todoke is really better than normal girl meets boys series. It won the Best Shōjo Manga award in the 32nd Annual Kodansha Manga Award and was nominated for the first Manga Taisho awards in 2008. It is also one of the top series people want to be seen made into a drama. Maybe the western audience has caught on? But I actually thought it was pretty popular before. It just wasn't being updated as often.

________________
Go confidently in the direction of your dreams. Live the life you have imagined. ~ Thoreau


whatphotoshopmypicswhatliesdoyouspeakof?! >D
Post #350113
user avatar
Member

1:34 am, Jan 17 2010
Posts: 58


I agree that the simplicity of the story and the story itself keeps it on top. I didn't expect to like it after expecting the cliches but I really do. Someone else said relaxing, I agree. I think it's because everyone can relate to the characters

________________
"I love you like the plant that never blooms yet carries in itself the light of hidden flowers.
I love you as certain dark things are to be loved, in secret, between the shadow and the soul" - Sonnet XVII
Pages (4) [ 1 2 3 4 ] Next
You must be registered to post!