manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
Try out our new iPhone application!
Manga Poll
Will the loss of Batoto affect your manga habits?
Yes, huge problems now
Yes, but it's not too bad
Just a little
Nope, nothing changes for me
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates

RSS Feed
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Why are most American Popular Shounen so LONG?

Back to Shounen/Seinen

Pages (5) [ First ... 2 3 4 5 ]   You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Post #496659
user avatar

9:17 pm, Sep 17 2011
Posts: 298

InuYasha, Bleach, Dragonball Z, etc. are not American... Though I see where you're coming from.

The days that 'shounen' was something for boys and 'shoujo' something for girls are long gone.
Gender roles are becoming less apparent and the gender divides with it also. I have no qualms (now or in my youth) about watching TV show that are quite obviously mainly targeted at females and actually enjoy it more than shows that are (obviously) mainly targeted at males... I'm not alone in this (though 15-20 years ago it was still something you didn't say aloud).

Shounen is, in my opinion, just a label you put on a story when it matches certain format/publishing conditions (or to be more precise, every story that gets published in a 'shounen magazine' is automatically shounen).
Example: Yotsubato!. Definitely not a manga targeted at a male audience exclusively.
Who decides this? I don't know and I don't care. Don't judge manga by labels someone else put on it, at least look at the content.

That's the 'shounen' bit, now for the 'long' bit:
As said before, MONEY.
Superhero/Action content lends itself especially well to episodic design and copy-paste villains and scenarios.
Something that is harder to do (but not proven to be impossible) when you want to do this with a story that is driven by actual plot. This gets very old very fast and it's hard to keep the story going (and interesting)... Without falling back to senseless 'filler/side' stories that often makes you lose interest even more (or makes you forget what the actual story was about).

The real question is not why they are long, but why they are so popular?... and not by a small margin.
Something I, never having liked any of the mentioned shows, really can't understand.

Who they, what are, and why?
- Manga Cover Database -
Post #496660
user avatar
Ginga Bishounen

9:52 pm, Sep 17 2011
Posts: 380

Money basically, lol laugh

User Posted Image
Quote from Akamatsu Ken
True magic Results From Courage Of The Heart
Boys And Girls Be Ambitious
One Step Can Change The World
Post #496670
user avatar
The Shorty

10:39 pm, Sep 17 2011
Posts: 330

the reason why american popular shounen is so long because if it wasn't popular, would it be long at all? laugh

Post #497414
user avatar

4:58 pm, Sep 22 2011
Posts: 131

In my opinion, this thread should be in the shojo/josei section with the question, "why are shojos shorter than shonens?"
simply because they would know better as to why they'd like shorter series
for shonen, it's as people have said: a series can go on for as long as it can keep bringing good ratings
though there should also be long shojos, I just don't know where they are

User Posted Image

My all time favorite manga:
Post #519189

5:47 pm, Jan 25 2012
Posts: 180

There are obviously shorter shounen stories. Most robot shows only went upto the 50-60 episode count because their anime. There's also relationship and slice of life stuff, like Suzuka was pretty short ect.

This is about the type of story, and the type of medium. Adaptations of Manga are long because manga's are long running, and they have to have filler so they don't overtake it.

But action shows tend to be longer because you have two things to do. The drama of the conflict and relationships/human drama.

Sailor Moon was very long running because it was adapted from a manga and an action show. See, it's pretty simple.

Post #519195
user avatar

7:15 pm, Jan 25 2012
Posts: 166

Shoujo mostly romance, and if romance goes so long...
OMG why don't you just read Twilight? *just kidding*

That's for myself, shounen goes so long because the characters have something to achieve, and It's something that really need efforts, sweat, blood, blahblahblah.
For shoujo, mostly they search for... The ONE?
and if it took dozens of volumes (for me, maybe more than 10), IMO, the main female will start to look like a drama queen or worst, whore.

For example: (cynical, sorry, since I prefer shounen than shoujo. )
Shounen: One Piece
Luffy, a boy in an island, wants to be The King of Pirates, and sure, it's NOT EASY.
Understandable why It'll took dozens of volumes.
Shoujo: Parfait Tic
Fuuko had to choose: Ichi or Daiya. And it took 22 volumes to decide that.
For me, that's an EPIC LOOOOOL.
(Sorry for bad example, search your own example)

But not all shoujo like that, I love shoujo where the main chara's life is about something other than just get bf. But since they're shoujo, the romance is fully treated. I like it.
Maybe like: Basara, 7 Seeds, (Tamura Yumi rocks!)
Same case for shounen manga where the mangaka is female, the romance is fully treated.
Maybe like: Erementar Gerad, Youko x Boku SS

btw, if you wonder why one piece, naruto, etc took so long, try read Bakuman.
yeaaa this is the main reason:
Quote from Masterba
the reason why american popular shounen is so long because if it wasn't popular, would it be long at all? laugh

Quote from Alexyz0
Money basically, lol laugh

Last edited by monkry at 7:27 pm, Jan 25

User Posted Image
Post #519254
user avatar

3:08 am, Jan 26 2012
Posts: 838

if a series is long it got nothing to do with being popular in america... its long because ITS popular in japan biggrin well maybe bleach its still running because its popular in america...

Post #519259
user avatar

3:46 am, Jan 26 2012
Posts: 717

Cause thats all US will ever publish?

Is this me in a nutshell?
Pretty much.
User Posted Image
Post #519260
user avatar

3:49 am, Jan 26 2012
Posts: 46

well it was popular in japan first so they send it over here so others can buy and read the manga, its always a lot slower to publish here as well ._ this is true with almost all manga series.

just living my life like any teenager would, facing the world, dealing with all the things that come at me. im not the special yet not that all normal, just somewhere in the middle ground :3.
Post #526904
user avatar
✯ Sarcastic

4:16 am, Mar 2 2012
Posts: 597

There is only so much story material for the 'He loves me, he loves me not . . .' types of manga.

User Posted Image
Pages (5) [ First ... 2 3 4 5 ]   You must be registered to post!

Back to Shounen/Seinen  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
Manga Search