It's a bit sad. I expected more from her manga. Somehow, she remind me of the author of GTO, always great and unique art, humorous, ecchi, but after giving their best manga they keep failing in the way to find another decent story.
________________
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Forums
Ane Doki ending with chapter 26
From User
Message Body
Member
3:52 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 151
She manage to put a fine ending... again.
It's a bit sad. I expected more from her manga. Somehow, she remind me of the author of GTO, always great and unique art, humorous, ecchi, but after giving their best manga they keep failing in the way to find another decent story.
________________
It's a bit sad. I expected more from her manga. Somehow, she remind me of the author of GTO, always great and unique art, humorous, ecchi, but after giving their best manga they keep failing in the way to find another decent story.
________________
Ojiisan
Member
4:45 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 85
Thats what I call a good ending.
My first thought when it was over, was "Hey, this actually got a pretty good chance to do a sequel"
The background story is there, a sequel that takes place a few years later would be pretty good.
In my opinion anyways
My first thought when it was over, was "Hey, this actually got a pretty good chance to do a sequel"
The background story is there, a sequel that takes place a few years later would be pretty good.
In my opinion anyways
Digital Wraith
Member
5:02 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 86
Member
5:02 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 86
I'm kinda hoping she takes it to another magazine and makes a sequel as well. If she tried for a sequel in her current magazine, it would be cut short again. I honestly thought we would get at least 30 chapters, but it ended well enough.
I'm happy with this story's ending, sort of. I honestly hate it when they make characters who are deeper and better constructed and hook the guy up with a character that has less to them just because they started in on the male character, a sadly overused idea in romance manga. I don't like the 1st girl gets the guy thing. I know this author made a few characters before that I liked better than the main girl, like some of the characters in Ichigo 100%.
________________
Never doubt your reasons.
Never doubt your cause.
-me
I'm happy with this story's ending, sort of. I honestly hate it when they make characters who are deeper and better constructed and hook the guy up with a character that has less to them just because they started in on the male character, a sadly overused idea in romance manga. I don't like the 1st girl gets the guy thing. I know this author made a few characters before that I liked better than the main girl, like some of the characters in Ichigo 100%.
________________
Never doubt your reasons.
Never doubt your cause.
-me
Mome Basher
Member
5:10 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 3380
Quote from KazukiNezan
I'm kinda hoping she takes it to another magazine and makes a sequel as well. If she tried for a sequel in her current magazine, it would be cut short again. I honestly thought we would get at least 30 chapters, but it ended well enough.
She mostly likely cannot.
Well...not outside Jump at least..due to contract(s)
________________
Everyday I'm tumblin'
Member
7:27 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 169
This is why I hate ranking...
yeah, although the story messes up in the middle part, but still, if we'll look at Ichigo 100%, it also "somewhat" messes up in the middle part..
Just try to look at it, there's a lot of manga offered by WSJ, so why not change the rank settings, instead of the constant top 5, why not make it into to, say, top 8?
But still, the art work is good... hopefully she'll have a better shot in her next series, whatever it will be.
support the mangaka.. if there's a manga available in your place, buy it. it's one way of showing our appreciation..
________________
Ras tel ma scir magister Veniant Spiritus Aeriales Fulgurientes!! Cum Fulguratione Flet Tempestas Austrina, Jovis Tempestas Fulguriens!!!
yeah, although the story messes up in the middle part, but still, if we'll look at Ichigo 100%, it also "somewhat" messes up in the middle part..
Just try to look at it, there's a lot of manga offered by WSJ, so why not change the rank settings, instead of the constant top 5, why not make it into to, say, top 8?
But still, the art work is good... hopefully she'll have a better shot in her next series, whatever it will be.
support the mangaka.. if there's a manga available in your place, buy it. it's one way of showing our appreciation..
________________
Ras tel ma scir magister Veniant Spiritus Aeriales Fulgurientes!! Cum Fulguratione Flet Tempestas Austrina, Jovis Tempestas Fulguriens!!!
Is a female
Member9:27 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 3457
That ending was actually pretty decent for a discontinued manga.
And no. No sequels. I think leaving it like that is fine.
Besides, the reason this was left like it was because it got discontinued. You can't be expecting a sequel when the manga was ditched
And no. No sequels. I think leaving it like that is fine.
Besides, the reason this was left like it was because it got discontinued. You can't be expecting a sequel when the manga was ditched
Member
6:23 pm, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 66
except for ichigo 100% all other mangas from her were discontinued, she could start writing for another magazine, one that accept more ecchi stuff
Last edited by tricki at 8:04 pm, Jan 15 2010
Last edited by tricki at 8:04 pm, Jan 15 2010
Member
7:58 am, Jan 16 2010
Posts: 112
7:58 am, Jan 16 2010
Posts: 112
See I liked how Ichigo 100% ended, it gave my the form of closure I so greatly desire (a guy and girl getting together or shows their future selves). This was a let down, but I still liked the story in general. Hopefully something better will come along ^^
Member
11:46 am, Jan 16 2010
Posts: 6
I want a sequel. 
If she could come up with a great story like, "4 years later", it could turn out pretty awesome, WITH a good story of course. Really, this is sad. It was actually my fav manga. Ugh. >_>
If she could come up with a great story like, "4 years later", it could turn out pretty awesome, WITH a good story of course. Really, this is sad. It was actually my fav manga. Ugh. >_>
Member
11:55 am, Jan 16 2010
Posts: 8
agreed with last post, even a one chapter epilogue is good. Sadly some of the my most favorite manga have endings like this.... if only they would add an epilogue to conclude it so the readers would have a feeling of closing or better satisfaction
________________
guitarist for band "Bucket of Sushi" =D
________________
guitarist for band "Bucket of Sushi" =D
Is a female
Member12:09 pm, Jan 16 2010
Posts: 3457
Quote from mehrik
if only they would add an epilogue to conclude it so the readers would have a feeling of closing or better satisfaction
If it wasn't discontinued, I'm pretty sure she would have done one.
Member
5:30 pm, Jan 16 2010
Posts: 1
5:30 pm, Jan 16 2010
Posts: 1
I really hoped that the ending was gonna be a bit longer than that - during the middle it was getting a bit dull - but toward the latter part THAT'S when the stories are about to progress and BAM cut down short
SEQUELS !!!!
SEQUELS !!!!
Member
4:02 pm, Jan 17 2010
Posts: 7
4:02 pm, Jan 17 2010
Posts: 7
Nah... she can always come back with Ane-doki 2... or i hope she will.
Before i heard that Ane-doki got an ace, i didn't really understand why Bukuman mangakas are crying about the ranking system... guess now i do...
Before i heard that Ane-doki got an ace, i didn't really understand why Bukuman mangakas are crying about the ranking system... guess now i do...
Member
5:29 pm, Aug 6 2010
Posts: 4
Sequels are for losers. That's what makes manga so special, the open-endings. At that point, you start to think what would happen next. Even now, with this glorious 4 pages sequel, it's still open. Thanks Kawashita-sensei!
