Quote
That's actually an interesting one. I read an article on women portrayed in comics and often people expect men only to accept male heros while women are expected to accept male heros and female heros.
Actually the recent trend is the opposite - a lot of popular series with a main female cast are made for the male audience (K-ON!, Hanasaku Iroha, Puella Magi Madoka Magica anime).
OK, some of these series can get a few female fans as long as they don't focus on the moe/ecchi too much. But I suspect there are far fewer males who would be interested in the recent fantasy shoujo with a main male cast because they usually have too much fangirl/fujoshi pandering to attract the male audience.
The reasons I don't read shoujo are:
1. The art. A lot of shoujo artists have art similar to each other. And their drawings usually lack details/skills, can look messy, lazy and weirdly proportioned. For good or at least acceptable (mainstream-y) art, I would give one example: Another. The mangaka is female. Nakamura Asumiko has good (non-mianstream) shoujo art which I quite like.
2. I am usually not interested in stories about highschool romance (I am more interested in adult romance/lifestyles). Being long definitely wouldn't help. Long manga always made me lose interest.
I find American teen TV-dramas/movies are just as boring though they are significantly different from shoujo manga given the huge cultural difference between Japan and the West.
3. Most shoujo romances and their characters/interactions/bahaviour are just too unrealistic and cliched. I knew Boys over Flowers and Fushigi Yuugi in middle school, which was like more than 15 years ago, and already found them annoying. Today I still think stories and characters like those (male and female) are boring or annoying. I am not the type who demands that main character has to be "strong". I would be more happy to read about realistic, well-developed, meaningful and consistent characters (including side ones), weak or strong.
Some shoujo are OK and readable though (in my case, they are always shorter manga). But after a while, their romance stories are too similar. You read one or two and the rest will be similar. Why should I read more then?
Of course I have a few favorite shoujo series. I am sure anyone can find something they like in shoujo if they look hard enough and don't pay too much attention to the most popular ones.
BTW, something like Maid-sama! or Ouran Host Club is definitely not my cup of tea. But I've seen more than a few of their male fans on the internet, esp. for their anime. I guess tastes differ greatly no matter you are male or female.
Last edited by coffee_11 at 9:59 am, Jun 22 2012