banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

What Do You Think Of It?

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #576067
user avatar
Member

5:47 pm, Nov 5 2012
Posts: 1051


I'm still a bit curious as to how closely the Japanese will follow the series. If they don't really follow the main storyline, I hope they that do side stories instead like they did with the Eureka comic or volume 2 of the Batman Beyond comics. The art style will take a little bit of getting used to though as well.

Anybody else still waiting for Season 3 of the show?

Last edited by Transdude1996 at 5:55 pm, Nov 5

________________
User Posted Image
Post #576068
Member

5:48 pm, Nov 5 2012
Posts: 262


I'm [im]patiently waiting, although I don't believe I will try reading this.... Looks............. Yeah, I'm not going to read this probably.. xD

________________
Earn Gift Cards for Wii, PSN, XBL, LoL, and more.
My lists are a mess, and most aren't public, and the public ones are still being updated.
(╯°□°)╯︵ (.□. \)
"Hindsight is fifty-fifty"
Post #576071
user avatar
Member

6:39 pm, Nov 5 2012
Posts: 641


This seems alrite, but then again I've already seen the actual show, so this is a rather big step down when you compare the two different mediums.
Not to mention it's kinda sucky when you already know the answer to the mystery too, so I'm not a huge fan of this adaptation right off the bat because the first arc is exactly the same as the first episode "A study in pink".

Would appreciate if they branch out into the cases they didn't tell in the TV series, there were a lot of cases they just skipped by in the show that I wouldn't mind reading it in this form.

They did capture Benedict Cumberbatch quite well I must say, although Martin Freeman's Watson's completely weird looking and inconsistent throughout the first chapter...

I'll have to wait until they do something different before this can be sorted into either my keep or leave lists, the show has done quite a fantastic job of this iteration already so seeing it on ink in exact replica form is a bit unimpressive.

Still waiting on Season 3 for sure, definitely looking forward to how they're going to continue the series.



________________
User Posted ImageUser Posted Image
Post #576072 - Reply to (#576071) by greydrak
user avatar
Member

6:55 pm, Nov 5 2012
Posts: 920


It was all a dream! Or maybe he wakes up in a fictional world! Well lets just say there are a lot of ways to bullshit ones way out of things -_-

Post #576910
user avatar
Member

10:26 pm, Nov 13 2012
Posts: 1


Since the manga is presently called Sherlock A Study in Pink I'm guessing that it's going to be pretty much the first episode of the show in manga form.

Post #576912 - Reply to (#576071) by greydrak
Member

10:33 pm, Nov 13 2012
Posts: 262


Well, after killing off Sherlocke Doyle actually brought him back to life because he was so popular.. So it's not hard.. It's not like he actually died at the end of the series, it's just the majority of the world thought he did..

He could disappear into another country and continue his work there or something..

Quote from Kaitentsuki
It was all a dream! Or maybe he wakes up in a fictional world! Well lets just say there are a lot of ways to bullshit ones way out of things -_-

There is no need for a "bullshit way" out of it honestly.. Lol.. And because of the writers involved, I highly doubt it'd be a dream or anything like that..

________________
Earn Gift Cards for Wii, PSN, XBL, LoL, and more.
My lists are a mess, and most aren't public, and the public ones are still being updated.
(╯°□°)╯︵ (.□. \)
"Hindsight is fifty-fifty"
Post #591149
Member

4:59 am, Mar 17 2013
Posts: 1


I think this is sooooo stupid on many levels. I mean, i love SH and all, but writing a manga based on a tv series, which is based on a novel? So do you even have any ounce of imagination and creativity at all? even the drawing is a total rip off from the movie. Gosh, this totally ruins my day

Post #591151 - Reply to (#591149) by svazt
user avatar
Member

5:12 am, Mar 17 2013
Posts: 1705


Quote from svazt
I think this is sooooo stupid on many levels. I mean, i love SH and all, but writing a manga based on a tv series, which is based on a novel? So do you even have any ounce of imagination and creativity at all? even the drawing is a total rip off from the movie. Gosh, this totally ruins my day


I don't think it's stupid at all. There's been worse manga adapations made.

I'm not sure myself, but maybe it was made into manga form so people in Japan would be able to appreciate the TV version?

________________
User Posted Image
You must be registered to post!