banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

New Poll - Native Language

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ]  
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #650754 - Reply to (#650719) by Xeronia
Member

12:38 pm, Aug 27 2014
Posts: 439


Quote from Xeronia
What do you do if you're natively bilingual? I'm Chinese-American. Although the English is obviously better (even though the Chinese came first), I've been speaking both without much thought most of my life.

Then they are both your native languages, as far as I'm concerned.
There is no option for that, so I'd suggest answering "other", like I did.

Last edited by zarlan at 1:03 pm, Aug 27 2014

Post #650755 - Reply to (#650733) by Sylar
Member

12:49 pm, Aug 27 2014
Posts: 439


Quote from Sylar
Both languages belong to the same family (Latin languages) but no, they are not the same. It looks like a mix of French and Spanish (and also Italian i think) but it's really a language on its own, not a dialect of Spanish/French.

Certainly Catalan and Spanish are both Romance languages, and more specifically Western Romance languages, but...
Catalan is either part of the Occitano-Romance languages, or part of the Ibero-Romance languages.

For more info:
Wikipedia - Catalan language#Classification and relationship with other Romance languages

Last edited by zarlan at 1:05 pm, Aug 27 2014

Post #650756 - Reply to (#650524) by zarlan
Member

12:50 pm, Aug 27 2014
Posts: 354


Fair enough. I've learned something new. People don't think primarily in one language. Thank you for my newly acquired education.

It appears that I should have voted other then based on various posts.

Post #650761 - Reply to (#650756) by mysstris
Member

1:02 pm, Aug 27 2014
Posts: 439


Quote from mysstris
People don't think primarily in one language.


Well you do if you're not competent (maybe fluent? Might depend on the person) in more than one language, of course, but otherwise you don't, AFAIK.

Quote
As for the native language definition, it seems to me that I'm not the only one to have answered the poll based on their personal interpretation of what "native language" is.

That is pretty much to be expected.
Unless you first present a clear definition of what is meant by "native language", for the purposes of the poll, you'll get some differing interpretations of the term.
It's not quite perfectly clear, and there are differing opinions. Even with the definitions I've posted, those could be interpreted in significantly different ways. It would, e.g., change which language(s) are my native ones.
I strongly feel that it should be defined one way, but there are not unreasonable arguments that can be made for other interpretations...

Well, the poll does ask "What would you consider to be", so I guess it's kinda appropriate wink

Last edited by zarlan at 1:17 pm, Aug 27 2014

user avatar
Pro-crastinator
 Member

2:06 pm, Aug 27 2014
Posts: 620


The lack of Chinese on here is surprising. I guess they do have their own sites for Chinese scanlations.

Post #650809 - Reply to (#650533) by sudsong
user avatar
Aijin
Member

3:28 am, Aug 28 2014
Posts: 187


Spanish and Catalan aren't the same language, even if they are similar. Depending on the other person's knowledge, you might or might not be able to communicate with a Spanish person using Catalan, but I could also talk to a French person using Catalan and we'd more or less understand each other.
I suggest you go and look up the two languages if you're interested in the differences.

________________
http://shokubutsujin.wordpress.com/
User Posted Image
subir fotos
Post #650839
user avatar
Procrastinator and
Member

1:37 pm, Aug 28 2014
Posts: 1025


Portuguese here. I'm glad to see we are 4.3%, I would love to know how much of this percentage speaks brazilian portuguese. roll

Post #651001
user avatar
Member

3:46 pm, Aug 30 2014
Posts: 4


Quote
Baltic (Latvian, Lithuanian, etc.) - votes: 105 (0.7%)

A whooping 0,7%. Soon we will dominate MU laugh

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ]  
You must be registered to post!