banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

New Poll - Good, bad, and the Ugly

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ]  
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Member

7:50 pm, Jun 13 2017
Posts: 42


I choose Okay, Great and Bad. For me is quite simple if i got bored or feel that the work is bad, i stop reading no matter what. I don't understand people who read stuff they feel its bad because for me it is something i do to relax and have fun.

user avatar
 Member

10:27 pm, Jun 13 2017
Posts: 291


Bad, Great, Okay is what I chose mainly because the middle is the longest and therefore it needs to be great to sustain a reader. A bad ending would be terrible since it always leaves a bad taste in the mouth.

________________
Must Read Webcomic:
Unsounded

Lists:
Reading
Complete
Western Webcomics
user avatar
Scan Master
Member

12:04 am, Jun 14 2017
Posts: 92


I'm going with Bad, Okay, Great.
That way there's a nice ramp-up... and once I get past the bad stuff, there's no more of it that I have to worry about. laugh

Then I'll watch a bunch of okay stuff until the very end, which would end up being great, and the majority of my time will have been well spent. cool

________________
Visit my scanning blog:

Jammin' Scans

::End of Transmission::
user avatar
Member

4:57 pm, Jun 14 2017
Posts: 53


I've never in my entire life read a manga with a great ending.
Never.
The nearest "great" endings are only considered as good only.
So, I chose the most probable answer - okay ending.
"Bad beginning, great middle (this always happens in my favourite manga(s)) but okay ending".

user avatar
Member

8:22 pm, Jun 15 2017
Posts: 215


Definetly not bad middle or bad ending.
Middle being the longest part, i'll definetly drop the manga.
Bad ending will always leave a bad aftertaste when you'll remember it.

So obviously bad beginning. It'll be hard to start the manga but if you have an okay middle you'll saw some improvement and keep hooked.
And the a great ending will left you happy and you'll remember this manga as a fulfilling story.

user avatar
Member

11:20 pm, Jun 15 2017
Posts: 45


A very interesting subject, and there was so many axed manga ^^

________________
My perfect sentence when someone suspect me : "I'm not suspect, it's not me I swear"
Post #692615
Member

5:36 am, Jun 16 2017
Posts: 3


So many chooses bad at beginning, I understand of wanting to "save best for last" but think realistically - if you find the beginning terrible, you normally don't know if it'll get any better later on. So what are the chances you'll simply drop it?
Therefore stories with bad start will just die without chances to make amends. I'd say it's better to have at least good at start and bad in the middle.

Post #692622 - Reply to (#692423) by residentgrigo
user avatar
Member

1:39 pm, Jun 16 2017
Posts: 18


I agree with this, the decisive moment for me to drop or not to drop the series is the middle act.
A lot of my favorite manga began with okay or bad beginning, but when they have a great second act, it's fine even if the ending is not that good or they got axed.

I can't explain it well but t's like what matters the most is the journey, you know? And that journey is the part when it took most time, which is the middle part.

Post #692623 - Reply to (#692416) by Anima
user avatar
Member

1:48 pm, Jun 16 2017
Posts: 18


There are a lot of great manga that starts bad beginning actually. What makes them popular is they have a great middle part. The middle part is what mostly makes up the manga, and people will start reading it because the "adventure" is great, it builds your anticipation to see how far can the manga goes.

user avatar
Member

11:05 pm, Jun 16 2017
Posts: 15


Reminded me of Air Gear.
Great start with a lot of potential, then starting to shit around vol15 I think confused
I completely stop reading it.

There is also a lot of good one that got axed... no
Mx0 etc

sigh... none

Post #692664 - Reply to (#692633) by BlackFrame
Member

1:50 pm, Jun 17 2017
Posts: 132


This is why I am okay with a bad ending, because most axed stories end badly.

________________
Internet Lurker At Heart
Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ]  
You must be registered to post!