banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Romance in HSDK:?

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member

9:02 am, Nov 24 2008
Posts: 530


Does History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi manga really have any romance in it? Because as far as I have read there hasnt been any romance in between Kenichi and Miu, as its all one-sided from Kenichi. So my question is, Why is it listed under Romnce tag? If HSDK is listed under Romance, Bleach can be listed under romance as well coz Orihime's love towards Ichigo is also one-sided just like Kenichi's. I mean, tags can be misleading

Post #230550
Member

9:17 am, Nov 24 2008
Posts: 251


/agree

user avatar
Member

9:23 am, Nov 24 2008
Posts: 22


SOO true lol maybe thier is romance because miu like kenichi well that what it kinda shows

Member

9:28 am, Nov 24 2008
Posts: 678


it's a working progress, but the interest between the two is there.

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
 Site Admin

9:30 am, Nov 24 2008
Posts: 6221


Haven't read Kenichi in a while, but there does seem to be a slight focus on Kenichi's feelings for Miu. We didn't even get a slight hint of romance from Bleach until Orihime confessed but there seems to be no focus whatsoever on her feelings for Ichigo other than that one scene.

Post #230559
Member

9:43 am, Nov 24 2008
Posts: 28


there is some kind of romance though i wouldn't say it is one-sided, since Miu gets angry (jealous if you will) when Kenichi is with Renka or Shigure ( as in a bath ), but it does progress somewhat and by the end i'm sure they would be a couple

Member

11:51 am, Dec 11 2008
Posts: 163


But you have to admit that it kinda starts pissing you off when you see miu experiencing feelings of love and then she starts asking herself what does feelings are.. I would like to see a major development in the relationship soon, altough I dont expect much from a shonen romance I still keep my hopes up so that they get crushed towards the end of the manga. bigrazz

________________
User Posted Image User Posted Image
user avatar
uhh...
Member

3:37 am, Dec 15 2008
Posts: 1034


yeah the romance is pretty immature....nothing deep about it, but it is a shounen action with the focus on martial arts, so you cant expect it to be no Suzuka though


________________
User Posted Image
Post #272246 - Reply to (#237872) by Monstar Maalik
Member

10:49 pm, Mar 31 2009
Posts: 97


Quote from Monstar Maalik
yeah the romance is pretty immature....nothing deep about it, but it is a shounen action with the focus on martial arts, so you cant expect it to be no Suzuka though


The romance in HSDK is still just at toddler level and IMHO Suzuka isnt that good a read .

user avatar
Member

5:30 pm, May 19 2009
Posts: 66


My Theory is any instance where the Main female character has to get Jealous over another girls action (like touching, hugging, kissing, etc) towards the Main male character, counts as romance...

in Bleach we do not see that happening, yeah there were time when i think Orihime felt a little jealous at Rukia because she could cheer him up that one time... eh that it plus ichi is explosively oblivious to any of it do it doesn't count.

Back to HSDK we see them caring for each other in their thoughts much more often too, plus they have their moments after like each 50 chapters haha. ch 188 is good example.

Post #289798 - Reply to (#272246) by ssuasw
user avatar
uhh...
Member

5:01 am, May 20 2009
Posts: 1034


Quote from ssuasw
Quote from Monstar Maalik
yeah the romance is pretty immature....nothing deep about it, but it is a shounen action with the focus on martial arts, so you cant expect it to be no Suzuka though


The romance in HSDK is still just at toddler level and IMHO Suzuka isnt that good a read .


thats irrelevant the point i was trying to make was, people who read Suzuka read Suzuka for the romance, cuzz it is a romance, thats not what HSDK is though, romance at best is just a sub-genre, thats what i was getting at

________________
User Posted Image
Post #343368 - Reply to (#289798) by Monstar Maalik
Member

7:38 am, Dec 20 2009
Posts: 4


Quote from Monstar Maalik
Quote from ssuasw
Quote from Monstar Maalik
yeah the romance is pretty immature....nothing deep about it, but it is a shounen action with the focus on martial arts, so you cant expect it to be no Suzuka though


The romance in HSDK is still just at toddler level and IMHO Suzuka isnt that good a read .


thats irrelevant the point i was trying to make was, people who read Suzuka read Suzuka for the romance, cuzz it is a romance, thats not what HSDK is though, romance at best is just a sub-genre, thats what i was getting at



Yes that is true... it is not the same type of manga like suzuka.. it is more focus on action and it is not pure romance anyway... it is more on action. all mangas are different, that is why it is fun reading different mangas even if it has same genre, the flow of the stories are not exactly the same.... or else you could predict it and slowly your interest will be gone.

Post #394850
user avatar
Member

3:15 am, Jul 27 2010
Posts: 49


So... I see there are 38 volumes and it's on-going.

I don't know how long the series was the last time a post was made... but does anyone know how well the romance has developed since then?

Seeing some developement between the two of them would be worth starting the manga. (I've been watching the anime for the last two days.)

________________
I forgot this existed... I'll keep it here for old time's sake.
user avatar
 Member

5:30 am, Oct 19 2010
Posts: 773


well miu-kenichi is almost a couple

for e/g

Spoiler (highlight to view)
when the pony tail guy proposed to her at the island tournament she said she already had a promise with kenichi

miu gets jealous when ma-kensei's daughter flirts with kenichi

she said in some chapter that she felt xtremely releived when kenichi was around...but she didnt know why herself!

so miu is an airhead who loves him but doesnt know herself

she heard his confession ......when he said that he was learning martial arts to be with miu




________________
best shonen manga couples :

shinichi X ran
natsu X erza
ippo X kumi
naruto X gaara
You must be registered to post!