bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
Do you prefer reading a completed or ongoing series?
I only read completed series
I prefer reading completed series but dabble in ongoing series
I don't care
I prefer reading ongoing series but dabble in completed series
I only read ongoing series
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

Comment removal/dissappearance

Pages (2[ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member


15 years ago
Posts: 17

Hi I've had either my commented removed or they seem to have vanished from http://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=51978 ,with if they were removed no explanation or reason why or one I could even think of.


user avatar
Site Admin


15 years ago
Posts: 10867

Because series comments are supposed to be about the series, not complaining about someone who updates the series page


________________

A just ruler amongst tyrants

Member


15 years ago
Posts: 17

it was about the series and I was the person who updated the series to then have no mods believe what I told them.


user avatar
Site Admin


15 years ago
Posts: 10867

We want more proof than just what you say. The issue was whether it would be a sequel or a volume 2, and you did not provide proof that satisfied me either way


________________

A just ruler amongst tyrants

Member


15 years ago
Posts: 17

there was nothing to suggest the name was gona change but there was proof that the series was going to continue so the logical option would of been too leave it showing ongoing rather than complete.


user avatar
Site Admin


15 years ago
Posts: 10867

But then the scanlator groups listed it as a "sequel" instead of a 2nd volume, hence the ambiguous nature


________________

A just ruler amongst tyrants

Member


15 years ago
Posts: 17

even under that circumstance it still would of been better to list it as ongoing since it was confirmed the story was continuing so rather than labelling it complete so as to confuse users into thinking there wasn't going to be anymore and so they might not check up about this manga or leave it marked as reading.
It could have even been a mistranslation of the group which lead them to label it sequel but they still indicated there was going to be more to the story and that should have been enough.


user avatar
Site Admin


15 years ago
Posts: 10867

Nope, not good enough for me


________________

A just ruler amongst tyrants

Member


15 years ago
Posts: 17

well this time your logic or reasoning behind that not being enough was proven wrong by the fact a 2nd volume did come out like I indicated and tried to thusly display for other users who didn't know.


user avatar
Site Admin


15 years ago
Posts: 10867

If you want the last laugh, just go for it. It doesn't matter to me in the end.


________________

A just ruler amongst tyrants

user avatar
Lowly Member
Member


15 years ago
Posts: 3888

I talked to someone from the scanlation group, and it's a sequel called Momo Lover, Sequel.

But I think it'd be best just to put it was 2 Volumes (Ongoing) for now. Even though it's not exactly a second volume.


________________

♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ

user avatar
Site Admin


15 years ago
Posts: 10867

The # of volumes is what is actually published in volume form, not in magazine form. For this series, it's gotta be either 0 or 1. I'm pretty doubtful it's 2


________________

A just ruler amongst tyrants

Member


15 years ago
Posts: 17

I wasn't meaning for it to be the last laugh but more to make a point, if there is info to suggest the story is going to continue it shouldn't be labled as complete and yes starlight it may of been labeled as sequel but it still has the same name so obvious it's just a wrong choice of wording.


user avatar
Member


15 years ago
Posts: 2275

We might just have to wait to get a better understanding on how the publisher will deal with it. If it really is the second season for the series... that it is actually labeled that on the new volume (or something to that effect), then it should get it's own series, as this has already been done on this site (see Love @ First Sight Season 1 and Love @ First Sight Season 2). If not, then it will just be kept on the current series page that it is now. This can be brought up again when "volume two" is published, as Volume One will not released until September 24th. Now, because it is labeled as "もも・らば 1", the next one will probably be もも・らば 2; however, we can not confirm this at the present time.

Therefore, this should be locked until further information can be ascertained, and the series be left as is.


________________

[color=green]"Officially, this machine doesn't exist, you didn't get it from me,
and I don't know you. Make sure it doesn't leave the building."[/color]

Member


15 years ago
Posts: 17

well this topic was originally for why my comments were being removed w/o an explanation and I don't think any of my comments were offensive or broke any kinds of rules and it was about this series but still each and every one of them were removed.


Pages (2[ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!