bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
How should SFX be handled?
The original should be replaced with a translation SFX
A translation should be placed next to the original
A translation should be in the margins
SFX shouldn't be translated at all
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

Descriptions and Mangahelpers

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 59

I noticed that whenever Mangahelpers write a new manga shout out, the previous summary for that manga gets replaced. It happened to many series before. One of the latest examples is Hoshi no Ponko to Toufuya Reiko. Yes, my summary is still there for now but it usually gets completely deleted and I won't be suprised when this one meets the same fate.
So my questions are simple. Should I bother adding summaries? Did I miss some rule that says Mangahelpers' summaries take over everything else? Because I don't feel like taking my time to write temporary "placeholders."


user avatar
icon Site Admin


11 years ago
Posts: 6221

I'm pretty sure there's no such rule. Just as you can edit the summary, someone, maybe a mangahelpers user must be doing so too.


... Last edited by blakraven66 11 years ago
user avatar
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 402

Hmm, interesting question... Obviously, it's disrespectful to your work to just replace it with someone else's summary, even though there was nothing wrong with yours. I guess this is a problem with the current MU system, that even though it allows anyone to edit like on wiki, it doesn't have wiki's edit history.

I would say that given the significant risk of your work being wasted by others, it isn't worth your time to provide summaries under the current system. Although personally, I'd never delete someone's summary unless it was thoroughly wrong.

If it makes you feel better, I'm very grateful to you and others who have been writing summaries of manga that isn't being scanlated yet, given that official Japanese summaries are almost entirely useless.


________________
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 59

Alright. So it's just some user(s?) who likes to promote Mangahelpers. Well, I'm gonna try one more thing. Let's see if he dares to delete really long descriptions. I'm 80% sure Mangahelpers will mention Kenkouki - Hi no Kuni Daiteikokugun Kurenai Ikki Tousentai within a month. It's a new Young Jump series after all.

P.S. Thanks for support cmertb! \o/


You must be registered to post!