banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

New Poll - Long Titles

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar


11:12 am, Feb 10 2024
Posts: 10634


This week's poll was suggested by LazyReviewer. Generally it's the isekai series that have long titles, but when does it get too long? I don't know what the actual longest title is, but here's an example of a long one: Isekai Shoukansareta Kita Seijo-sama ga "Kareshi ga Shinda" to Naku Bakari de Hataraite kuremasen. Tokorode Sono Shinda Kareshi, Zense no Ore desu ne.

You can submit poll ideas here
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=3903

Previous Poll Results:
Question: You are transmigrated into a book which you read in your previous life and...
Choices:
You remember every important detail - votes: 565 (26.4%)
You only remember a few events/names - votes: 1136 (53.1%)
You only remember the names of the original leads - votes: 77 (3.6%)
You don't remember anything! - votes: 361 (16.9%)
There were 2139 total votes.
The poll ended: February 10th, 2024 10:58am PST

I feel like many of us have inflated opinions of our memory

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
Member

11:22 am, Feb 10 2024
Posts: 188


There is no title that is too long but I rather it be less than 5. After 5 words, you know the fanbase is just going to abbreviate anyway, your not going to remember the exact title, and your never going to tell someone the exact title anyway.

________________
Internet Lurker At Heart
user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT
 Member

12:18 pm, Feb 10 2024
Posts: 2398


The Lord of the Rings is 5 words. The absolute maximum before the title becomes a sentence. Don´t try to be more epic than the epic. I can maybe see 6 words working in edge cases but even that seems too much and individual novel names are their own thing where the 5 word limit equally applies.

I can´t think of a single one of these word salad LNs or manga titles that are worth looking at so the gimmick continues to remain the sign of a hack attention grabber.

Edit: October 2019. When Light Novel Titles Started to get so Long
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pi79l5k8gBM
I hate the LN market so much. The absolute ass crack of young adult literature and still comically niche outside of Japan.

Last edited by residentgrigo at 12:24 pm, Feb 10 2024

________________
I also read EU/US comics and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists + Imdb
User Posted Image
Post #805437
user avatar
Member

2:38 pm, Feb 10 2024
Posts: 646


IMO most of the best titles are under 6, but 'A Year and a Day in Old Theradane' comes to mind as a long title that I like (albeit not manga).

I dislike long titles when they're a sentence (or, horror of horrors, multiple sentences) and are describing the content of the work rather than making any attempt to be clever.

user avatar
Member

11:06 pm, Feb 10 2024
Posts: 10


I don't particularly care about the length of the title, but this trend of writing the synopsis with the title not cool.

I do understand why it exists: It's the clickbait principle
The synopsis is a short, well written description to appeal to the interests of the readers, draw them in, and get them hooked on the main concept. However, it is not seen until you flip the book over or click the link.
The title, however is visible on the cover, website homepage, and every list/catalog - requiring no additional effort to be seen - but it doesn't have the captivating power of the synopsis.
So why not then write a very descriptive title to bait the readers even if it is long? It may be cumbersome, but it's surely effective.

Now, here's a suggestion: let's make this a thread for sharing the worst offenders...

Post #805446 - Reply to (#805439) by Koneko_Nyaa
Not a human
Member

11:42 pm, Feb 11 2024
Posts: 5


Agreeing to this hypothesis, I think Japanese long titles have been catching up with the level YouTube clickbait video titles. It's got to the point of fake comments on thumbnail and outrageous brackets; those SSSS, 999999 and 0.000001% is apparently old news.

Example: https://www.mangaupdates.com/series/auc93s2/jako-ni-wa-kaji-ga-oniaida-www-to-iwareta-kaji-level-9999-no-ore-tsuihousareta-no-de-boukensha-ni-tenshoku-suru-saikyou-de-musou-shinagara-guild-de-tanoshiku-kurashimasu

Post #805454 - Reply to (#805439) by Koneko_Nyaa
Member

12:27 am, Feb 13 2024
Posts: 485


I mean the real reason is that the big webnovel site (Syosetu) just didn't have a synopsis option at all for years and enough series go picked up for actual publication in that era that it became an accepted practice.

Member

1:30 pm, Feb 14 2024
Posts: 34


I chose 9. The people who selected "There is no title that is too long" probably only do it to be contrary or something.🙄 Yeah, you people go and work through a 100-word-long title and then try and say again that there's no such thing as a title that's too long.🙄 Ultra long titles are ridiculous and can be contraproductive, unless done in an artful manner to get the attention of a specific target group of readers. For example, those super long novel titles that you repeatedly see here sound stupid, and aren't funny at all (not the translators' fault- they're just correctly translating it). Maybe it's different in the native languages, but I doubt that.

Last edited by amy_levi at 1:45 pm, Feb 14 2024

user avatar
Josei Addict
Member

5:31 pm, Feb 14 2024
Posts: 177


I picked 8, but realistically, it depends on the length of the words and how catchy the title. Immediately "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" came to mind and I really like that title (clocking in at 6 words and I threw in two more in case there are some titles with more prepositions).

I can't stand those super long isekai & light novel titles that are basically summaries of the manga. 😔

Last edited by flowinmyboat at 5:35 pm, Feb 14 2024

________________
http://i.imgur.com/LxhWm.jpg (will reformat this some day…)
You must be registered to post!