bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
How should SFX be handled?
The original should be replaced with a translation SFX
A translation should be placed next to the original
A translation should be in the margins
SFX shouldn't be translated at all
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

Female Author?

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 51

category "Male Demographic with Female Author" ?

How do you know HONNA Wakou is a woman?


user avatar
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 1792

Because the rule of Google states:
If you Google a Japanese mangaka named Honna Wakou that wrote a certain manga and the first thing you find is information about a female Japanese mangaka named Honna Wakou that wrote that manga, chances are she is female.


________________

in need of romance?
uncommon, sad, sweet

Member


7 years ago
Posts: 219

the picture they used for them on google search is the actor who played the female lead in the movie adaption of nozoki ana. mangaseek says gender is unknown and booklive says they're male other sources vary so who knows?


user avatar
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 1792

I think data links on Wikipedia can be trusted (in most cases)
[url]https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q10644200[/url]


________________

in need of romance?
uncommon, sad, sweet

Post #764420 - Reply To (#764413) by Lorska
Post #764420 - Reply To (#764413) by Lorska
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 219

im not familiar with that site but even japanese people are unsure...


Post #764440 - Reply To (#764412) by MaskingTape
Post #764440 - Reply To (#764412) by MaskingTape
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 51

Quote from MaskingTape

the picture they used for them on google search is the actor who played the female lead in the movie adaption of nozoki ana. mangaseek says gender is unknown and booklive says they're male other sources vary so who knows?

Exactly, possibly the people and websites (including wikidata which even I can edit) who thought the author is a woman based themselves on that actress picture? lol.

"female
0 references" lol

本名ワコウ

本名means real name no? is it a common surname? and then the first name in katakana... is it even a female-like name?
isn't it just a pen name? perhaps why then people actually don't really know the author's gender?


user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT
icon Site Admin


7 years ago
Posts: 2448

Here is an ANN article conforming the gender:
https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2015-11-28/nozoki-ana-wakoh-honna-to-launch-fureru-to-kikoeru-manga/.95769
"Honna launched her...". So stop down-voting the tag.
You can easily find other neutral sources, including publisher information. This could all be a pseudonym but basically every author can hide behind one. Who is to say that Stephen King wrote all those books and not his wife. Insert dramatic gif [here]... ?
Case closed.


________________

I also read EU/US comics and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists + Imdb

Post #764673 - Reply To (#764668) by residentgrigo
Post #764673 - Reply To (#764668) by residentgrigo
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 51

Quote from residentgrigo

Here is an ANN article conforming the gender:
https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2015-11-28/nozoki-ana-wakoh-honna-to-launch-fureru-to-kikoeru-manga/.95769
"Honna launched her...". So stop down-voting the tag.

What says that wasn't based on the misleading first-look google result or even this website? lol.

You can easily find other neutral sources, including publisher information.

Where?

This could all be a pseudonym but basically every author can hide behind one.

This just makes me want to start disconsidering author's gender, unless there's any actual source somewhere showing actual evidence. Lol.

Who is to say that Stephen King wrote all those books and not his wife. Insert dramatic gif [here]... ?
Case closed. What's that pigeon playing chess quote again? Haha jk... ?


user avatar
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 1792

This is basically saying the only way you will acknowledge her gender is when you find the transcript of her birth certificate which also states she wrote the manga in that same official governmental document.
Information on the internet isn't rocket science... You either believe the majority of the same information or you doubt it and say everyone just did a Google search of a false source. There is no way to convince you of anything this way so there is no point in having this discussion to begin with.

Basically, if you wanna doubt, do it but don't involve others in it.


________________

in need of romance?
uncommon, sad, sweet

user avatar
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 1143

Warn: Banned

If I may inqure, why does it even matter, anyway? Just seems like a pointless tag to begin with.


________________
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 51

I'm not doubting, there are just no sources nor this "majority of the same information". I don't want to be convinced of anything especially of what you don't know, I made the question wondering who put that tag there and why. And looks like my suspects were correct...

I asked because sometimes I do get curious to know if it was a man or a woman who wrote the manga.

Has Honna Wakou ever presented itself as a woman or not, like in those author comments in manga volumes? Well, maybe some time I'll check


... Last edited by modnar 7 years ago
user avatar
Member


7 years ago
Posts: 454

Heh, wow, amazing how some people could obsess over such a trivial thing.


Post #768900 - Reply To (#764698) by svines85
Post #768900 - Reply To (#764698) by svines85
Member


6 years ago
Posts: 51

Quote from svines85

Heh, wow, amazing how some people could obsess over such a trivial thing.

Who's obsessing? I just don't know the need for tags based on supposition. If it's not known, then leave it as unknown.

@MaskingTape
"or you doubt it and say everyone just did a Google search of a false source"

Quote from MaskingTape

the picture they used for them on google search is the actor who played the female lead in the movie adaption of nozoki ana. mangaseek says gender is unknown and booklive says they're male other sources vary so who knows?

This obviously is a misunderstanding. Not a false source, it's not even a source thereby.


... Last edited by lambchopsil 6 years ago
user avatar
Member


6 years ago
Posts: 454

Well then I'll stand corrected on the "obsessing" point, but not on the "trivial" point..........that part stands. It's a trivial tag (among many, maaaany here) that I'd never pay attention to to begin with, about a trivial piece of information that I wouldn't even remotely consider when evaluating whether or not to read a story.

But to each their own 🙂


Post #804390 - Reply To (#764675) by Lorska
Post #804390 - Reply To (#764675) by Lorska
Member


2 years ago
Posts: 51

Reading back, lovely how this nasty piece of work just conveniently ignored this question:

[You can easily find other neutral sources, including publisher information.]

"Where?"

Don't act like a smartass if you don't even know it. Quoting a random anime website phrase that contain no reference isn't a source.

Here is a japanese comment that says this author's gender seems to be unknown.
https://twitter.com/nymphsao/status/898916452303949824?t=8F8GXd3_tIX6Z81o0PnjoQ&s=19

As for the people who think the interest isn't important, then why are you here? Don't reply if you have no interest. Some people might be interested to know if the author is male, female or even otherwise (nowadays). If you can't respect that it's YOU who shouldn't involve others, therefore no need for your useless smart ass remarks so please next time go troll elsewhere.

Besides, remember there's a (false) tag that implies the author is female when that isn't known. Which can mislead people to find this manga when it's not really what they were looking for. Stop defending a false tag and attacking people who want a single ACTUAL source of what the author's gender is. And not a random ONE anime little "article" single pronoun used by who knows who. That's not a source at all.


... Last edited by modnar 2 years ago
You must be registered to post!