Mangahelpers can go to hell. They acknowledged that the document was real and tried to pull the wool over our eyes in the mean time. I hope they go down and that Viz burns them to dust.

something interesting i found...

http://img33.imageshack.us/i/59948885.jpg/
http://img33.imageshack.us/i/98465773.jpg/
http://img30.imageshack.us/i/14164387.jpg/

well, i can't say i'm surprised by this. they tried to do this whole thing behind the fans' back and now that just confirms their duplicity.

Not sure if legit...

________________
Member of FoOlRulez and head coder of the FoOlSlide project.

Doesn't look real...besides the obvious grammatical errors, how can a private email of such content be so easily leaked? The drafted email and business plan I can understand since it's obvious that more than one person was aware of it, so anyone could have leaked. But this is just fake...

And well that MH admin did say the email was a draft, meaning it has not yet been sent. How much truth those words hold, I have no idea though.

________________

Monkeys, always at your service.

What I don't like is that:

LooooooooL
They are what they are thanks to scanlation group, and then they will ask them to stop?? And the way they think they've some influence in the scanlation world made me lol!!!! Bullshit!!!

And no way I'm buying manga online!! I loooove to have my copy in my hand, and it'd cost more to read online than to have a pretty copy in the library!!

I'm disappointed, truly... And I really hope that MH will crash xD

Those "e-mails" are 100% fake. They'll only cause more confusion so stop spreading them around the net. GEEZ.

I have to agree with you and say that I also think this stuff looks a little iffy. Anway, I doubt that VIZ would participate in anything that foolish. ....I hope

Last edited by shoujo22 at 11:49 am, Sep 25 2009

This has to be fake. He hasn't even sent the email yet and this was too easily leaked and convenient.

________________
Why, hello there!!!

Notice that the dude registered a few minutes before posting that stuff. And he never logged in again after making that single post.

Oh well...

BANNED

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants

It would be even better if you deleted those links as well.

I wonder who leaked the (draft) proposal? Could it have been intentional to gain attention without approaching VIZ directly? I mean there are what, 4-5 people involved? Or maybe I'm just thinking too much


Anyways, I know several people are not against the idea of removing only the licensed series from MH, but I don't think VIZ or any publisher for that matter would want any association to anything that the allows illegal distribution of manga. I think that the current MH would ceased to exist, whether this plan goes through or not there would definitely be changes.

well for if this goes through and MH loses its much audience(which they probably will judging from the reactions) it would be a truly great chance for Baka Updates and others to step up and hug the spotlight for the underground manga community xP.

This
/topic

________________
"“That's the difference between me and the rest of the world!
Happiness isn't good enough for me! I demand euphoria!” "

Well u never considered why a person would be registering a few minutes before and posting a single post. I am that lala2080 and if I told you those were genuine stuff and i posted this just to protect my real identity. Would anyone believe? I doubt so.

Last edited by lalala2000 at 9:02 pm, Sep 24 2009