banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

New Poll - Comics Ranking

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ]  
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #797689 - Reply to (#797650) by Unknown
user avatar
Member

4:40 am, Jun 7 2022
Posts: 412


I hardly read either manhwa or manhua, but I did like China Girls and Mia - Unjou no Neverland more than any manhwa I've encountered, so I put manhua second.

Post #797692 - Reply to (#797650) by Unknown
Member

5:47 am, Jun 7 2022
Posts: 263


scream queen is a pretty good one, it only works because its chinese, but yea generally chinese ones suck the most and most can only be enjoyed if you just roll with it.

I would put korean and manga at the same level with a slight nod to manga because I like more genres of manga than I do korean comics.

Post #797707
user avatar
Member

7:12 pm, Jun 7 2022
Posts: 646


I voted manga, manhwa, manhua. Some of my favourite works are manhwa but I despise webtoons, I don’t think I’ve ever read a manhua.

user avatar
Member

2:59 am, Jun 8 2022
Posts: 3


The people who chose manhua. How do yo all sleep at night? 🤨
I would have said manga, manhwa and then manhua.... at a very distant last. But most of my favorite BL's are manhwa. And koreans have wayy better art style generally.. Like hello!!! BJ Alex, Killing Stalking, Under the greenlight.
Manhua on the other hand has the worst storylines that don't even make sense and their art is also very simplistic and not good enough.

Last edited by TheOneWhoGotAway at 2:59 am, Jun 8 2022

user avatar
Member

6:19 pm, Jun 9 2022
Posts: 15


I mainly read Manga and Manhwa. I avoid Manhua because I don't want to end up accidentally reading CCP/PRC propaganda. I would however be open to reading a Taiwanese manhua or two if I find one that suits my interests. So if anyone who reads this post got any Taiwanese Manhua recs, I'm all ears.

Post #797729
user avatar
no
Member

7:37 pm, Jun 9 2022
Posts: 45


i chose manga > manhwa > manhua... but if most manhua had better translations then i think i would read it more. The artstyles are so pretty but then the translation turns out to be absolutely terrible and i can't understand the story at all.

but the manhua i have finished (and could understand) were good but i read more manga and manhwa.

________________
hi <BR>
Post #797730 - Reply to (#797727) by K9ofChaos
user avatar
Member

8:23 pm, Jun 9 2022
Posts: 26


Same here. I suspect like other forms of their media, the Chinese government only ensures that specific manhua are produced and publicized.

Post #797731
Member

10:17 pm, Jun 9 2022
Posts: 485


I want original stories with a single writer/artist. Unfortunately for me everything is so overwhelmingly novel adaptations now, including manga.

Manhwa adaptations are pretty but incomplete. Quality and artists randomly change between seasons and sometimes it just ends.

Manhua are mostly really bad adaptations of their source novels or weird gag comics. I can enjoy a weird gag comic, but they're something I randomly binge, not something I get invested in. A few of their major publishers don't even list an author anymore.

That's not to say there aren't new original Korean and Chinese comics, but I feel like I need to actively look for them.

Last edited by kaloo at 10:27 pm, Jun 9 2022

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ]  
You must be registered to post!