bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
If you're reading an original story by a Japanese author but it's online-only and formatted in a vertical strip with full color, what do you call it?
Manga
Webcomic
Webtoon
Other
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

Japanese pen names are for posers?

Pages (4[ 1 2 3 4 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Sorinozuka
Member


16 years ago
Posts: 321

It just gets annoying sometimes.


user avatar
Middle aged
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 7789

Shouldn't use. Weeaboos are lame.
Pen names in general suck.
Shouldn't be used unless
you draw some very peculiar hentai and
want to protect your identity, though
not necessarily even then.


user avatar
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 77

Definitely not. It's not like they have it patented or something, haha. I do understand why someone would say that to you but let them be. It's not like they're Japanese (probably, hehe).


user avatar
Crikey!
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 1308

Even though I dont exactly mind anyone using any pen names, it sounds a bit like a wannabe and who isnt actually..

pls dont take it as a racist thing but its a bit like a brown person like me choosing an obviously white name like Stella or Vivian

Tell me, how many times havent you become judgemental when you call up a call centre and get a Indian accented fella on the other end who calls himself Jason and you think "yeah, right"..


________________
user avatar
Fruit Salad
Member


16 years ago
Posts: 1353

😲 I never knew Stella and Vivian were associated with white.


Post #287990 - Reply To (#287986) by base_coat
Post #287990 - Reply To (#287986) by base_coat
user avatar
Crikey!
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 1308

Quote from base_coat

😲 I never knew Stella and Vivian were associated with white.

I dunno, maybe American or English, I have a nice non native English accent so if I roped in "Vivian" as my name, i have seen some raise eye brows..at least its easier than people stumbling on my real name..


________________
Post #287994 - Reply To (#287990) by BimboSilly
Post #287994 - Reply To (#287990) by BimboSilly
user avatar
Member


16 years ago
Posts: 123

Don't use names/words from languages you aren't speaking fluently. Don't use names or symbols from cultures, ideologies or religions you aren't affiliated with. It makes you appear dumb when you can't live up to the expectations that your name has raised. Ultimately, it is your choice, though.

Quote from BimboSilly

Quote from base_coat

 😲     I never knew Stella and Vivian were associated with white. 

I dunno, maybe American or English, I have a nice non native English accent so if I roped in "Vivian" as my name, i have seen some raise eye brows..at least its easier than people stumbling on my real name..

Vivian reminds me of aunt Vivian, from Fresh Prince of Bel Air. Never got the feeling that the name might be more fitting for a white person.


Post #287995 - Reply To (#287972) by Mamsmilk
Post #287995 - Reply To (#287972) by Mamsmilk
user avatar
What?!?
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 1130

Quote from Mamsmilk

Shouldn't use. Weeaboos are lame.
Pen names in general suck.
Shouldn't be used unless
you draw some very peculiar hentai and
want to protect your identity, though
not necessarily even then.

You do realize some of the best authors in the world have and do use pen names. Sometimes their real name isn't very marketable or is so long it would be hard to place on a book cover. Either way isn't it basically the same as not going by your real name on message boards?


________________
Post #287996 - Reply To (#287995) by Spanky151
Post #287996 - Reply To (#287995) by Spanky151
user avatar
Member


16 years ago
Posts: 123

Quote from Spanky151

Quote from Mamsmilk

Shouldn't use. Weeaboos are lame.
Pen names in general suck.
Shouldn't be used unless
you draw some very peculiar hentai and
want to protect your identity, though
not necessarily even then.

You do realize some of the best authors in the world have and do use pen names. Sometimes their real name isn't very marketable or is so long it would be hard to place on a book cover. Either way isn't it basically the same as not going by your real name on message boards?

You mean us Adolf Hitlers and Josef Stalins who want to write children's books? Indeed, how are we supposed to survive without pseudonyms? 🤨


user avatar
Member


16 years ago
Posts: 13

Does that mean that Asian People can't use English Pen names? No. Theres nothing wrong with trying to get closer to a culture you didn't grow up in.


Post #288003 - Reply To (#287996) by Mindflayer
Post #288003 - Reply To (#287996) by Mindflayer
user avatar
What?!?
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 1130

Quote from Mindflayer

Quote from Spanky151

Quote from Mamsmilk

Shouldn't use. Weeaboos are lame.
Pen names in general suck.
Shouldn't be used unless
you draw some very peculiar hentai and
want to protect your identity, though
not necessarily even then.

You do realize some of the best authors in the world have and do use pen names. Sometimes their real name isn't very marketable or is so long it would be hard to place on a book cover. Either way isn't it basically the same as not going by your real name on message boards?

You mean us Adolf Hitlers and Josef Stalins who want to write children's books? Indeed, how are we supposed to survive without pseudonyms? 🤨

Ever hear of Mark Twain? Maybe George Orwell? Robert Jordan? Dr. Seuss? Judging a book by what someone chose as a pen name is sophomoric.


________________
Post #288006 - Reply To (#287994) by Mindflayer
Post #288006 - Reply To (#287994) by Mindflayer
user avatar
Crikey!
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 1308

Quote from Mindflayer

Quote from BimboSilly

Quote from base_coat

  😲      I never knew Stella and Vivian were associated with white. 

I dunno, maybe American or English, I have a nice non native English accent so if I roped in "Vivian" as my name, i have seen some raise eye brows..at least its easier than people stumbling on my real name..

Vivian reminds me of aunt Vivian, from Fresh Prince of Bel Air. Never got the feeling that the name might be more fitting for a white person.

OK, I clarify, at least non-American and non-English, non-Australian, non-Kiwi and non-canadian...well, that should do it..


________________
Post #288007 - Reply To (#288003) by Spanky151
Post #288007 - Reply To (#288003) by Spanky151
user avatar
Member


16 years ago
Posts: 123

Quote from Spanky151

Ever hear of Mark Twain? Maybe George Orwell? Robert Jordan? Dr. Seuss? Judging a book by what someone chose as a pen name is sophomoric.

You understand neither Mamsmilk nor me, do you? A writer's real name doesn't tell anything about the writer's talent or skill and only morons don't buy a book just because the author's name doesn't sound "marketable". We all know that morons shouldn't exist and that is why pen names shouldn't be used. At least not for those reasons.

Quote from BimboSilly

OK, I clarify, at least non-American and non-English, non-Australian, non-Kiwi and non-canadian...well, that should do it..

Ah, okay, never mind.


Post #288009 - Reply To (#288007) by Mindflayer
Post #288009 - Reply To (#288007) by Mindflayer
user avatar
Crikey!
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 1308

Quote from Mindflayer

Quote from BimboSilly

OK, I clarify, at least non-American and non-English, non-Australian, non-Kiwi and non-canadian...well, that should do it..

Ah, okay, never mind.

I was just trying to make a point with bad examples I suppose..but then again on the whole your opinion goes in the same way mine does, so its cool 😀

Pleasure 😃


________________
user avatar
icon Member


16 years ago
Posts: 75

Plenty of Asian mangaka choose English words as their pen name. Queenie Law, Caramel Dow, and similar names are definitely not Asian in origin, but are used as pen-names by Asians.


________________

My Mini-City

Database of FMA doujinshi (No longer being updated. Use The Doujinshi DB Project instead!)

Pages (4[ 1 2 3 4 ] Next
You must be registered to post!