I cried while i was reading the part that he left her and stole her song. I think what the boy's done is unforgivable but it for the girl's sake so it's maybe ok. I love the ending so i rate 10 for this manga.

I deffinitely agreed with mangafan321. Seriously, if it were me, I can't just EASILY forgive all the shit that the guy have done! Even if it's for her sake. Seriously, I would've wanted to at least see him get hurt like if the girl found another guy after leaving her just like that for a long time. Or maybe, something like the girl saying "what you did was unforgivable, but even though I knew it was all for me, this pain and hate is still there. I don't know if I can go back to the way we were before again" instead of the bullshit, "I hate you for that!"

Oh hell no! Yeah, she still loves him, thus is faithful for the one she truly love, I'd give her that. BUT, at least give them another time off. I feel that the main guy needs to learn his lessons as well. Like, wtf! Just because he kissed her all of sudden doesn't mean all is forgiven and forgotten. I had an extreme urge to punch to computer screen because of that. Gah! I'd rather have this go longer because I want to see the girl stand up on her own to catch up to him--not the fact that he just HAD to help her out in one day. That girl needs to toughen up and be independent. Use the past to grow strong, not remember the painful times and be a stupid, annoying crybaby. She can still remain kind and "mary sue" all the fuck she wants, but give them some fucking brain--dammit! DX

Wtf is wrong with shoujos these days. I used to not give a shit about stuff like these before but now I had enough with the forgiving heroines and thinking everything is always their fault. At least for once I want to see the one who inflicted pain suffer the consequences more, or admit his wrong doings and beg down on his knees for forgiveness. Just do something besides a stupid, useless, damn kiss!!!

That's why, NOOOO! I CAN'T ACCEPT THE ENDING!! I must find another manga to read to get my mind off of this.

... Last updated on November 22nd, 2011, 8:50pm

I'm unhappy with the ending. I was somehow expecting older people (they were still in high school) and a much longer time break.

It's a quick story without much substance beyond a "Kyah."

why do people like this manga? the main guy was sucha jerk he abandoms the main girl, stealse her song, and then treats her badly. And we are expected to believe that he is an angel that did this all for her? was her getting a career worth hurting her like that? i might have liked this manga more is the girl has found a new guy while the main guy was away working on his career, i woulda lkoved to see his face seeing her happy with someone else after he wasted all those months "helping" the main girl.

Yes it's a cute little story. The art is appealing and the storyline sub par. But if the genre heading of smut has caught your eyes and you're only reading it for the smut, I'm afraid you'll be disappointed. The moments of smut are quite brief and overall can be classified as only teasers. You're better off reading something else to quench your smutty thirst.

i LOVED it!and yes,it was amazing!i was very mad at the guy but loved him at the same time BECAUSE:he treasured her as a skillful and capable person.other guys would be like"be by my side and support me,i don't want other guys to look at you(so don't pursue a career)" so they wouldn't like her to have her own debut,they'd want their girl to just stay in the shadows selfishly.but he respected and treasured her talent,recognized her value and wanted to make her realize that fact.it was very mean of him to do it this way but all he did was truly only for her.He loves her so much and highly treats her with the appreciation she deserves.read it people!

This is such a sweet manga, I say it's worth reading and it has a good plot but if that guy did that to me and I did forgive him, boy, would he have to grovel...

it really was a good manga in my opinion. the only problem i have with this is that if i was the girl, i wouldn't forgive the guy that easily. i mean, who cares if it's ultimately for the girl, that was still too cruel. ahh, shoujo. if the heroine in this story had some more backbone then i would have rated this a 10.

anyway, it's still a 9 because i enjoyed the story and the art was very good. and i love the clothes.