| From User |
Message Body |
|
lambchopsil
|
Post #328241 |
Archon Solon
6:49 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 4427
|
How would you like your anime adaptations to be? Something exactly the same like Suzuka? Same general plot, but with some new and great content (as in a GOOD filler)? Totally different story, like Full Metal Alchemist? Or you don't really like anime anyways and you think it's a lost cause?
Or anything in between!
Question: How would you like the anime adaptation of a manga series?
Choices:
The exact same, just animated - votes: 6275 (49.6%)
Same general plot, but with some good, new content - votes: 5283 (41.8%)
Different plot so that it's not repetitive - votes: 371 (2.9%)
No anime for me - votes: 711 (5.6%)
There were 12640 total votes.
The poll ended: October 24th 2009
Last edited by lambchopsil at 6:02 pm, Oct 24
________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
lambchopsil---
MangaUpdates admin
Join the MangaUpdates Folding@Home team! (and help humanity)
Click here for info. Easy signup |
|
EternalNightmare
|
Post #328247 |
Memento Mori
Member
7:09 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 79
|
Same but better... like that's gonna happen =P
________________
"The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown"
________________
http://www.pp-international.net/ |
|
blakraven66
|
Post #328257 - Reply to ( #328247) by EternalNightmare |
Hand of Basileus
Super Mod
7:25 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 4659
|
Quote from EternalNightmare Same but better... like that's gonna happen =P
Hey, it can happen. I consider School Rumble, Ouran High School Host Club, Black Lagoon, Hajime no Ippo and RAVE anime better than their manga counterparts.
________________
|
|
mewnbrite
|
Post #328260 - Reply to ( #328257) by blakraven66 |
Member
7:32 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 325
|
Quote from blakraven66 Quote from EternalNightmare Same but better... like that's gonna happen =P Hey, it can happen. I consider Ouran High School Host Club anime better than their manga counterparts.
Yes o.o; I tried picking up the manga from where the anime ended and I was like WUT. Didn't like the manga.
Though the manga for Ghost Hunt seems 10x better than the anime.
I'm all for the same but better  Having a completely different plot makes me rage, and what's the point of it being 100% the same? 
________________
Nightingale Scans Forum |
|
RakShine
|
Post #328261 |
Member
7:34 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 33
|
I think Rosario+vampire is a good example of why a series should follow the plot of the manga, Instead of useless ecchi. I would have hoped to see some cool battles.(tsukune should not be such a wuss)
|
|
divinity9
|
Post #328263 |
Member
7:43 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 2
|
Succeeding with adding new content that's actually *good* is simply too rare to be worth the risk imo. Guaranteed new good content, who would say no to that... but we're not living in an utopia, are we? I'd rather they stuck close to the original. ^^
|
|
NightSwan
|
Post #328274 |
Hollow Swan
Member
8:10 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 3173
|
The exact same, just animated.
Prefered with better artwork, like in Ouran High school.
________________
 |
|
Yenoh
|
Post #328278 |
Yamtaro
Member
8:15 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 1120
|
I'm in between the first one and second one. : D
I like it exactly the same,some new content (comedy fillers), just animated.
Edit: Ack! I didn't word it right, I want: exactly the same plot, some new content (like, funny things that isn't included in the manga), just animated (I just want to see the characters moving for real). There.That makes more sense.
Edit 2: I like fillers that explain some mysteries on the manga, I also like one-episode side story fillers (just for fun).
Last edited by Yenoh at 2:18 am, Oct 18
________________
 |
|
Romashk
|
Post #328284 |
Member
8:30 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 14
|
Call me naive, but I wish that authors, in the process of reviewing their manga(to make the script for anime), would actually take time to find out what readers want(ed) to see in the story and not just follow popularity trends. Maybe half of the butchered stories out there could at least earn respect they deserved.
I like anime, however if script writers are not sure what will be good for the story they better leave it as is. 
|
|
StarlightDreams
|
Post #328288 |
Nerdlight
Member
8:41 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 2471
|
I'd like it to be the same...:x
________________
BROWNIES!
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ
Next to Read...Full Metal Alchemist |
|
Regnak
|
Post #328291 |
TheFawzer
Member
8:47 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 190
|
I like it when its just the same, like Hajime no Ippo. Now that was a good anime, it followed the story and for a sport manga seing it animated nicely just makes it feel new.
Adaptations like Naruto and Bleach where they add uneraleted stuff, I just feel like its a waste of my time and it tarnishes a otherwise good/decent story.
________________
Is the ability to do something not reason enough to do it? |
|
tactics
|
Post #328293 |
Stark
Member
8:51 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 965
|
I'm going to have to go for the same.
Although, new content isn't too bad because it makes it a little different. New 'anime characters only' though is a no no.
________________
Admit it. You could stare at this all day. |
|
loosecannon504
|
Post #328319 - Reply to ( #328293) by tactics |
The Gorilla Killa™
Member
10:07 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 1965
|
Quote from Yenoh I'm in between the first one and second one. : D
This is exactly how I feel. Sometimes an anime adds new content that's actually good (Like giving character development to someone that gets none whatsoever in the manga, or they add things in the anime that only appear in the extra pages of the tankoubon), but other times the anime adds things that don't need to even be there in the first place.
Quote from tactics New 'anime characters only' though is a no no.
This is a perfect example of what I meant by the anime adding things that don't need to be there.
________________
What is love, baby don't hurt me, don't hurt me, no more~♪ |
|
Calíbre
|
Post #328344 - Reply to ( #328319) by loosecannon504 |
Danger Mouse
Moderator
11:35 pm, Oct 17 2009
Posts: 2716
|
Quote from loosecannon504 Quote from Yenoh I'm in between the first one and second one. : D This is exactly how I feel. Sometimes an anime adds new content that's actually good (Like giving character development to someone that gets none whatsoever in the manga, or they add things in the anime that only appear in the extra pages of the tankoubon), but other times the anime adds things that don't need to even be there in the first place.
Some fillers are acceptable, like in the most recent episode of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood.
I like funny fillers that go off on random tangents.
What I hate is when these fillers last like 10 episodes.
Get that mess out of here.
________________
~~~~~~~~~~~~~More Pennies for my Plots~~~~~~~~~~~~
|
|
Aeylis
|
Post #328356 |
Apoptosis
Member
12:53 am, Oct 18 2009
Posts: 228
|
Either its the exact same, or it shouldn't exist at all. I can accept good fillers if it is an anime that doesn't really have an end in sight (like One Piece) However, seeing as though I'm not a fan of anime adaptions, I chose 'No Anime.'
________________
I am just a simple Medicine seller. |
