manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
For background art in manga, you prefer...
Lots of detail
An average amount of detail
Very little detail
Sparkles and patterns that fit the mood is just fine
I don't really pay attention to the backgrounds
I don't care
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Worth Reading anymore? (caution spoilers)

Back to Kimi no Iru Machi


Poll
Is this worth reading anymore?
YES
NO
You must login to vote.

You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
mystichead
Post #390848
user avatar
Member

3:29 am, Jul 10 2010
Posts: 64


Hey guys,
I know this is weird......but im just curious....
I left this manga on hold cuz i got frustrated on it when Nanami didnt want to be Haruto's girlfriend, and i think now he was thinking of getting together with Eba.....which i thought was chezy, and extremely lacking for a plot ....and all the characters and plot were slowly starting to frustrate me......

Soon after tht also went on my manga reading hiatus, in which i put most of the series iwas reading ion hold due to work and school and personal problems....now tht im coming back iwas wondering if should strt this up again.........

I dont mind spoilers, heck if u want to use them to fill me in go ahead, i forget details anyway, i only remember how the feeling of knowing the plot thus when i reread so i forget .....so its fine.....

Also im only gonna add to to this, to facilitate on ur decision on wht u recommend, as a guide, i like deep plots, and simple plots, and character depth and even non-depth, wht i dont like is overuse of cliches and deus ex machina stuff and fanservice (mind u if its done skillfully and not overused thts a different story)........regarding tht....i seriously hated Suzuka.....i dropped it when Suzuka left for America.......and Cross-over aswell.....

anyway thnks for helping those who will......and remember i odnt mind spoilers if it mens putting me up to date......and to facilitate explaining why i should read or not...........cuz even if i know wht hapened and turned out reading it again, ill only remember tht i liked the feeling of the plot and or characters




________________
I take interest in:
Science, biases, tactical games, girls, stories,anime/manga/novels, games, hard sciences, social sciences, myself, psuedoscience, statistics, girls, science, statistics, myself, girls, science, Warhammer 40k, boxing, biking, exercising, MYSELF, GIRLS, & SCIENCE

In Order respectively
tactics
Post #390896
user avatar
 Member

7:40 am, Jul 10 2010
Posts: 3369


Yeah go for it.

Although you will probably end up hating Eba like the rest of us laugh

If you really want to know what happens, go check out the discussion thread to hear what's happening and whether you're interested or not.
So are you at the point where Haruto has confessed anything to Eba? You might as well read on if you've got time. The story is keeping me interested, even if it is a bit frustrating at times (which I find is a good thing - Partly what keeps me reading)

Oh dear you haven't met Shiho yet have you? You need to read on so you can see her laugh

________________
User Posted Image
Lnc411
Post #390905
user avatar
Member

8:30 am, Jul 10 2010
Posts: 339


I don't know how to explain this without spoiling it for you. But simply put, this series can get frustrating. Personally, I don't feel like it has that deep of a plot... or character, but that's just my personal opinion. You know that feeling where you wish the character of a show/movie/book gets depressed, and you wish you were there to slap them and and tell them to get over it. Well, you will feel that later in the story, lol. Currently, we're just getting barraged with a bunch of random female characters will little to no background to them... I don't know if you can say I actually "read" this series anymore. I usually just skip to the last 2-3 pages, to see if anyone gets angry or pimp smack someone. laugh

The Guy
Post #390912
user avatar
It's him!!
Member

8:51 am, Jul 10 2010
Posts: 612


If you dropped Suzuka because you were frustrated, I advise against reading this one. At this point, it will only get more frustrating before it gets better.
Here's my advice. Try continueing Suzuka from beyond the America trip. I think it picks up and gets a lot better nearing the end. Less frustrations and more closure. If you still can't handle it, even after they
Spoiler (highlight to view)
get back together
, I suggest you never, ever, touch Kimi no Iru Machi, ever again.

________________
Do but despise reason and science,
The highest of all human gifts -
Then you have surrendered to the Devil
And must surely perish. - J.W. von Goethe
Criminal Intent
Post #390914
user avatar
Masanobu Hojo
Member

8:57 am, Jul 10 2010
Posts: 365


Wait a while before picking this back up. The story is in a bit of a rough patch right now.

________________
LOOK AT MY WITTY SIG!!11!!!!11
tactics
Post #390918
user avatar
 Member

9:07 am, Jul 10 2010
Posts: 3369


^ by the sounds of it, this guy's quite far back. By the time they catch up things should have cleared.

I hope laugh

________________
User Posted Image
anyagrace
Post #391071
user avatar
Member

6:26 am, Jul 11 2010
Posts: 28


in my opinion, the start of the story's quite ok but then, i realized my mistake. i read the whole thing until chapter 20-somehting and i was like "suzuka's better to read and reread"...

but i still read some pages of its current releases... just a few pages for curiosity's sake since it's possible to grasp what's happening even if you read 5 or lesser pages from the ending... no offense to those who like this manga so much... smile

________________
If anyone is interested in joining JShoujo Scans, kindly send me a pm, leave a reply here: thread or just visit our website and forum. Thank you. ♥♥
mystichead
Post #391990
user avatar
Member

4:57 am, Jul 16 2010
Posts: 64


thanks guys
After checking out suzuka again

I am strting to like it..............but not too much...ill finish it eventually........

However while attempting to this..........i have read up to 83. for Kimi no Iru Machi.............I am sorry but i have reached my limit.....i dont really htink its getting better ENOUGH for me to come back..... thus im just gonna put this on hold till maybe forever.......most probably never coeback for it...but its on hold just in case and not discontinued...............
well thts about it THNX guys

Last edited by mystichead at 6:53 am, Jul 16

________________
I take interest in:
Science, biases, tactical games, girls, stories,anime/manga/novels, games, hard sciences, social sciences, myself, psuedoscience, statistics, girls, science, statistics, myself, girls, science, Warhammer 40k, boxing, biking, exercising, MYSELF, GIRLS, & SCIENCE

In Order respectively
harutake
Post #399230
user avatar
schytophrenia
 Member

10:09 am, Aug 13 2010
Posts: 5


as for me, I think I will not read this series, at least until all the chapters is ready, or in the other word, when Kimi Machi is finished, so I can read all the chapters without all the waiting.. lol biggrin

________________
they told you I'm difficult, but so are they
Masterba
Post #400646
user avatar
The Shorty
 Member

3:51 am, Aug 20 2010
Posts: 330


this manga has many ups and downs and soooo many complications and misunderstandings... although that is what keeps it interesting! eyes

________________
D'oh!
SrwpkMX
Post #444996
Member

4:28 am, Feb 4 2011
Posts: 15


i wanted to say No, its not worth reading anymore.

However, i voted yes.
For the simple reason that .. the ending is up in the air right now, still not set in stone who he will end up with.

Also, devoted fans have been waiting for a long time when haruto finally gets lovey-dovey with his girlfriend, and its finally starting to develop that way.

pumpupthevolume
Post #445001
user avatar
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
Member

4:38 am, Feb 4 2011
Posts: 591


i still enjoy reading it

________________
"when i'm sad, i stop being sad and be awesome instead."
- Barney Stinson
sycoal
Post #445005
user avatar
Member

4:50 am, Feb 4 2011
Posts: 47


I stopped reading around the time when yuzuki and haruto were long distance dating due to me being lazy and other factors. I caught up with the chapters last week and I enjoyed them. I was happy that I didnt have to wait for a new chapter ever week as I caught up.

As for the story right now, it is getting a little weird again and I hope they dont do anything stupid. For whatever reason it seems like EVERY woman in haruto's life (family excluded bigrazz) has feelings for him. The latest chapter (122) seemed to hint at a rift growing between his current relationship, which I think is dumb, but then again I'm not a writer.

Is it worth reading? I say yes because I really want to know who he ends up with and thats IF he ends up with anyone. All the girls might get sick of his crap and just stay friends. I will caution anyone who wants to read it to wait until at least 5 chapters come out because a majority of the chapters end in cliffhangers that make you want to rip your hair out. Or build a time machine so you know what's gonna happen smile

You must be registered to post!

Back to Kimi no Iru Machi  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer