manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
Try out our new iPhone application!
Manga Poll
Your favorite series was dropped by the only group scanlating it, so you...
Find the raws and look at them without understanding the words
Ask other groups to pick it up
Bug the old group to pick it up again
Try to start your own scanlation group
Learn the language so that you can read it yourself
Look for summaries or synopsis to spoil yourself and feed the urge
Do nothing and wait patiently (sadly)
I already read the original language, so no worries
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates

RSS Feed
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

can u bear to read long shonen with no girls?

Back to Shounen/Seinen

so can you people bear to read a long 10+ volume shonen/seinen action manga with no girls just dudes flinging fists and baring knuckles?
while waiting for updates
You must login to vote.

Pages (10) [ First ... 7 8 9 10 ]   You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Post #620745
user avatar

11:18 pm, Nov 12 2013
Posts: 32

Yes action is all I really need.

User Posted Image
Post #620748

11:29 pm, Nov 12 2013
Posts: 196

Yes and no. My issue generally isn't a problem with "no girls", it's the randomly enforced lack of opposite gender. Plus an all male lineup just forces a yaoi fanbase, which is irritating.

I have much the same problem with manga with absolutely no males.

Post #620820
user avatar
bishounen lover

5:52 pm, Nov 13 2013
Posts: 439

I don't particularly mind not having a lot of female characters. However having ALL action and just guys duking it out the whole manga would be a bit dull. I'm a weirdo that likes action/fighting series but not for the action/fighting parts.

Seeing that I'm a straight female, lot of the time, I find that the females that are put in such manga are annoying, especially when their role is just to be the eye candy. Their character is typically given far less though than their male counterparts. If you take away such a character's good looks (and any role they may play for the 'harem'/gratuitous love interest) and they no longer are needed or wanted in the story, then the character is worthless and needs to leave. (well if its a minor character, I don't mind but no main characters please) Many chars achieve both eye candy and likeable character status, but sadly, not enough of them.

So bottom line, its better to leave a manga with no women than to add gratuitous fan-service characters just to fix the problem.

Post #620822

6:24 pm, Nov 13 2013
Posts: 57

in the action shounen manga female characters are kind of a second thought. They are usually not of consequential importance at all (makes sense since shounen means "targeted to young male audience). So I doubt I would mind.

Post #640106
user avatar

1:42 am, Apr 23 2014
Posts: 13

I'd rather have no females than crappily written ones who only exist for fanservice or as a love interest with no substance. Horribly written characters just bother me in general.

Post #644376
user avatar

12:59 pm, Jun 11 2014
Posts: 18

I don't mind, there are some good ones without any females like crows or worst.

Post #644389
user avatar

4:53 pm, Jun 11 2014
Posts: 463

love those, just focus on fighting with no romance. but i also like manga with fan service and gratuitous boobs - all that matter is the manga is good.

completed : 1530+ and counting!

manga challenge: read top 50 completed manga in MU
shounen: 22
shoujo: 18
seinen: 30
josei: 16
Post #644391
user avatar

6:12 pm, Jun 11 2014
Posts: 207

As long as the story is good and the characters are interesting then I'm all for it. I don't recall having ever read a long shounen/seinen without a girl in it though.

Remembrance, a forsaken thing that revokes ignorance and leaves people in doubt, is my only redemption and solace deep within the cascade of white.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
The evergreen trees speak of days long past when music mingled with the wind and sweet murmurs brushed our cheeks.
Post #644395
user avatar

6:45 pm, Jun 11 2014
Posts: 105

I don't mind if it's gay, but the thought of an all male cast doesn't appeal to me. My ideal shounen would be no boys and ALL GIRLS. biggrin

Post #644414
user avatar

11:38 pm, Jun 11 2014
Posts: 2595

Yes, and I can name a few that got super popular even though girls really play no significant role.

Arguably, Prince of Tennis really has no focus on the girl or romance, and Eyeshield 21 barely had much on the girl. The girls are there, but they don't do anything to the plot and they don't influence the MC much... so I don't think it matters if they don't appear at all.

But on the other hand, if there's absolutely no girls I feel like the manga's direction could go towards shounen ai...

Oh and I might say, best shounen are the ones that don't have the annoying girls slowing them downnn -- subjective opinion at best.

R-18 below
User Posted Image
Detective Horror Series

Tracker BakaBT
Post #667682
user avatar

9:21 am, Jun 23 2015
Posts: 65

I kind of think that too many girls make a manga quite typical . If the storyline is good I'm fine without them. Plus if there is friendship and cool teamwork sort of stuff I'm totally cool with only guys

Post #667689
user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT

10:59 am, Jun 23 2015
Posts: 1008

maybe. The manga just has to be good and you can have male lead series with no women and no action on top. Yamikin Ushijima-kun, enough Yakuza tales, political series, medical ones or cooking manga count. Quality female publication with zero romance also exist...

I read Bande dessinée / Comics too and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists
User Posted Image
Post #667693
user avatar
Lone Wanderer

2:57 pm, Jun 23 2015
Posts: 1439

Absolutely. All guys, all girls, equal ratio... As long as it's not harem or reverse harem, I don't care about the gender composition of the cast. And if the plot is nonsense, it doesn't matter if the manga has the hottest characters on the planet, I still won't read it.

And as for all those people who said "having no girls is unrealistic!" Well...I'd say it's more unrealistic when an unattractive, perverted, dirt-poor idiot finds himself surrounded by 5 or 6 extremely hot women who're all head-over-heels in love with him (or the same with genders reversed), but I don't see most of you complaining about that bigrazz

User Posted Image
Pages (10) [ First ... 7 8 9 10 ]   You must be registered to post!

Back to Shounen/Seinen  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
Manga Search