manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
Try out our new iPhone application!
Manga Poll
Other than synopsis, summary, or plot, what is the main factor that determines which new series to read?
The cover (or first page)
Art and character design
Mangaka (author and artist)
General popularity
Genres and categories
Ratings, reviews, or recommendations from others
Whether the series is complete or not
The scanlation group
I come to MU and see a new series on the release page, so I decide to try it
I just read random series
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates

RSS Feed
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Is this becoming a shoujo cliche?

Back to Shoujo/Josei

You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Post #503486

6:46 pm, Oct 25 2011
Posts: 69

In many shoujo manga, the characters are prevented from doing something "cliche", and then later they say "It's not like we are in a shoujo manga, so something as cliche as that won't happen" ( when describing some corny / moe moe scene that actually does happen in some cliche shoujo manga)

I've been noticing it a lot recently. The characters in a shoujo manga say "we aren't in some shoujo manga" when in fact they are.

Could it be that this in itself is becoming a shoujo manga cliche? Because if it is, then the characters are doing exactly what they said the aren't doing. What's the word for this? Ironic?

But still, I crack up everytime I read it. lol laugh

Post #505611
user avatar

2:04 pm, Nov 5 2011
Posts: 92

It depends how they present it...usually they are mocking cliches, so I don't think saying that its a cliche..

"That day, all female officers will be required to wear TINY MINISKIRTS!!!!!"

User Posted Image
Post #506042 - Reply to (#505611) by CurlyJoe
user avatar
forum bunny

8:45 pm, Nov 7 2011
Posts: 510

Quote from CurlyJoe
so I don't think saying that its a cliche..

Breaking the fourth wall is kinda more of a technique than a cliche. It's used all the time in all sorts of media, and often in an a self -referential, "it's not like we're in X" type way.

Post #525898

8:53 pm, Feb 26 2012
Posts: 130

Breaking the fourth Wall is a technique however the phrases themselves are a bit cliche. I suppose it could be dramatic irony (in which the audience knows something the characters don't) but it's played for laughs indeed.

I like my men androgynous.
I like my women androgynous.
Post #528654
user avatar
potential sadist

11:07 am, Mar 12 2012
Posts: 114

I think it's some kind of a technique that makes it more realistic or something? I mean, it makes the readers believe that the manga characters actually think that they are real. (LOL. Don't know if it made sense. XD) Hope this helps. biggrin

User Posted Image
Post #544622
user avatar

12:38 am, Apr 9 2012
Posts: 27

My bad, I read this wrong, Breaking the fourth wall could very much become a cliche, but not yet.

Last edited by aziza_ at 4:54 am, Apr 9

Post #544942 - Reply to (#506042) by story645
user avatar
✯ Sarcastic

7:51 pm, Apr 10 2012
Posts: 597

Quote from story645
Quote from CurlyJoe
so I don't think saying that its a cliche..

Breaking the fourth wall is kinda more of a technique than a cliche. It's used all the time in all sorts of media, and often in an a self -referential, "it's not like we're in X" type way.

Actually, it is not breaking the fourth wall if characters say that they are not in a manga. That is like someone in a horror in film expressing that they are not in a movie. This is more like a tool to instill a feelng of realism (although it may backfire).

However, if they start to sound as if they are indeed in a fictional story, such as in YOMEIRO-CHOICE, when a girl scolds another for taking up a whole page just for a transformation sequence, or when a character says that 'readers don't want white loli,' it is considered a comedy technique to add humour.

User Posted Image
Post #554126

8:46 am, Jun 2 2012
Posts: 352

I don't see it very often so no I don't think so. (I'm mainly a shoujo/josei reader and have been for years so I've read a lot)

It is funny though when I see that.

Post #561639

2:55 am, Jul 18 2012
Posts: 24

I have seen this a few times, but the only manga I remember is Kodomo no Omocha. I haven't seen it enough though, so it doesn't feel overused to me.

User Posted Image
Post #571190
Avid Reader

7:04 am, Sep 24 2012
Posts: 17

I see this really often, actually. I don't think it's become a cliche necessarily, but the effectiveness does depend on how it's used. Sometimes it's done really poorly, as if the mangaka is screaming "MY MANGA, IT'S NOT STEREOTYPICAL SHOUJO, I EVEN MADE A JAB AT CLICHES LOLOL!" but other times it makes me chuckle.

Check out my deviantart at jennerality!
You must be registered to post!

Back to Shoujo/Josei  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
Manga Search