Baka-Updates Manga - Viewing Topic - Is this becoming a shoujo cliche?

App

Try out our new iPhone application!

Manga Poll

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed

Forums

Main Index | New Posts ( all ) | Search Forums

You are now viewing a topic.

Is this becoming a shoujo cliche?

Back to Shoujo/Josei

You must be registered to post!

From User	Message Body
Usagi~Gurl	Post #503486
Member 6:46 pm, Oct 25 2011 Posts: 69	In many shoujo manga, the characters are prevented from doing something "cliche", and then later they say "It's not like we are in a shoujo manga, so something as cliche as that won't happen" ( when describing some corny / moe moe scene that actually does happen in some cliche shoujo manga) I've been noticing it a lot recently. The characters in a shoujo manga say "we aren't in some shoujo manga" when in fact they are. Could it be that this in itself is becoming a shoujo manga cliche? Because if it is, then the characters are doing exactly what they said the aren't doing. What's the word for this? Ironic? But still, I crack up everytime I read it. lol
CurlyJoe	Post #505611
CurlyTop Member 2:04 pm, Nov 5 2011 Posts: 92	It depends how they present it...usually they are mocking cliches, so I don't think saying that its a cliche.. ________________ "That day, all female officers will be required to wear TINY MINISKIRTS!!!!!"
story645	Post #506042 - Reply to (#505611) by CurlyJoe
forum bunny Member 8:45 pm, Nov 7 2011 Posts: 510	Quote from CurlyJoe so I don't think saying that its a cliche.. Breaking the fourth wall is kinda more of a technique than a cliche. It's used all the time in all sorts of media, and often in an a self -referential, "it's not like we're in X" type way.
CynicallyOp	Post #525898
Member 8:53 pm, Feb 26 2012 Posts: 130	Breaking the fourth Wall is a technique however the phrases themselves are a bit cliche. I suppose it could be dramatic irony (in which the audience knows something the characters don't) but it's played for laughs indeed. ________________ I like my men androgynous. I like my women androgynous.
justine_panda	Post #528654
potential sadist Member 11:07 am, Mar 12 2012 Posts: 114	I think it's some kind of a technique that makes it more realistic or something? I mean, it makes the readers believe that the manga characters actually think that they are real. (LOL. Don't know if it made sense. XD) Hope this helps. ________________
aziza_	Post #544622
Member 12:38 am, Apr 9 2012 Posts: 27	My bad, I read this wrong, Breaking the fourth wall could very much become a cliche, but not yet. Last edited by aziza_ at 4:54 am, Apr 9
Seijurou	Post #544942 - Reply to (#506042) by story645
✯ Sarcastic Member 7:51 pm, Apr 10 2012 Posts: 597	Quote from story645 Quote from CurlyJoe so I don't think saying that its a cliche.. Breaking the fourth wall is kinda more of a technique than a cliche. It's used all the time in all sorts of media, and often in an a self -referential, "it's not like we're in X" type way. Actually, it is not breaking the fourth wall if characters say that they are not in a manga. That is like someone in a horror in film expressing that they are not in a movie. This is more like a tool to instill a feelng of realism (although it may backfire). However, if they start to sound as if they are indeed in a fictional story, such as in YOMEIRO-CHOICE, when a girl scolds another for taking up a whole page just for a transformation sequence, or when a character says that 'readers don't want white loli,' it is considered a comedy technique to add humour. ________________
mysstris	Post #554126
Member 8:46 am, Jun 2 2012 Posts: 352	I don't see it very often so no I don't think so. (I'm mainly a shoujo/josei reader and have been for years so I've read a lot) It is funny though when I see that.
tsuyutonamida	Post #561639
Member 2:55 am, Jul 18 2012 Posts: 24	I have seen this a few times, but the only manga I remember is Kodomo no Omocha. I haven't seen it enough though, so it doesn't feel overused to me. ________________
SaneJenn	Post #571190
Avid Reader Member 7:04 am, Sep 24 2012 Posts: 17	I see this really often, actually. I don't think it's become a cliche necessarily, but the effectiveness does depend on how it's used. Sometimes it's done really poorly, as if the mangaka is screaming "MY MANGA, IT'S NOT STEREOTYPICAL SHOUJO, I EVEN MADE A JAB AT CLICHES LOLOL!" but other times it makes me chuckle. ________________ Check out my deviantart at jennerality!

You must be registered to post!

Back to Shoujo/Josei Back to Top

Search This Topic:

Manga Search

MANGA Fu