manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
Which kind of story would you find more interesting
Dystopia
Utopia
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

What do you think of the ending? (WARNING:SPOILERS)

Back to Shin Angyo Onshi


Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
makoz
Post #167957
Member

10:25 am, Jun 7 2008
Posts: 477


The ending is definitely rushed. Tae dies and anyone who is related to Angyo Onshi has been killed as well, which brings a true end to that era. I wish we could have seen what becomes of Bandja and Sando in the future. cry

I wonder how the blond girl (w/ western type of clothes) was related to Munsu?

Kuroe Kurose
Post #167960
Member

11:10 am, Jun 7 2008
Posts: 12


Marlene (the blonde western girl) was trained by Munsu when he was in the West.

As for the ending, I don't think it was rushed, so much as our expections were pretty high for a huge battle. I wanted to see more fight scenes with, Yeongsil and Mago and Mujang and Jung Son, but the story was about Munsu defeating Aji Tae, in the end.

Se3D03
Post #167961
user avatar
Member

11:43 am, Jun 7 2008
Posts: 172


I don't think it was rushed either, I think that was the way author wanted to express it in every way. The way that Tae killed almost everyone with that huge attack, showed just how strong he was, yet his strength was overcome by someone who's relatively weak in physical/power terms as munsu. I loved reading this, and it was really awesome until the end. I just want to see what happens to them and the world after this fight. I read in a forum somewhere that there is still an epilogue chapter after this which explains what happens after. I can't wait to read that.

________________
"I just passed the Nursing Board Exams!!!!! Thanks be to God!!!!"
tsuto
Post #167980
user avatar
Catnapper
 Member

2:32 pm, Jun 7 2008
Posts: 3488


More than rushed, things happened fast. Well, the last volume was good, the ending was good too. And well, the hero's fate was sealed.

________________
This week's favorites:

- Joshi Kausei





ççççççç[Ô .Ô] tsutopodus© will eat your manga and steal your cats!
Locutis
Post #168006
user avatar
Member

6:27 pm, Jun 7 2008
Posts: 3


Just so everyone knows the release by KORAB-scans has about 15 pages missing at the very end. SAO vol 17 is not completely out.

As a member of ETC I am sad to see another group put out an incomplete volume and state it is through the end. It is even worse that they put out this very low quality edit and proofing job and say that they "decided to go for quality and speed" (direct quote from [KORAB-scans]_Shin_Angyo_Onshi_v17.jpg). We at ETC try to put out a quality product and are sorry that we are not fast enough for some, but this is our hobby and we go at a pace that balances our love for our releases and our real life.

Kuroe Kurose
Post #168040
Member

9:33 pm, Jun 7 2008
Posts: 12


Ahh, well that's certainly a relief! ETC does have the best quality scanlations anyway, so no rush intended.

Se3D03
Post #168054
user avatar
Member

10:22 pm, Jun 7 2008
Posts: 172


So that's why i really was feeling that there was something missing at the end of volume 17. Anyways, I still definitely will wait for ETC's awesome scans, and reread it all over again. No rush guys, we patiently wait for your releases and we difinitely still will. ETC and SAO rules.

________________
"I just passed the Nursing Board Exams!!!!! Thanks be to God!!!!"
ahobaka
Post #168081
Member

12:36 am, Jun 8 2008
Posts: 1


For all those that did not notice, when looking at mangashare, there is a comment posted from a member of KORAB scans that says "Yes. The epilogue for this one is missing and addtionally a short side story after that. I can release all by end of this week. Check tomorrow or the day after tomorrow." This was posted on the 6th of June, 1 day before your posts about the missing pages. It was in response to a comment about a missing epilogue.

Just making a clarification. I thought since I noticed, I would share.

PhoenixRe
Post #174755
user avatar
LnoE RDeiR
 Member

11:01 pm, Jul 1 2008
Posts: 116


I dont think it was rushed, just fast-paced but very good. It closed beatifuly and the fate was sealed as is already mentioned. I admit that it was a bittersweet feeling reading the epilogue but thats how it was supposed to be cry

Although I wonder who the dude was. It;s clear to me that he wasnt confident when showing the medallion but he had the spirit allright...

A great series series that moved me...

PS Incidentaly right now as I am writing this I have just finished the last volume and my playlist (in shuffle mode from 1000+ songs) has played two cranberries songs (refering to the bittersweet feeling

Pritcher
Post #175128
user avatar
 Member

2:43 am, Jul 3 2008
Posts: 224


I just finished this up, (thanks ETC!), and I thought the ending was great. It was fitting for the story and most everything was wrapped up nicely. Sure a lot of people died, but hey at least they died well and went to their heaven to "live" happily ever after.

I was really glad Chun Hyang, (Sando), came back to her senses and didn't get killed off though. I was a little worried about what they were gonna do with her character for a while there. Now she just needs her own spin-off series to better explain who/what she is. Any excuse for more Sando. biggrin

PhoenixRe
Post #175538
user avatar
LnoE RDeiR
 Member

11:15 am, Jul 4 2008
Posts: 116


Couldn't have said it (or wrote it biggrin ) better myself Pritcher

As for Sando, seconded and I now that I think about it I really hope the author considerates it

corx_d_afikolami
Post #175543
user avatar
African Albino Cat
Member

11:31 am, Jul 4 2008
Posts: 675


One of the best series I've ever read. Like most of the people here, I like the bittersweet feelings in the final chapter. It's tragic but Munsu really shows us the aura of a person who holds firmly to his beliefs.

________________
User Posted Image
muaddib
Post #175545
user avatar
Member

11:48 am, Jul 4 2008
Posts: 18


Definitely ended well...for my opinion. A lot of sadness and despair will surely bring some good reviews...hero dies goes to heaven with his beloved and the rest go on living.

youngavatar
Post #175846
Member

3:16 am, Jul 5 2008
Posts: 3


the greatest manga i ever read. After this manga it going to be hard to find something as good as this. no manga i read so far is as good as this manga.

DarthBlood
Post #178103
Member

10:51 pm, Jul 11 2008
Posts: 2


I thought this manga was beyond amazing when I first read it. It seemed to be like one of those stories that just followed the main character doing random things, like Eatman. But then, later on, it got a plot involving Aji Tae and whatever, and I thought that just made the manga suck beyond belief.

What was the worst part was that Sando joined Aji Tae! For me, that thought just killed my love for this manga, despite the fact that she becomes good again at the end. It's not the fact that she was evil that bothered me, but the fact that she abandoned Munsu!

And besides, the ending? It left a lot of questions...

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Shin Angyo Onshi  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer