bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
How many series are you currently regularly reading?
None
1-5
6-10
11-20
21-50
51-100
100+
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed
Eyeshield 21
by SaneJenn on January 5, 2007, 10:24pm - 18 years ago

Rating - 6.4 / 10.0
Series Image
starstarstarstarstarstarstarstarstarstar

User rating of this review - 3 out of 5
Story/Plot - 2 out of 5
Characters - 4 out of 5
Drawing Style - 3 out of 5
Enjoyment - 4 out of 5
Overall - 3 out of 5

Plot/Story
A regular sports story with a typical plot, but Eyeshield 21 has its bright sides. Sena Kobayakawa is a small, cowardly boy who has just entered high school. He had been running away from and serving bullies all his life, and always seeks protection from Mamori Anezaki, his childhood friend. Hiruma Yoruichi, captain of the Deimon Football Team, sees Sena's fast and amazing running and forces Sena into the football team. Along with the football team is Kurita Ryoukan, who has dreams with Hiruma to go to the Christmas Bowl. Soon later, Mamori decides to become secretary to help out Sena, who is concealed as Eyeshield 21 to let his identity hidden. Sena is motivated to keep playing football after seeing an amazing rival, Shin. They later on gain more teammates and formulate more techniques.

The story is cliche in the way that everything goes in tournament style, they name their "techniques," the main characters have their motivations and some with dark pasts, and how the main character has his "extremely-beat-up-but-determined" moments. However, there were good aspects too -I liked how there were no impossible "power-ups" like there was in Prince of Tennis, and how it showed a lot of the training (like they did in America). There were good and bad aspects, but the typicality of it all was the biggest "bad" factor.
Characters
Sena - A wimpy, weak highschooler who has amazing running abilities from years of dodging and being an errand boy. His codename is "Eyeshield 21" to hide his identity and to keep other teams from trying to recruit him, and in the football field he uses an eyeshield and wears a jersey with the number 21. His goal is to defeat Shin, of the Oujou Knights Football Team.

Mamori - A caring girl who watches out for Sena. She has always been watching his back, and the reason why she became secretary was because of Sena. She is oblivious to the fact that Sena is Eyeshield 21, mainly from the fact that she cannot imagine him being a football hero.

Hiruma - The captain, quarterback, and founder of the Deimon Football Team. He keeps a book with embarassing facts about people that he can blackmail with. He has regular statistics but he is the brains of the football team and decides what to do.

Kurita - A fat, big, food-loving lineman. He's a giant, but he's very friendly and polite. He was also with Hiruma at the start of the club and has dreams of going to the Christmas Bowl. He's a bit of a crybaby at times, though.

Raimon Tarou - Also known as Monta, this monkey look alike originally had dreams of being a catching hero in baseball like his idol, Honjou Masaru. Ever since Honjou had given him his broken baseball glove, Raimon wanted to be just like him. However, the only good aspect of him is his great catching, but his throwing abilities are atrocious, so his baseball is not recognized. He joined the football team to be the catcher because unlike baseball, football needed people with specialities.

Ichimaru Tetsuo - A guy from the track team that always appears. He's very nice but is a big pushover. He keeps on playing for the football team although he has no significant abilities -he's just really there to fill in the empty spots.

Juumonji, Kuroki, and Toganou - Named the "huh huh bros." They are all linemen and have been called trash many times, and were originally bullies of Sena. Juumonji seems to be the only smart person of the trio, and is pressured by many people calling his friends trash. Although they only really joined the football team because of Hiruma's blackmail, they get serious about it later on.

Yukimitsu - Your average studyholic nerd. He's been attending cram school for quite a while, and his mother forbids him to do any extra curricular activities. However, he decides to join the football team because of his desire to do something other than studying. His idol is Eyeshield 21. He is weak and has less than average abilities.

Komusubi Daikichi - A lineman. His idol is Kurita, and decides to be his apprentice. He's very short, which gives him struggles, but also very strong and determined. He hardly speaks and when he does, only powerful people understand him.

Shin - Part of the Oujou Knights football team, he is their ace. He had been the fastest high schooler until Eyeshield 21 came into the picture. He is very strong though not insanely tall. Not much is known about his throwing and catching abilities (probably average). He is very bad with technology.

There are a lot more characters and somehow we all get to know them, and the best way to know them all is to read the manga. They're actually pretty deep but it annoys me that each has some dark past (or their past is exaggerated).
Drawing Style
Nothing amazing, but the artist is able to portray football quite clearly.It won't get anyone to read it just for the art, or to not read it because of the art.
Enjoyment
It depends -if you like these kinds of shounen it will definitely do its job, but if you're just into the manga and not the sport or into tournaments the enjoyment level might go down a little.
Overall
I suggest people to try it out. Although it's not completely original, the manga has good aspects and some people tend to love it, even though others stay away. Overall, a good read to pass time or from boredom, but nothing to stay up until 3 AM to read.


 

User Comments
user avatar
No Subject  
by NochiTheReaper
16 years ago
Rating: 2.0  / 5.0

I disagree on a lot of things, but I guess this is just your opinion. 😐

user avatar
u cant give eyeshield a 3/5 ...it deserve at least a 4/5...  
by kazesages
18 years ago
Rating: 4.0  / 5.0

good football manga ...u'll get the manga even if u dont know how to play the game

user avatar
totally wrong  
by wewerethere1
18 years ago
Rating: 1.0  / 5.0

This is the only manga now that is not disappointing
This is as far as the sports can go and this has gone beyond
The drawing is the most cutest and one of the best that I've ever seen in my life. The character development is the best. To add football into this is what makes it a huge success also. I find no flaw in this manga, sorry to say.

user avatar
try it  
by kinghart
18 years ago
Rating: 4.0  / 5.0

well, I think the story of this book is great.you can imagine that a "weak" boy be a hero in american football



... Last updated 18 years ago
user avatar
Oh God, you totally missed the point!  
by Laclongquan
18 years ago
Rating: 3.0  / 5.0

Man, you are definitely not get it at all. That's why you think not too highly of this manga.

Okay let's dissect this review

.........
Nah... it's not okay. Sound too much like I beat you black and blue like a redhead stepchild.

I will write a review about Eyeshield 21. That will tell why I dont agree with your review. Do check it!

user avatar
I mostly agree, but...  
by Sosseres
18 years ago
Rating: 3.0  / 5.0

You give your impression and manage to get it across quite well. You have some grammar errors that are annoying, but nothing really blatant.

As for telling about that many characters, there is no point. You don't use all those listed people for anything except listing them, thus there is no point for a person to get that information at all. You usually list the key people since they help explain the plot, but beyond that you only need to list individuals worthy of special comments.

As for the above comments about art, that could really have been developed above an average style as being the only comment. Comparing it to Ippo and Glass mask and stating why it was alike or different might have been one idea.

Just fleshing that out some would have been nice, since there is no sound in manga the art plays all the more important role. Especially so since a lot of mangaka tell parts of their story in the images and not in the text.

Lastly, a comment on the comedy portion. It is dull and can actually be missed if you are not into that type of humour. In the first 60 or so chapters I laughed weakly once I think, and felt like it once or twice more. So I would not say that the humour is a saving grace in any way.

user avatar
No Subject  
by Obsidian
18 years ago
Rating: 5.0  / 5.0

it's a good review talking about both the bad and good sides of this manga. The artwork is not the best I've seen but it's also not the worse. So 3/5 is a decent rating.

user avatar
EUhm..  
by barbapapa
18 years ago
Rating: 2.0  / 5.0

3 out of 5 for drawing style? You're kidding right, that cant be objective. Yusuke Murata is probably one of the best shounen artists right now, an extremely well-defined style, able to draw serious and funny scenes. Incredibly dynamic action-scenes... meh

user avatar
a bit underrated i think  
by bully_jesus
18 years ago
Rating: 3.0  / 5.0

while it is true, that the plot and storyline are terribly dull ( sort of like american wrestling ) the true strength of Eyeshield 21 is that it is very very funny. And has a huge cast of charcters.
I would like to express my respect for the detailed charcter descriptions. I would never have put in all that effort.

Show 
 per page