Yeah, it's mostly ecchi moments strung together by the thinnest of plots... but it's an easy, light read, more like microwave popcorn than anything else. Maybe a few unpleasant kernels in there, and if you're looking for something artisanal you'll be sorely disappointed, but if you just want to see pretty art of silly, over the top, ecchi situations set to a backdrop of vaguely-Alice-in-Wonderland, it'll do what it set out to do.

This was clearly never intended to be anything more than mindless fun imo, and it seems like CLAMP probably had fun making it. Sometimes stuff is just corny and bad and silly and that's ok. If we got rid of corny stuff we wouldn't have popcorn anymore, and that would be a sad world indeed. So pull up a chair, put up your feet, and have fun rolling your eyes and snorting at the ridiculous situations for a little while.

(By the way, it absolutely does count as shoujo-ai. Just because it isn't a super moving grand love story to shake the ages doesn't mean it isn't shoujo-ai. It's explicitly ONLY women ever in sexual situations with other women, and even if you want to say that it doesn't count because Miyuki-chan isn't into it, the women pursuing Miyuki-chan most certainly ARE interested. I personally feel like it qualifies)

I agree what Jeli said
At first I thought that this was a exciting manga
now it's just full of softcore stuff
like miyuki getting undressed for no reason

I'm ashamed to say I've read this nonsensical piece of filth- although in my defense I am an X fan and I was told there was an X parody somewhere in the book before reading it. Anyway, my advice is to stay far far away from this manga and its OVA unless you're out for some cheap girl on girl thrills... (And by the way, the X parody was lousy too). I'm giving it a 2 for the art alone.

This wasn't what I expected at all. I thought CLAMP would make something good, but it's just a bunch of wtf moments and try to get Miyuki naked in every scene, and wearing skimpy outfits; like Yeran said.
I don't think this is really shoujo-ai, unless you count that there are no males in this manga and that all of the girls try to get Miyuki chan naked for no reason at all.

Not recommended.

... Last updated on July 11th, 2010, 1:27pm

There's pretty CLAMP art, but the manga makes absolutely no sense. Ladies in varied (skimpy) dress pop up and try to get Miyuki-chan naked. Then there's some stuff about being late, mirrors, and general wtf moments that serve no purpose other than to space out the lady-raeping.

Sounds good to me!