I loved the cryptic clues throughout the story which hinted to what you already suspected yet still enticed you leaving you uncertain if your theory is correct or not. Most importantly because of the reincarnation aspect and Niina discovering herself made it a very dynamic story, one that I will remember, such a tear jerker and a story that is a must read in one sitting, thank you to the scanlation group and the mangaka for such a wonderful manga.

Such an amazing story with amazing characters! I love Hiina a lot and I really like how the characters actually develop throughout the chapters. How they move on with their lives and make sure to cherish each other, making new friends and deciding their future. I love it!!!! And the ending is just so sweeeeeeet. Of course there are a lot of scenes where I cried a little but it doesn't stop me from smiling too. Truly, a recommendable manga to read!

Omg Princess Bubblegum I am on the same boat as you!!!! After reading basically all the yaois I can put my hands on, I decided to give shoujo manga another shot and this one was good. It didn't foucs only on love but family as well. The only thing I wished would have happened is I really wished she told them she use to be Chitose. I know by doing this will change the whole storyline but that thought just kept tugging at me. I seriously want to see how it would have been if the storyline went down that route.

This is the kind of Manga that should have been serialized much longer. The story has lots of potential and quite unique. It has a lot of room for development especially with Niina's situation where she can remember her past life. I want to know how it started and would have loved to see her progress on dealing with it. It wasn't entirely explained in the story and we only got a short scene on Niina dealing with Chitose's past life.

The premise weirded me out though: a ten year old girl in love with a much older guy. Don't get me wrong, I love age gap romances but that situation just didn't excite me. However, when she got older, it was a lot a better. Again, the story has lot of potential with romance part too but the Mangaka limited her story. It was kinda rush and short. It would be nice to see development of Atsurou from being a heartbroken boyfriend to accepting and moving on to his life. It would have been better if we were able to see how Niina stepped out of loving Atsurou because she's Niina and not just a fragment of memory from Chitose.

Overall, it was a very nice story.

Okie, so I love the art and Niina and Atsurou... But the story seems quite rushed, it looks like the content of 6 volumes condensed into 4 volumes. Atsurou is absolutely absent in 1/3 of the story and in general he receives little character development. I would have liked it better if the author'd spent more time on his feelings and thus given some more depth in his character.

... Last updated on September 16th, 2013, 3:59am

I'm a hardcore yaoi fangirl and I had given up on shoujo manga a long time a ago..
but this series change my perspective of shoujo...it truly is unforgettable and sweet...
i cried a lot when i was reading every chapter..it was a shock for me because i am a cold and an unfeeling person..this manga truly move me.. one of my favorite ever....

... Last updated on July 30th, 2017, 3:49pm

I am in love with this story.
The characters are all so meaningful,
the message of the story's beautiful
it's just amazing how connected I feel to it and how much I love it.

I'm intensley reading this right now, so I'm not going to go into detail but what's important:
GREAT CHARACTERS
GREAT ART
AMAZING SPECTACULAR PLOT LINE(ohmygoodness all of the feels)
and like someone before in teh comments said, THIS ISNT A LOLLICON.
Not at all.


This is one deep, amazing, manga. One of the few 10s I feel fully deserves a 10<3
also PLEASE MORE SCANS PLEASE

Little Niina is so ridiculously adorable! Contrary to what the description implies, it's not a lolicon story, at all.

It's cute and a bit heartbreaking at the same time: imagine feeling and remember someone else's memories since you were 11-years-old. There are all these people you want to reach out to but can't overtly do so. Not only that but, as in later chapter, Niina is having a serious identity crisis. She has all these memories but she isn't Chitose but her whole life she's lived on being Chitose "reincarnate" rather than herself.

I really like this story, and if you're into this concept, I would recommend it!

... Last updated on November 10th, 2012, 9:40pm

It is very touching, and the story is good. I usually don't like mangas with age differences, except for a few such as Hana to Akuma, etc. I read the first 3 chapters and it was awesome, I was satisfied with the ending but somehow it got serialized ^ ^ (No complaints) The story is still so sweet and heartwarming. The art is also a big plus in this. Niina is so cute~And her character is not annoying, actually, I don't think any of the characters are annoying Which is really rare.
Overall:9.8
Art=10
Story=9.5
Characters=10