It was okay. I ended up not finishing it, because I got bored. The beginning and middle portion of the series was interesting, but as I got towards the end, it stopped hooking me in..

... Last updated on August 7th, 2020, 2:06pm

Really enjoy the concept of reincarnation and how all the different lives were tied together

Satoshi is probably the most overrated author alongside Naoki Ursuawa but i will give props where props are due.

This is a good manga worthy enough to be read once. I found the romance simplistic but fun the action was eh and the comedy sometimes needed to take a backseat.

It maybe that im attacking this series a bit more than i should but its still a good manga. Way better than Lucifer and the biscuit hammer

... Last updated on January 2nd, 2020, 10:33pm

This manga actually tackles life, and it does it well. Kudos to Mizukami, there is depth to this creation.

The only complaint I have is the digital copy I had by Crunchroll was realtively low resolution. Hopefully a better one will be available in the future.

This mangaka have the best idea in parallel universe, reincarnation, time, souls - they are explained clearly by the end of the story and tied up everything beautifully. Anybody who like anything a little more high brow and deals with these topics should read this.

Simply said, Spirit Circle is one of the greatest manga ever written. Mizukami Satoshi is an unbelievably talented writer as demonstrated in Hoshi no Samidare, but Spirit Circle manages to even surpass that. It baffles me how he is able to express in 45 chapters all the emotions, depths, struggles and growth that most Seinen/Shounen authors cannot express in their entire careers.

I wished the journey could have lasted even longer, because what a journey it was. The tension between the main characters are amazingly drawn out; the supporting characters play important and impactful roles throughout the story, and yet the author still manages to leave the audience with so much possibilities to imagine for ourselves.

A must-read, timeless masterpiece for all manga fans out there.

A great manga. One of the best and most unique that I've read so far, and I've read mountains of stories, manga, novels, etc. All in 45 chapters and 1 Extra too! The romance and nostalgia may be too difficult for some to grasp, but for those who appreciate meaningful and well written stories, instead of the usual shallow material, this manga is just for you.

The author makes such good use of nostalgia. I have no words at how good this manga is. He created such a deep universe in 45 chapters. I am so happy to be born in this era to be able to read this.

I am fairly certain this is Mizukami-sensei's best work. I wrote a long review explaining why I think so. The man loves reincarnation and this is all about that. It tells multiple stories of different kinds and they pretty much all draw you in. I don't think the series is perfect, though; aside from the ending (which I do not like) I think there are some other problems, specifically with some characters. It doesn't totally harm this as a series, however. So long as you don't go into this expecting an action manga, you'll find a downright fascinating journey.

Full review:
https://terrenceswiff.wordpress.com/2016/06/10/spirit-circle/

After reading hoshi no samidare and this one MIZUKAMI Satoshi officially became my favorite mangaka, sure he may not make long ass series like One Piece, Bleach or Naruto, but both of manga offer deep meaning making it whole different level from all other main stream crap. Definitely must read if you like hoshi no samidare.