Narrative-wise, this series is on the weaker side.
On the art department, it's simply splendid. The character designs, buildings, are simply meticulous. A 10/10 from me. If I have the spare change to buy artbooks for this series, I absolutely will. I simply love macabre tones and gothic aesthetics. THE AESTHETICS ARE SIMPLY BRILLIANT.
But my reviews are based on how "fun" I find the series to read, and I will overlook the art skill for the sake of it, and unfortunately, its pitfalls overshine its strengths (to me, anyway). Since this series keep having people glazing it, I kept my expectations high since I'm a fan of many of the themes presented, but it was a mistake on my part.
First, the overarching narrative. It spells the typical revenge mystery thriller plot.
Second, this series deploys lots of mini-arcs. Which is not always a bad thing. The author and their team (editor, whatnot) does a great deal of research for these mini-arcs that tackle issues of the era (since I consider it a periodic drama of some sorts)
My problem is, some of these arcs feel very self-contained, and it might even be better if the main cast are not overly involved in them. I feel like the main cast going into them can overshine the subcasts of that arc, and well, it just leaves me disappointed. Another annoyance, is that sometimes, you feel like that these subplots are just thrusted in "inorganically" to the "main narrative" (the revenge one). If you look at the type of main narrative it is, it sets for a tone of suspense and thriller---but due to the big emphasis there is on the subplots, it feels like the main narrative is always thrusted to the backburner... making the subplots feel like fillers. Not all mini arcs have this problem though, but some do, and it feels jarring when trying to read this... It doesn't feel very cohesive when this happen (other series that do this but more seamlessly: FMA, HxH, etc.)... It feels like the author is milking it to the detriment of diluting the experience of reading this. But what can you do, this series is a cash cow and it makes sense financially doing it. But it leaves a sour taste that this series is gimped and it has the potential to reach higher highs.
Sometimes, you're like, oh what is this character going to provide and add to the story, but they are just COOL... and STYLISH... but then you'd be like even if this character is cut off from the roster, there wouldn't be that much change to the narrative anyway. The author keeps pilling up characters that LOOK COOL and STYLISH, but it becomes shallow if you strip themselves of that STYLISH PRESENTATION. Shame. The characters would have become better if the author spent more time developing them than always trying to frame them as cool. Yes, there are developments, but they mostly seem to happen either in flashbacks/off-screens, and not really in the present narrative---which is why it feels stale. The only "progress" that you truly feel is mostly delegated to the main protagonist, it is his story after all... But even so, having such a large cast and the author still doesn't do much to show of the main protagonist. He is like a pretty flower pot 80% of the time, the sense of agency is low, but oh well IT MAKES HIM LOOK COOLI guess so it's allowed. (THIS SERIES FARMS TOO MUCH THE RULE OF COOL to the detriment of developing the characters more). There's just too many missed opportunities (hence the stringent score---I just want the series to be better!)
If the series gets a rewrite and streamline the fat and fillers it might be better. Maybe if it happens, I can give this series the double score of what I've given to it.