I was absolutely obsessed with this when I was 14. I would reread it over and over again while it was still ongoing, and binge on the monthly forums discussions. The theory crafting was perhaps the most fun part of the journey "reading and waiting" for it, like the off-season of a long running show. But even so, as the story reached towards the end, the obsession started to fade. The knots are getting tied, the intrugues, once laid bare, starting to lose its weight to me. Perhaps, unconsciously, there were areas that started to bother me became more perceivable the more I started to think about it. And with all the interesting parts resolved, I tried really hard to find if there were worthwhile arguments that would make me wanting to reread it---there wasn't.
Pros
- memorable and iconic design (lots of cute girls and boys eye candy)
- strong, immersive ambience (and kinda soothing) as long as the cons below doesn't detect you or your immersion (aka suspension of belief isn't triggered)
- cute, adorable, and dorky main cast (earnest, loyal, fun-loving, etc.)
- the type of plot twists was fun (for a 14 years old anyway... Not sure if I would enjoy doing it now --- I still enjoy mysteries but would probably consider this type of mystery not my fav nowadays)
- there's something about the above quantities to be very likeable to kids under 15-16. Personally I guess the appeal of the cute sides and the occasional rumination relatable and fascinating? (But it never truly gets as dark like works with heavy thematic like Bokurano and Oyasumi Punpun)
Cons
- the developments hinges a lot on shock factors ; and they do get repetitive after a while ; losing its impact --- becoming more "arbitrary and random".
- seems to be a story that relies strongly on the world building (that explains why things are the way they are), but with a poor in-story world building due to the author focusing too much on banters instead of developing the world and its mechanisms, making it feel fake and made me not care about the stakes at all. The problem is that the mobs are handled like a decoration, an afterthought, and not a resident of the world. The author would often introduce scenarios like "omg! Dangerous scenario incoming! Characters will die", but 99% of the time they are NPCs that either off screened, flashbacks, or jerks---with less than one panel of development. So MOST OF THE TIME you end up never really caring when there's a "dangerous scenario" (maybe only at first). I swear I feel more guilty letting 1 Shin Megami Tensei / Devil Survivor mob die than 50 characters in Pandora hearts dying. If not guilty, at least add shock factors like Gantz/Jagaaaaaan, but nah, the mob assaults feel more on the level of "how unfortunate"---because you never really get to interact/to know them.
- weak reread motivation due to not wanting to go through the badly crafted parts. It has some fun plot points, but with a weak framework full of plot holes that couldn't support it.
Now that I think about it, the plot and the storytelling formula is really close to these rpgmaker games made around 2010-2020s that hinge on the shock factor and horror.
Biggest problem with the series is that everyone but the main cast and arc centric character feel neglected, making the scope and works feel narrow, like a theater stage rather than a world of its own. With unresolved plot threads that feel unsatisfying at the end. Granted, it's a really old work and standards and expectations weren't the same. It's a really simplistic kid story with loose threads in the end that the adult me can't see past the weaknesses anymore. Maybe i saw that it had the potential to be something more, but it couldn't punch past its weight class.
Vibes? Reminds me of Toilet bound Hanako-kun (which is geared towards 9-15 years old kids), but with a more European-inspired setting.
Recommended?
It'll be a more or less fun experience if you set your expectations not too high, seeing that it's a story that would be considered most enjoyable for kids.
It's not a difficult read, and gets even easier if you enjoy the characters. However, if you don't find the mystery solving intriguing at the 3 chapters mark, then you won't find it intriguing because that's the bread and butter of this series.