It has been ages since I last enjoyed a (long) romance manga like this one. I didn't feel irritated at all while reading through the 14 volumes, which is quite uncommon for me. Really, just that is reason enough to rate this 10. I am in the twenties, and have been lacking good romance manga to read. Most shoujo mangas leave me partly angry, because they tend to be superficial (I know I am generalizing), alike and just plain boring. Of course that has something to do with age. That's why this manga entertained me very much. No it is not perfect, but it entertains the group it is meant to entertain, therefore the tag josei.
I like how it is not dramatic in a sick way, and how things that could have been shoujo-dramatized are solved in reasonable and nice ways. I like how Momo (love to say that name - momomomomomommomomomomomooooo!!!) can take responsibility even though he is just in his twenties. Because it is possible to be mentally grownup in that age. I also like how Sumire pictures a specific segment of women, who are shy, too self-conscious (especially about their flaws) and insecure - but still hardworking ... Well, you might realize that I kind of can relate to this Sumire-person. Hahahah. I just felt very pleasant while reading Kimi wa Pet.
Now, food for thought... There was one thing that was a bit hard for me to relate to. They focused quite a bit on the
women who are getting married have to stop working
-theme. It may be a common thing to think about in Japan, but in some countries in Europe, that's really not the biggest problem. Compared to that, they made
! Sumire being pregnant
much less of a thing to think through. That is something that is calculated quite a bit about where I live, and if it isn't planned,
! abortion
is often discussed. That wasn't the case here. But it didn't ruin the story for me, nonetheless.
Art - nice. Story - splendid. Ending - good. And as many before have mentioned, I really want to read more... But on the other hand, no. This piece is complete, and ended just when it was meant to end. 10 points to the international pet society!
Just be yourself. by Lillian on February 4th, 2010, 10:53am
QUOTE:
The ironical thing is that Hasumi actually still had a clumsy and naive girl image of her in his mind. Taking that he surely wouldn't mind the faults she desperately tried to hide from him and wouldn't just still love her, he'd love her even more knowing all about her. After all she is a lovable person.
Those two would be a great couple if just Sumire hadn't hidden half of her personality.
Answer to Lillian:
Lillian, I really like your analysis, but there is one thing I think you missed. It's hard for me to explain, but I will try. I disagree with you about Hasumi and Sumire being a perfect couple. It seems to me that Hasumi is missing a bit of empathy, compared to how subtle and weak to others' wishes Sumire is. She cannot chose the dress she wants to wear without being encouraged A LOT to choose for herself, as it was explained in the manga. Hasumi is too rash and missing quite a bit of delicacy to be able to truly understand Sumire. That is also shown when he just assumes that Sumire will stop working when they get married, without even thinking about discussing it seriously with her. That is why Momo is perfect for Sumire. He can sense her small changes under her facade. And in return, she is also very considerate of him (but that is just a trait of hers). They balance each other out, imo.