When I read angelkurisutin's comment about their bond seeming brotherly, I thought: Yes! That's exactly it! It does seem more like a strong desire for connection, belonging and love that is more familial. (At least the more the story goes along the more it seems that way.)
The story is magnificient at times and terribly pointless (and not in a AHSUM PWP sort of pointless way, more in a this-is-a-waste-of-time way) at other times.
Chapter 1 was fabulous in it's dramatic intensity. It could be a stand alone oneshot. Chapter 2 and 3 were mostly WTF. Chapter 4 had a sequence with a little thief that held a poignant moment when Edgar said, 'young children are easy to forgive those that are different.'
Chapter 5 could be interpreted as a bit of unresolved sexual tension, but you have to perv' it reeeal hard. But it did take us back to the angst and drama and intensity of Chapter 1. I felt the story lines in Chapter 1 and 5 were played well and pulled me in.
The art of Edgar's transformations is amazing: That alone is worth giving this story a read. There is one piece of art where he has half transformed (chapter5) that intensely shows torn emotions. Reeling.
There is a lot of inconsistencies in the historical time period, but what the hey. It was illustrated with wagonloads of talent!
What's with the eyepatch? Just to give Lukka character? I know he was injured at the beginning, but it doesn't play into the story at all. Maybe it was to give the reader more appreciation for his happy nature?