Winter Flowers

The artwork is not my cup of tea, I don't like it.
But the story is good, and seeing the beginning, it's rather an unexpected development.
Then the story goes, and I kinda moved by

How the both of them regret all the things.
The things they couldn't convey when the girl were still living.

BUUUUT theeen

SMUT?! WUUUUUT
WHY OH WHY
IMO it's so out of place for a story like this! It seems forced, and... with a ghost? Guh...

So because of dat scene, that's the best score I could give...

... Last updated 13 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

touching oneshot

by shandychan
13 years ago

Rating: N/A

This oneshot was very touching
The ending was sad but i think he was glad that he got another chance to tell his feelings to her this time. He must lived on for her dake

Was this comment useful? Yes

Sad

by thebikernun
15 years ago

Rating: 6.0 / 10.0

What a sad manga. The art was well done and the story sweet and bitter.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Made Me Cry!

by MissyCat
15 years ago

Rating: N/A

This was a great oneshot.
I'm a little tires of stories that have always the same ending... this story has such a good twist, it was so unexpected.
But now i just can't stop crying because of it...lol

Was this comment useful? Yes

Rewrite of traditional Japanese story-telling

by PrincessVera
16 years ago

Rating: N/A

This story is a lot more "Japanese" than most romantic manga, and you can tell because, as others mentioned,

The man has sex with a ghost.

The plot/twist seems very original/weird at first glance, but I don't feel like this is the case at all. The author took a common literary occurrence and wrote it into manga.

Was this comment useful? Yes

...awwwww...~

by otakuness
16 years ago

Rating: 9.0 / 10.0

im getting goosebumps all over me!!! god this is so very touching!!! about the miracle and stuff like that!!! maybe if i ask god too perhaps that would happen to??

what an unexpected story...but it only made me teary-eyed but it didnt make it fall...but still its nice...

Was this comment useful? Yes

Touching.

by dreamlessnights
16 years ago

Rating: 7.0 / 10.0

It was nice and happy and all then all of a sudden, they're there, watching the fireworks and he asks her that question. I don't why, but it just struck me, and I wasn't at all confused. And then I just cried.

It was good. Only thing that threw me off was the sex scene. Dunno. Found it kinda odd.

Was this comment useful? Yes

D`: Saaaddd~

by Chocoroll
17 years ago

Rating: 9.0 / 10.0

At first I got confused when Yuudai asked Hana,

"Why did you die...?", and I was like, "What do you mean?! She's sitting right there?!", but then I understood what was going on when he thoroughly explained what had happened.

Uwa, I cried. Even if

Yuudai slept with Hana's ghost...

Grr, I wish it were an actual series instead of a oneshot. Sadly, I enjoy tragedies.

... Last updated 17 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

Ehh..

by Twilight_Moon
17 years ago

Rating: 7.0 / 10.0

The story's sad at the end and all.. but it made no lasting effect on me. There were no pages preserving the feeling of loss...But it was a oneshot, so what could I expect? It was a decent tragic read.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Disappear

by Di27
17 years ago

Rating: N/A

A very sad one-shot it was like the second episode of Suika

where the girl disappears. I didn't expect her to be dead then and everything. wahh

Was this comment useful? Yes

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ]