The art was sometimes really unsightly but the story was kinda OK.
I didn't really feel pity for the characters, for example Fujimaru. His miserable life left me totally cold. He looked like a girl and behaved like a traditional Japanese woman, or rather how they want a woman to behave. WTF.
Some seem to think that others who don't really like this manga can't understand the deep story.
Well, I like to enlighten you about the readers who didn't like this piece of work very much.
The story is to rushed, for example, the years in between the capture and escape are totally left out, there is just a short flashback about Fujimaru's first rape and that's all.
Imagine you are held captive for years and even worse you are constantly raped by some disgusting dudes. I don't think anybody after that would behave like a well educated, sweet-hearted and undisturbed young man/woman.
Fujimaru is used as dramatic effect to show Shirou's despair and to provoke a tear out of the reader's eye but I couldn't feel anything for him because he shows little comprehensible actions. This lead's to an impossibility to identify with his character at all and therefore is easily forgotten.
We, quasi by passing by, find out that Sougetsu is the father and at the same time the brother of Saizou. This scene is converted in such a banal manner, that it's not even shocking.
This seems to me like a useless try to explain and excuse Sougetsu's sick behavior.
Shirou is kinda naive by trusting the leader (after he was raped) that nobody would lay a hand on his brother and just accepts Fujimaru's underground captivity for the years to come. Shirou could have used his status as the favorite harlot to persuade Sougetsu in loosening up the rules. That doesn't even come to his mind. He endures the rapes and seems to enjoy it after some time. Shirou needs circa 10 years to realize the truth about his brother because he seemed to be blinded by naivete, pleasure and illogical trust to Sougetsu.
Well, my suspicion is that this is just an excuse to fill the pages with unnecessary large amounts of smut instead of giving Shirou a normal functioning brain.
After the "tragic" death of his brother, he meets a former male prostitute and sleeps with him. I thought that this side-character and plot were totally useless and uninteresting. It's like the author had a couple of pages to spare and squeezed in this unconnected side-story, but in such a rushed manner, that it left me wondering if the author didn't know how to continue.
It would have been more interesting if the rest of the story revolved around Sougetsu and Shirou's hate-lust-relationship instead of just using the last couple pages to squeeze in their reunion,sex under questionable consent and departure.
Well, I liked the open end. This gives a chance for a continuation.`
(English is not my primary language, so forgive me. 🙂