The plot for the most part is decent and well developed. It is thought through and there are not a lot of holes. The premise itself has a bit of originality despite there being many types of these "wish granting shop" stories out there. The characters were likable, with uniquely different and endearing backgrounds. To this end, the manhwa was solid.
However, I cannot give it full points because of two factors: 1) the predictability of the ending and 2) the lack of actual consequences for wish abuse.
For the first factor, I saw as far as volume 1 what the ending was. It did not stop me from enjoying reading this manhwa because the development in the middle was really nice, but it did stop me from becoming excited about anything because I could guess too easily what would happen next.
The second place where I docked marks was for the lack of substantial punishment for those who abused their wishes. This manhwa is bubbly and happy and caters to a bubbly, happy audience who probably does not wish to think about people in pain and suffering. This is probably the key reason why everything in the manga was so predictable in the end- because you knew that nothing bad would happen anyway. Contrast this to xxxHolic or Petshop of Horrors which are manga that have a combination of happy and sad stories. Such contrast between joy and pain complement each other by heightening the emotions the readers feel. When reading a happy manhwa like this, yes it's pleasant, but there's not a lot of depth of emotion.
I think this manhwa is perfect people who want to smile, relax and have a good time reading. If you enjoy happy endings and romantic comedies with a supernatural twist, definitely read this. If you are looking for a mixture of both comedy and tragedy, go read xxxHolic or Mushishi. If tragedy is much more your cup of tea, go read Yumekui Kenbun.