Having waited till all the fuss about Hikaru no Go to calmed down to actually read it, I have to say, the manga lives up to expectation.
Many people complain about Sai's departure and the end, I however think those were excellent moves made by the the authors. Without Sai's departure, Hikaru's growth will not get started. He needs to learned to walked on his own and having retired so soon, Sai's strength forever stays great. Retiring on your top imo proving effective. Though I was really bumped out losing my most beloved character, and sure there is so many other way for Sai to say goodbye, this way still is my definite choice. Bittersweet.
Also Sai's departure has not effect the flow of the manga, it sure left sadness and wonders, in my opinion, this is why the manga stands out.
I can understand why lots of people dis-satisfied with the ending but didn't the authors explain the needs to co- exist of the two rivals 😕 Again, I am happy, not another cliche ending plot. We get to imagine, we get to wonder, and in a cheesy way to speak get to hope, that's how the manga stays in fan's heart. Or at least in my case.
They could have dragged HNG longer if they wished and I am thankfully and regretfully at the same time that they did not..... On one hand I remember reading Death Note after L's death constantly cursing. I wish Obata sensei had done the same to Deathnote, not dragging out the exhausted horse. Well that's another story. But on the other hand, another few volumes of this greatness who am I to complain ^^.
All in all, this manga deserves a 10. Art, what more could I ask? plot? pfft I feel redundant just to think about bragging more. What I like most is how the characters are portrayed, strength and weekness, everyone has one, that helps them grow.
Hikaru and Touya's relationship developed well, I can see why these two, together with Naruto and Sasuke, friends and rivals at the same time, very popular in YAOI DJ lol. Probably one more reason is because the female characters are not very powerful in Obata sensei's works (Death Note's Misa) but well you can not ask for absolute perfect, that would ruin things somehow.
Ehem, I need to restrain myself from blabling forever like this, last words, S A I ..........>sigh<
Okay I'm out.