banner_jpg
Username:     Password:      
Forums

New Poll - Harem Endings

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar


8:19 am, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 9386


Another poll suggested by silenteye. This time it's about harem endings! Tropes abound.

You can submit poll ideas here
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=3903

Previous Poll Results:
Question: Most hated type of ending for a series
Choices:
Ending with too many unanswered questions - votes: 995 (22.2%)
Axed or abrupt ending - votes: 2643 (58.9%)
Cliffhanger / suspenseful ending - votes: 494 (11%)
Sacrifice goal for the greater good - votes: 88 (2%)
Protagonist fails objective - votes: 39 (0.9%)
Protagonist gains objective but loses something more valuable - votes: 114 (2.5%)
Protagonist achieves objective - votes: 17 (0.4%)
Gets the love interest at the end - votes: 99 (2.2%)
There were 4489 total votes.
The poll ended: March 9th 2019

If you're going to end something, solve/reveal all the mysteries. Blacklist, I'm looking at you.

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT
 Member

8:35 am, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 1794


I hate harems. Well 99,9% of them, as no genre only trash. Still, it´s the prime example of self-defeating storytelling. Sayonara Zetsubou-Sensei should have been the last word on all of this. The weirdly complex ending was genius. One could easily make a full series about the premise of the last chapters. A shame there was no final OVA to adapt it.

________________
I also read EU/US comics and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists + Imdb
User Posted Image
Error 404
Member

8:53 am, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 39


MC ends up with Best Girl™, of course. Dunno why that isn't an option.

________________
The early bird may have caught the early worm, but the late worm survived!!
user avatar
Lone Wanderer
Member

8:58 am, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 1994


What an easy choice this was! I hate harem 🤣

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

9:36 am, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 330


The best end to a harem is in the beginning of Harem End.

Post #768031
user avatar
Is a female
 Member

10:32 am, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 3449


Back when I read harems, I used to just hope they'd get with SOMEONE, ANYONE because 9 times outta 10, they would end up with no one and it was the most frustrating thing. Oblivious MC's are the worst, even more so in a harem where their obliviousness is ramped up to 10.

Now I hate harems. Don't read them anymore. Bad genre, idk why I ever liked them.

________________
User Posted Image
Member

1:28 pm, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 80


I don't hate harems, but I feel that most of the time, they are done badly. I really don't care who the main character goes for as long as its not too predictable and it has good story telling.

On the other hand, I think I grew up. Some of the normal tropes in the genre disgust me now. Therefore, I read them less. I dont want a pervert MC and I really don't want some completely dense and idiotic MC.

________________
Internet Lurker At Heart
user avatar
Member

6:35 pm, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 430


Hah... I have a problem answering this poll because I don't hate harem series, but I don't (at all) take them seriously from a romance point of view.

So yeah, don't much care at all cuz I wasn't taking the "romance" part seriously to begin with, I read "straight" romance stories for that. Harem's are for comedy/just plain old entertainment as far as I'm concerned, if it's a series that's actually trying to seriously present romantic relationships with a harem-size group of significant others........yeah, I'm probably just gonna dump it, too far to stretch suspension of disbelief right there.

How about an option for "I hope he's bangin' everybody along with their sisters and mothers too"? I could get behind that, he'd be my hero then 😀

Post #768039 - Reply to (#768028) by dreamaway
user avatar
Member

7:25 pm, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 504


Quote from dreamaway
MC ends up with Best Girl™, of course. Dunno why that isn't an option.

Ditto

________________
DailyMotion - Weasyl
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

7:33 pm, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 2


To me, harems are just another kind of romance. While monogamy focuses on the relationship of the two persons and their gradual build-up to love, harems(polygamy) are, to me, more about the relationship between all of them, how they balance things out and accept eachother and less on a focused, in-depth love. Usually the adventure they go through together through thick and thin tends to be the attracting force there, at least for me. It's not really about one being better than the other, like chocolate and vanilla both are nice tasting on their own.

Also, since I feel this way, I don't really like any "harems" where the MC doesn't end up with the relevant girls because that's kind of like a part of the package for me. There are also different types of harems and not all of them apply to my thoughts here. I'm more thinking of isekai harems and fantasy harems, not school life or modern day stuff where they always end up with one person.

By the way, I refuse to accept anything where the mc ends up with one girl as a "harem". The very idea of a harem is several girls getting into a properly romantic(in one way or another) relationship with the mc. For it to be a harem in my mind, the mc has to choose at least 2 girls, preferably 3 or more, otherwise it will forever be nothing but a fake harem. Just because some girls are swooning over the mc doesn't make it a harem in my mind. Hell, the "harem" thing is way too vague since people likes to call it a harem even if the girls doesn't even like the mc in that way at all as long as they're close by and accompany him for whatever reason. As soon as another girl is introduced, people scream "harem" as if 2+ girls = harem no matter what happens. I really find that to be a bit ridiculous.

Another sad thing about harems is that it's very easy to do wrong and it doesn't surprise me that so many people hate them for it.

Well, that's my two cents on the matter. 😉

Member

8:34 pm, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 64


in matters of the heart, people don't like to share
I like slice of life stuff so harem is pretty alien to me.
I don't pretend to have everything figured out
I wouldn't think a series would ever end, it would just rinse & repeat, a new hair style or different tragic back story

user avatar
Member

9:33 pm, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 6


Tenchi did it right. He banged everybody, but he gave the first and arguably best girl a baby first HOWEVER not before he lost his virginity to the klutziest/funniest girl.

Post #768046
user avatar
:D
Member

10:52 pm, Mar 9 2019
Posts: 307


I first voted "ends up with no one" but unfortunately later realized that the option includes those stupid storylines where the MC "just can't choose". should have voted that I hate harems....

when I used to be able to tolerate harems, my ideal that I really wanted but never found was one where all the characters wanted the MC, but the MC didn't want any of them and thought they all needed jesus. I thought for sure I had found that in Ouran Host Club, but alas, I was naive to expect anything of that caliber from a shoujo manga.

________________
;D
Post #768054 - Reply to (#768044) by orochijes
Member

1:33 pm, Mar 10 2019
Posts: 80


Tenchi was my first harem, and it will always be one of the best. 🤣

________________
Internet Lurker At Heart
Post #768058
Member

9:36 pm, Mar 10 2019
Posts: 13


MC ends up with everybody is my main choice for harems now.
The reason is ive gotta SO tired of the MCs choosing the lamest girls just cause they the main heroine girl. There are lot of the times The other options are way better than the main one like For:
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
Oreimo and Oreshura where they choose the generic crappy abusive tsundere versus the way better girls.

Even if the main girl isnt the worst one there are still times where the other options are really good and i rather see them all work out than one or none.
So yea i rather it be a Tenchi Muyo Type ending where they get every girl. That way every girl gets a good ending. Plus the point of a Harem is to have a fantasy situation where you get multiple girls for yourself.

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!