bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
How should SFX be handled?
The original should be replaced with a translation SFX
A translation should be placed next to the original
A translation should be in the margins
SFX shouldn't be translated at all
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

thoughts on the ending? *spoilers*

Pages (2[ 1 2 ] 
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Not-BlackOrion
icon Member


12 years ago
Posts: 766

To be honest the ending was the only thing i liked about this Manga, No offense, the art is decent and the writing is so/so, but i didn't like how 5 out of 10 characters were straight (lol) out Mary Sues and Gary Stues. The plot was pretty much "that guy looks good in girl's clothes" +"classic high-school everyday comedy" with "yes homo" written on it

but it wasn't bad, i just tough it was quite bland and there was nothing i "really" liked about it... except maybe the clothing, classy.


user avatar
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 91

Under normal circumstances, I would never read boys love type manga. However, this seemed different and I enjoyed it for the most part.

About the ending, it was ok. It had a better ending than probably the majority of manga. but it leaves a lot of questions in my mind. Even though they confessed to each other, It seems to me that maki fell for Aikawa mainly because he looks like a cute girl. Maki made it clear many times that he basicly saw her as a girl, but what happens if she stops crossdressing and maki sees Aikawa in his male form? Will, maki still feel the same way.

even though this manga didnt dig deep into the chaallanges ahead,I still thank about them.


________________

Jeffrey

Post #595114 - Reply To (#595042) by wolfinthesheep
Post #595114 - Reply To (#595042) by wolfinthesheep
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 12

Quote from wolfinthesheep

The first two questions were answered fairly explicitly...Aikawa cross-dresses because he wants to, and he's guy. Those have been repeated over and over and over again.

The third question is completely irrelevant to the story; trauma is not foreshadowed or hinted at, and being effeminate and weari ...

Yeah, cross dressing is normal (something known to happen from trauma or be done to bully people), tip-toeing around male/female questions 80% of the time for jokes is explicit, and "why do you do this? just because" is an explicit answer. Why do you make bad posts? Just because. Did I just write a manga?
😲


Post #595131 - Reply To (#595114) by OlgaFrow
Post #595131 - Reply To (#595114) by OlgaFrow
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 198

Quote from OlgaFrow

Yeah, cross dressing is normal (something known to happen from trauma or be done to bully people), tip-toeing around male/female questions 80% of the time for jokes is explicit, and "why do you do this? just because" is an explicit answer. Why do you make bad posts? Just because. Did I jus ...

Wait, did you seriously just say cross dressing is caused by trauma or bullying? Yeah, the problem is clearly with the readers and not with the manga...


user avatar
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 950

The ending doesn't make much sense to me. Maki is not attracted to guys. He's not gay. Aikawa doesn't exactly seem to be a transsexual. He calls himself a guy constantly and doesn't seem to be interested in having any surgeries. Why is Maki interested in "doing" him at all, like the epilogue indicates? He's attracted to Maki as the girl he appears to be. He loves "her." I think the penis poses quite the problem and the mangaka pretends that doesn't matter.


Post #599459 - Reply To (#599453) by jedinat
Post #599459 - Reply To (#599453) by jedinat
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 198

Quote from jedinat

The ending doesn't make much sense to me. Maki is not attracted to guys. He's not gay. Aikawa doesn't exactly seem to be a transsexual. He calls himself a guy constantly and doesn't seem to be interested in having any surgeries. Why is Maki interested in "doing" him at all, like the epilogue ...

You'll find that sexual attraction is not as binary as you make it out to be.


Post #599462 - Reply To (#599459) by wolfinthesheep
Post #599462 - Reply To (#599459) by wolfinthesheep
user avatar
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 950

Quote from wolfinthesheep

You'll find that sexual attraction is not as binary as you make it out to be.

I think I'm old enough to have found or have not found what I will find. lol. The manga just did not address any flexibility or really anything about Maki's sexuality beyond him being uncomfortable with Aikawa being male. Suddenly it's "I love him!" and he's suddenly okay with it?


Post #599520 - Reply To (#599462) by jedinat
Post #599520 - Reply To (#599462) by jedinat
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 198

Quote from jedinat

I think I'm old enough to have found or have not found what I will find. lol. The manga just did not address any flexibility or really anything about Maki's sexuality beyond him being uncomfortable with Aikawa being male. Suddenly it's "I love him!" and he's suddenly okay with it?

Uh...

I thought the entire manga was essentially Maki becoming comfortable for his feelings for a crossdressing guy. Sure, I suppose it's "sudden" if you consider 42 chapters sudden.


Post #599540 - Reply To (#599520) by wolfinthesheep
Post #599540 - Reply To (#599520) by wolfinthesheep
user avatar
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 950

Quote from wolfinthesheep

Uh...

I thought the entire manga was essentially Maki becoming comfortable for his feelings for a crossdressing guy. Sure, I suppose it's "sudden" if you consider 42 chapters sudden.

...he treats him pretty much the same in all 40 chapters. So, uh... you don't have much of a point imho. There's very little character development.


Post #624048 - Reply To (#595096) by jeffreymgibson
Post #624048 - Reply To (#595096) by jeffreymgibson
user avatar
Come and Go
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 400

Quote from jeffreymgibson

Maki made it clear many times that he basicly saw her as a girl, but what happens if she stops crossdressing and maki sees Aikawa in his male form? Will, maki still feel the same way.

The problem is, what kind of look we could see when Aikawa in his male form? There are time when Aikawa wears the male uniform and we still could see it as a girl wearing male uniform.
So I guess thats just left the option of when Aikawa fully naked only. Now how will Maki see and accept Aikawa.
Well, Maki could always just do Aikawa from behind. 😛


Pages (2[ 1 2 ] 
You must be registered to post!