bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
How should SFX be handled?
The original should be replaced with a translation SFX
A translation should be placed next to the original
A translation should be in the margins
SFX shouldn't be translated at all
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

New Poll - Manga vs Others

Pages (3[ 1 2 3 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Site Admin


12 years ago
Posts: 10862

This week's poll is from Hatez17. It's sort of an unfair question (in my mind), and the audience for MU will probably skew some of the results. And yes, some of the choices kind of overlap (especially the webcomic choice), but deal with it. We've had sort of similar post polls, but this is the first to explicitly pit the different types against each other.

You can submit poll ideas here (and try to keep them manga/anime-related)
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=3903

Previous Poll Results:
Question: Do you think manga would be better as color or black and white?
Choices:
Color - votes: 2690 (18.7%)
Black and white - votes: 7599 (52.8%)
No preference - votes: 4113 (28.6%)
There were 14402 total votes.
The poll ended: June 1st 2013

Huh, black and white still reigns as king. I guess the rise of webcomics hasn't yet influenced the masses toward wanting more color.


________________

A just ruler amongst tyrants

user avatar
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 38

Cant say I prefer Manga over Manhwa (and/or Manhua), But there are more Manga out there, so ofc I have found more Manga that I've enjoyed.

I tend to dislike Western comics... but every now and then you find a gem 🙂

Also: I have no idea what an OEL is 😔


user avatar
Noblesse Forever!
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 1067

It's an unfair poll as many people hardly give a chance to webcomics. Over the years both manhua and manhwa have evolved especially in art. It's a pity may people don't give them a chance or form a biased relationship thanks to few low quality works.

Also: I have no idea what an OEL is 😔

OEL = Original English-language manga.


________________
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 184

😳 I don't even know the difference between them.


Post #601543 - Reply To (#601530) by strixflash
Post #601543 - Reply To (#601530) by strixflash
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 14

Warn: Banned

Manhwa and manhua is shit deal with it


Member


12 years ago
Posts: 130

I don`t have a Preverence, what matters is if the story and art are good, or better, to my liking 😁


user avatar
Mad With a Hat
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 4764

Manga all the way.
Also, for the previous poll, definitely b&w with some first colored pages.
Makes it special that way.

Manhwa is generally too melodramatic for me (also, the names...), and I don't read manhua.
I've read exactly one OEL that I found interesting.
I'm not into the format webcomics use, so it's hard for me to get into them.
And they're mostly manhwa or manhua, which I don't especially like.
Western comics - American comics are too... American.
I do like French comics, but unfortunately can't read them unless translated.

As for the comments like "I don't know what these are..." read the FAQ or google.


________________

Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
[img]http://i411.photobucket.com/albums/pp199/SyberAngelGabrielle/couplesig.jpg[/img]
[color=black]And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
[/color]

Click 'n Play!

If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.

user avatar
A manga parasite
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 323

Not the right question to ask on Mangaupdates, off course most people would chose manga as they come for manga over here. 😐


________________

Even after dead, we raise from the ashes for the sake of manga.

Member


12 years ago
Posts: 16

I would really like to choose both manga and webtoon since there is quite a number of webtoons I really like. But with so much more (sometimes great, sometimes really crappy) manga out there I chose manga this time...-_-;;
I'd like to have a second option...
For the last poll: I just think the quality of manga would drop if they'd do them full-color since the mangaka would have fewer time to think about plot and their drawings if they also have to concentrate on how to color the whole thing...


________________

sorry for the bad english...^^;

Post #601551 - Reply To (#601543) by Vu2010
Post #601551 - Reply To (#601543) by Vu2010
user avatar
A manga parasite
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 323

So you've got bad luck with finding any good ones, I guess you've never checked the database properly. For manhua (yeah, it's a rarity, I've only found one.), but for manwha, their even are some in the top fifty. The modern form of manwha that are released as (manwha) web comics, score even better sometimes than most manga on mangaupdates. Even the first place is taken by one of them, and a second one is going in the direction of the top ten.


________________

Even after dead, we raise from the ashes for the sake of manga.

Post #601553 - Reply To (#601551) by deadphoenix
Post #601553 - Reply To (#601551) by deadphoenix
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 14

Warn: Banned

Yeah deviantart shit and shounen shit , so much better dude . score even better , lol by what ? user vote ?


user avatar
bishounen lover
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 445

I don't have a huge preference between Manga, Manhwa, or manga style Manhua (as opposed to Chinese full color comics which have their own unique style). I guess my knowledge of Japanese puts manga at an advantage though. This category is probably my favorite.

The full color Chinese comics (not sure if there's a specific name for them) are typically gorgeous in art style but I don't care as much for storytelling style and the typical stories I've seen in those comics.

Webcomics are kinda nice, I do really like full color, but i don't know, sometimes i feel like they're lacking something, can't say what.

There have been a couple of Western comics I've really enjoyed, like Sandman or Umbrella Academy but as a whole i don't really care for them as much.


Member


12 years ago
Posts: 133

Anything that has a good plot that suits my taste for that particular moment.


________________
user avatar
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 58

I couldn't care less what type it is as long as I like it and I have found some I like from all the types, but western comics have a tendency of being too cheesy and American or just generally crap.


Post #601564 - Reply To (#601543) by Vu2010
Post #601564 - Reply To (#601543) by Vu2010
yarny, yarny
Member


12 years ago
Posts: 95

That's because the talented Korean artists end up doing manga for Japanese audiences. You may read a lot of "manhwa" without realizing it 😀 (Until Death Do Us Part? Area D?) Basically, their work gets siphoned off to the popular markets (i.e., Japan), and then all that's left to do proper manhwa are the bad artists.


Pages (3[ 1 2 3 ] Next
You must be registered to post!