I'm looking for anything that fits-

Creepy Seme (or uke) I don't want the scruffy or 'scary face' creepy.Something like the seme in Bikkuri suru hodo Doji na Koi. The way he would stare at the uke and creep him out. Way adorable. Anything like that would be great. and

sloppy or 'shy' sex.

Shy couples. Both seme and uke are shy or awkward around each other.

Manga where the people around the couple -family/friends already know about the relationship before the couple knows they know about (if that makes sense) Or where someone knows they will end up together before they even know.

Sorry if I'm not clear enough. I'm bad at explaining.

😳 😳 😳 😳 😳 😳 😳

For the creepy character, try Hideyoshiko's Udagawachou de Mattete yo. Definitely fits the awkward bill, too 🙂

That's a great recommendation! But I've already read that one.
Anymore!? 😀

Koisuru Boukun (Creepy uke!! xD)

I know more, I'll come back

Variety's the very spice of life, That gives it all its flavor. -- William Cowper

😮 I remember watching the anime based of this manga, but i haven't read the manga yet.

-waiting for more. ^.^

^ Well you absolutely have to read the manga! It's in my top best yaois ever. =D You'll become addicted.

Junjou Romantica Seme can be creepy at times! xD
Yume Musubi Koi Musubi: Shy seme, sloppy sex (And VERY good yaoi)
Aigan Shounen: uhgg... >.< Creepy as fuck seme... Actually, not sure if you'll like or not.
Rikugun Renai Shikan Gakkou: the seme can be creepy :3 And it's VERY funny
Mori no Koe not sure
Aijin Ichimayen: I personaly think the seme look creepy xD Just his face, dunno. =3
Kowarekake no Omocha: Creepy and dark seme. =( but I didn't like how he was mean
Royal Fiancé: Sloppy sex, lovely story =)
Omerta - Kochou no Yume no Kate: Dark seme, good plot
Houyou Jikken Only started this one. So far thought the seme was creepy because I didn't know what he's up too... there's angst... <.< >.>
Invoke (Higashizato Kiniko) : Creepy seme (spoil: you'll see at the end... it's creepy =o)
Zion no Koeda creepy seme in a way
Ore ni Koi Shite Dousunda don't remember
Kichiku Megane Hmmm... creepy seme
Kanpai! dj – Unapai : God, creepy seme and warning gore
Koyoi wa Kimi to Chi no Kiss wo if you consider vampires creepy
Kohitsuji Project ^
Oresama wo kurae well, kidnaping... I personaly think it's creepy

Well, a lot of them are NOT perfect at all, but I did my best. =) Sorry for the delay, I have my final exams.

Variety's the very spice of life, That gives it all its flavor. -- William Cowper

Thanks for all the suggestions! There's a few I've already read, but the ones I haven't are now bookmarked. <3

Anyone else have any suggestions?