Reader counter

14 years ago
Posts: 937
Just a suggestion (duh), but I was thinking we could have something resembling a reader counter, where readers of a manga select an option similar to 'I am reading this manga'. No user info needs to be provided.
It'll be a good way to gauge a manga's popularity, and it has a few other uses as well.
There are times when you will miss what you never had. I wonder how you will find what you so desperately need.

14 years ago
Posts: 62
Actually, if you look near the bottom of an information page for a manga, they show how how many reading lists it's on, which is pretty much what your talking about.
Practically perfect in every way. - Mary Poppins

14 years ago
Posts: 3120
Click series stats.
Then choose one of the list stats.
Miisa would be rolling in her grave.

14 years ago
Posts: 937
But isn't that one restricted to public lists? I was thinking this one should just be a counter, and nothing else. That would make it possible to open it to non-users too, though they might spam. You guys(mods) might have a method to deal with that.
@Sagaris - you're teasing me wiith the Miisa thing, aren't you?
There are times when you will miss what you never had. I wonder how you will find what you so desperately need.

14 years ago
Posts: 3120
Quote from Casey D. Geek
@Sagaris - you're teasing me wiith the Miisa thing, aren't you?
Why would you think that, lol.

14 years ago
Posts: 937
Quote from Sagaris
Quote from Casey D. Geek
@Sagaris - you're teasing me wiith the Miisa thing, aren't you?
Why would you think that, lol.
Because you still haven't told me what it means!
There are times when you will miss what you never had. I wonder how you will find what you so desperately need.

14 years ago
Posts: 3120
Quote from Casey D. Geek
Quote from Sagaris
Quote from Casey D. Geek
@Sagaris - you're teasing me wiith the Miisa thing, aren't you?
Why would you think that, lol.
Because you still haven't told me what it means!
You really don't get it, lol.

14 years ago
Posts: 162
Quote from Casey D. Geek
But isn't that one restricted to public lists? I was thinking this one should just be a counter, and nothing else. That would make it possible to open it to non-users too, though they might spam. You guys(mods) might have a method to deal with that.
The number of readers counts the total number of reading lists a series is on, regardless of whether those lists are public or not.
Allowing non-users to add to a reader count makes no sense.

14 years ago
Posts: 937
Quote from XiongMao-kun
Quote from Casey D. Geek
But isn't that one restricted to public lists? I was thinking this one should just be a counter, and nothing else. That would make it possible to open it to non-users too, though they might spam. You guys(mods) might have a method to deal with that.
The number of readers counts the total number of reading lists a series is on, regardless of whether those lists are public or not.
Allowing non-users to add to a reader count makes no sense.
It does if you only want to gauge the popularity of the series and not much else.
Oh well, I can understand this probably won't be that useful. Thanks anyway.
That thanks doesn't include you, Sagaris. You'll be thanked when you explain what Miisa is.
There are times when you will miss what you never had. I wonder how you will find what you so desperately need.

14 years ago
Posts: 162
There is no way to prevent multiple votes; such a system would be intrinsically broken. Also, what non-user would come to Mangaupdates and note that they read a series? Might as well make an account.

14 years ago
Posts: 937
People use BU only for info too. These people don't usually register.
There are times when you will miss what you never had. I wonder how you will find what you so desperately need.

14 years ago
Posts: 3120
Quote from XiongMao-kun
Also, what non-user would come to Mangaupdates and note that they read a series?
Creating a list that cannot be retained is utterly useless, lol.

14 years ago
Posts: 10892
We're leaving it the way it is
A just ruler amongst tyrants

14 years ago
Posts: 162
Quote from Casey D. Geek
People use BU only for info too. These people don't usually register.
Such users would gain nothing from noting they read a series. Why would they press the "I'm reading this button"?

14 years ago
Posts: 937
As I already said, it might not be that useful. Basically, I had the idea of counting readers of a manga who didn't purchase the manga, and hence were not included in the official counting.
There are times when you will miss what you never had. I wonder how you will find what you so desperately need.