bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
Do you prefer reading a completed or ongoing series?
I only read completed series
I prefer reading completed series but dabble in ongoing series
I don't care
I prefer reading ongoing series but dabble in completed series
I only read ongoing series
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

can u bear to read long shonen with no girls?

Pages (11) [ First ...3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Last ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 357

Yes, I can and I have.
Crows is a good example. It's actually pretty good.


user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 585

I think it depends on what you mean by "no girls"
If it's no girls whatsoever cus they "cheapen the experience by having them be rescued by the guys all the time", then yeah, I can live without having girls in a story...I hate useless girls that are always hindering the guy cus they get in the way because the guy has to constantly be fawning/worrying about them, but if it's just "because girls don't belong" type of thing, then, I think I'd be a bit weird having an all-male cast...but I can live with a shonen where the girl dissapears from the story for long periods of time


user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 85

Depends on the manga, I think Yes, but some of shonen can be better with girls in it.


________________

[img]http://i47.tinypic.com/qps9vs.jpg[/img]
This World May Not What Everyone Thought

user avatar
his and her sonnet
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 1127

there should be a balance between boys and girls in the story
i'd rather read something which has both
but if the story's good i dont mind

edit : i read very little shounen anyway,coz most of them have harem or ecchi
and if it doesnt then it would most probably be endless fighting or fighting evil or saving the world etc etc
i prefer seinen...most seinen have girls in them and they tend to have important roles/personalities that make the story interesting


... Last edited by sarah-eats-cupcakes 14 years ago
user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 120

Quote from Name-Undecided

"The fewer the girls, the better the manga" is my policy so Hell Yes.

That pretty much explained my policy too.

No girls = Twice the fun.


Endless Abyss
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 138

yeah imo girls just get in the way off all out fights and mind rape stuff in good seinen manga
like akaji, kaiji, crows, tough, one outs,... the list goes on


user avatar
A bomb!
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 479

Girls > Boys = bad
Girls = Boys = good
Girls < Boys = good
If there is more girls than boys it almost always ends up in moe pantsu quest.


user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 79

i think shounen should have some girls in it but not the timid and weak kind where they always have to be protected. the girls who are capable of defending themselves, maybe have learnt a sport that involves attacking and defending is a bonus and should definitely be added to shounen manga 😀

but in my opinion, more boys than girls is much more enjoyable 🙂


________________
user avatar
Ginga Bishounen
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 380

Don't mind personally.


________________

[img]http://imageshack.com/a/img707/4034/maidsigv1.jpg[/img]

Quote from Akamatsu Ken

True magic Results From Courage Of The Heart
Boys And Girls Be Ambitious
One Step Can Change The World

Member


14 years ago
Posts: 25

I'm fine with it. If it's a good read, then I don't really care.


user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 38

Yeh, I mostly prefer it without girls, in most cases they complain too much...


________________

I'm sure the universe is full of intelligent life, it's just been too intelligent to come here.

user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 53

wait, if their are little to no girls, then isn't that shounen-ai or boys love, if so then HELL NO. the only manga I've read with this type of scenario was 07-ghost, I seriously didn't know this was BL at the time, but I did notice a huge lack of girls, (the only ones that were emphisized on was a robot and a strange looking mermaid) and I droped this as soon as the best friend said "I love you" when he died. (literally didn't go a page further)

Naruto- This manga really borderlined there, but since I don't pay BL any attention I never even noticed it. (I didn't notice until I read a post on this site and really thought about it)


Post #505750 - Reply To (#497432) by PepperPia
Post #505750 - Reply To (#497432) by PepperPia
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 60

Quote from PepperPia

Yeh, I mostly prefer it without girls, in most cases they complain too much...

Depends on the girls, I think.
I don't mind a bit of romantic subtext (Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles) or when the girls turn out to be hellishly strong (Yankee-kun to Megane-chan). In fact, girls with character are quite welcome.

The point where it becomes that every chapter girls are kidnapped, held hostage, crying and pleading for mercy, saying "how could you have done this!?" or otherwise screw everything up... well.


user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 15

well if the story is interesting enough to keep me from thinking about the girls! but it's hard to find this kind of manga.


Member


14 years ago
Posts: 186

If that's what the writer wants to do then I'm fine with it. Most of Dai's quest or Bio meat necter, or death note would have been good if the few girls were boys and if some of the romance had been dropped(Dai's quest did create an interesting situation with a group of its secondary characters). Still, if you like the characters and can relate to them, its fine if there's a romance that doesn't detract from the story.

And of course, I don't think girl characters distract from the story, but what a writer might do with them could, especially if he's trying to fanservice too much. I'm not just talking about panty shots but just adding the character types and being too cliche about them, especially when it isn't in a humour comic.

So yeah not only can I bear it, I probably wouldn't notice since I concentrate on what is there, in a good, enjoyable story.


Pages (11) [ First ...3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Last ] Next
You must be registered to post!