bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
What's your sleep cycle?
Early bird
Night owl
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

Anime compared to manga

Pages (2[ 1 2 ] 
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member


18 years ago
Posts: 16

hmm.... i still have few more eps to finish the anime
well, as im a manga person (manga 90% of the time has better story than the anime periode), i prefer to watch the anime to get the bad ending then read the manga and feel better with the good ending, same with flame of recca, was shocked with the lame ending of the anime, but the manga was diff ~_^


Member


18 years ago
Posts: 19

imo, most of the time, for manga that have story the anime tend to do worse and for no plot ones, anime tend to do better


Post #97241 - Reply To (#97223) by TaDa_Baka
Post #97241 - Reply To (#97223) by TaDa_Baka
user avatar
Pomegranate
Member


18 years ago
Posts: 2596

Quote from TaDa_Baka

imo, most of the time, for manga that have story the anime tend to do worse and for no plot ones, anime tend to do better

I believe some producers want the anime to be different from the manga so viewers would be more interested... The thing about "not making it better but worse" is suspicious -__-


________________
user avatar
Member


18 years ago
Posts: 186

whee, i watched anime first then, after 6 months(more-less didn't count really) readed manga
to say i was shocked is to say nothing:
Anime:
1.Wow, intresting
2.Cool!
3.(at the last ep's) YEAH! BLENDER-MIXER MIX ROCKS!!! Ahahahah 😀
or something like that
then at the manga version:
1.Heh, anime is exactly same as manga ver.
2.WTF? No cutted eps? Looks like anime is completly the same
3.(at the last ep's) NANDEKURE?! WTF?! Anime has completly different turn of story?! 😲

Well, it seems that anime and manga "Claymore" is now will be different
That's great! Double the story - double the fun
(hope they don't do trash in anime ver.) 😎


________________

I always know ahead of time
That someone life today is mine
And i know how, and i know where
I am a Maniac as you can see

http://dnevniki.ykt.ru/images/userpics/8545/4670ea.jpg

user avatar
Member


18 years ago
Posts: 452

Just seen the intro lol. But I heard there were only gonna be 26 eps so I figured they would end it too soon. I'll see it someday though! 😀 😎


________________

mwa ha ha ha...
Check out my FF7 hardcore mod (PC version only): [url]http://forums.qhimm.com/index.php?topic=6818.0[/url]
[img]http://www.imagenerd.com/uploads/dn-lLXuA.gif[/img]

Post #107543 - Reply To (#66251) by Nelo_Neko
Post #107543 - Reply To (#66251) by Nelo_Neko
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 4

Quote from Nelo_Neko

Quote from xissix6

I'm sad that they only aired Claymore for only 26 eps. Hopefully, they make another season. As for the manga, I'm waiting for the next chapter to come out... The ending of the anime was disappointing. Doesn't even tell of what happens to Isley or Priscilla, not only that, Helen, Deneve and Miria all split up.. Don't really like that happening. Oh, also for the manga, you know that raki is with Isley, but what actually happens with him?... i wonder if he's stronger.

Even more sadly is how they minced and rolled up the storyline at the end. I sincerely doubt they are gonna make a second season since the story is beyond repair. Well, that's my opinion. If anyone disagrees, then fine.

i've seen both, and i was really looking forward to the anime, it started of good, theme song alrite, the fight at the beginning rocked, also did the fight with rigaldo. then it turned for the worse. i guess they wanted to wrap it up and focus with the manga. honestly i couldn't even finish the last episodes as it felt like a much poorer version of dragonball GT.


user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 492

I was sad with the anime's ending, because I wanted Clare to make Priscilla into mincemeat. (Theresa was my favorite character, so I wanted Priscilla to pay.) 😀 Plus, it's a bit disappointing that Number 1 and 2 didn't show up in the anime. I thought Miria's plan in Pieta was brilliant too. Still, I don't really like the results of the main team's training for the last seven years.

Clare can use the Windcutter indefinitely, but her sword speed is lower. Miria's new mirage can also be used indefinitely, but, again, is overall slower. To me, it's like they trained for years and got weaker. I do acknowledge the fact that they took care of the problem of possibility of awakening, but still...


user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 31

what i cant understand is how could claire overwhelm pricilla the anime last eps when while partly awaken (80% of youma released) she was only as strong as the lion beast who is himself very inferior to isley and pricilla.
can the claymores in the anime unleash more than 100% of youma, lika claire 😕 😕


Member


17 years ago
Posts: 320

Yea, I saw the anime before I read the manga. Yea, I thought it was badass, but I felt the ending was disappointing (the Priscilla vs. Claire fight I felt was weak). My friend also felt disappointed with the last fight and he doesn't read manga. However, he's convinced that there will be a second season, but an alternate story. They really need to make another season because they've already introduced elements that expands the story (such as the Abyssal Ones). For those that don't read manga, they're gonna feel disappointed if they don't continue with the story.

Of course, they royally screwed up the ending in the anime, so if there is another season, it will have to be an alternate story. I'm convinced that this alternate story won't even compare to the original story since the final fight was anime-only and was sub-par compared to the rest of the anime. But I also hold a bias that anything different from the manga storyline is garbage (pretty much referring to fillers) so I'm probably not being fair. However, it doesn't change the fact that the manga storyline is great and the anime screwed up any chance of continuing with this great storyline. And if they wanted to change the storyline so much, I would have rather they killed Raki instead of doing what they did, but that's just me rambling.


user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 21

they did good with the anime although the last two episodes need to be redone. in the manga raki is with priscilla and easley, and clare and the rest of the pieta survivors are off doing their own thing. they make the anime to difficult to be following the manga now with those last two episodes. I hope they make raki stronger too, maybe a male claymore or a half-awakened being.

It's wierd how i got attached to this series, everything is just really original, with a woman protecting a teenage boy and kissing him. Then the boy finding the two most powerful badguys and 1 likes to cuddle with him, and another likes to teach him to be a better fighter. And these boy reminds clare and the two badguys about they're past very strongly. Interesting series even though Raki cries a little too much in the anime and the concept is based on female fighters.


user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 79

They would have to redo the ending of the first season to make it follow the manga. I do not think they could get away with running a completely different story then the manga in a second season.


________________

“The ability to speak does not make you intelligent.”
-Qui-Gon Jinn

user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 29

OMG! I hate the anime! I was sooooooooooooooooooooo pissed when I saw it! ARGH! I read somewhere that the anime differed from the manga so I grabbed some popcorn and went to work. But the story is exactly the same! I sat there and it felt like I was watchin a re-run! The manga is drawn so vividly that I forget its pictures in a book. If they were going to make an anime the story should have deviated from the manga long before ep what 24? And then it kinda felt rushed. I was so let down. That has never happen before. BOOO! BOOO! to the anime! 🤢


________________

Some people are like slinkies, not really good for anything but they bring a smile to your face when pushed down the stairs. 🙂

Pages (2[ 1 2 ] 
You must be registered to post!