Pretty straightforward. Everyone who reads Kuroshitsuji knows that there are a bunch of fangirls out there who are in love with the CielxSebastian couple, and I was wondering where all of you stand.
Sorry, I realized too late that there should have been an "I'm not sure option". Feel free to expand on your answers.
Last edited by unusuallove at 11:31 am, Feb 3 2011
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Forums
Should/ will CielxSebastian happen?
Poll
Yes it should, and yes it probably will, because there are so many hints in that direction
Yes it should happen, but it probably won't
No it shouldn't happen, but it probably will seeing as there are so many hints in that direction
No it shouldn't, and no, it probably won't
You must login to vote.
From User
Message Body
Member
5:59 pm, Nov 15 2010
Posts: 710
5:59 pm, Nov 15 2010
Posts: 710
Member
6:15 pm, Nov 15 2010
Posts: 636
Far as I know, everything has been of the implicit "fangirl tease" varierty. I mean the manga is still shounen, not shounen-ai, even if the fan base has ended up being mostly fangirls.
________________
"It is those who know little, and not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved by science."
________________
"It is those who know little, and not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved by science."
Member
2:16 pm, Jan 10 2011
Posts: 710
2:16 pm, Jan 10 2011
Posts: 710
Can I just say something that I just thought of? According to the anime, Ciel loves Sebastian more than his own parents. Because when Sebastian took a picture of Ciel with that camera that would show the person not of this world who was most important to you, it showed Sebastian. Not Ciel's parents. And his parents would have totally worked, since they were dead.
I know the anime is no where near as legitimate as the book, but I still think this is noteworthy.
I know the anime is no where near as legitimate as the book, but I still think this is noteworthy.
:D
Member
12:23 pm, Jan 12 2011
Posts: 734
i love yaoi but i wouldnt like THAT to happen, i guess a part of me wants to bcz they are always together and bcz of the things i read, btu then again, kuro is more than just "lets see if they happen to do H things" i read it for other reasons, and whatever happens as long as is well made, i dont care.
________________
"It's so warm that, Before the snow has a chance to stick, He melts it for me."
________________
"It's so warm that, Before the snow has a chance to stick, He melts it for me."
insomniac Kagehime
Member
5:20 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 2707
it woon´t and i don´t want it. ciel should marry lizzy and get some cute kids and sebastian should die or get together with grell
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
Pew pew
Member
5:35 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 883
No...
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
Member
5:52 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 19
5:52 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 19
I think that the relationship they're in right now is perfect for them, but I guess I wouldn't mind romantic tension between them (especially since I don't like Lizzy at ALL). They're relationship is already so complex that I think romance would only make it deeper and more interesting.
Ultimately, though, I think Ciel deserves more than Sebastian (and definitely more than an arranged marriage with his cousin), but I think we all know Ciel isn't going to get the ending he deserves. His fate has pretty much been decided since the day he was kidnapped and his parents were killed.
@ForteAtrox
I don't think it would totally go against the story of the manga, as long as it was never a happy romance, you know? Like, it would have to be one-sided or possessive or creepy or something to work. Basically, I think romance between them would be possible, but what wouldn't be possible would be happiness between them.
Ultimately, though, I think Ciel deserves more than Sebastian (and definitely more than an arranged marriage with his cousin), but I think we all know Ciel isn't going to get the ending he deserves. His fate has pretty much been decided since the day he was kidnapped and his parents were killed.
@ForteAtrox
I don't think it would totally go against the story of the manga, as long as it was never a happy romance, you know? Like, it would have to be one-sided or possessive or creepy or something to work. Basically, I think romance between them would be possible, but what wouldn't be possible would be happiness between them.
Member
6:02 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 60
It shouldn't and imo it won't happen cause i think that Ciel sees Sebastian rather as a replacement for his parents than a possible lover
insomniac Kagehime
Member
6:12 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 2707
Quote from ForteAtrox
No...
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
don´t forget the mangaka used to draw yaoi and kuroshitsuji was also planned as yaoi. it´s not really against the story *fufufufu* still it won´t happen because it´s shounen
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
Taro
Member6:43 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 1975
Like juls91, I like yaoi, but I don't want really want to see any Ciel x Sebastian action.
There's just something about that pairing that I don't want to see...
There's just something about that pairing that I don't want to see...
Member
6:44 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 1354
Ain't it already happening? 
Super Lazy
Member
6:48 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 149
Quote from tartufo
Ain't it already happening?
Lolz! Same question.
Quote from ShadowSakura
Quote from ForteAtrox
No...
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
don´t forget the mangaka used to draw yaoi and kuroshitsuji was also planned as yaoi. it´s not really against the story *fufufufu* still it won´t happen because it´s shounen
I didn't know it was planned to be yaoi. Thank you for the info!
________________
Ruler of the Yaoi world
insomniac Kagehime
Member
6:55 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 2707
Quote from veve
Quote from tartufo
Ain't it already happening?
Lolz! Same question.
Quote from ShadowSakura
Quote from ForteAtrox
No...
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
don´t forget the mangaka used to draw yaoi and kuroshitsuji was also planned as yaoi. it´s not really against the story *fufufufu* still it won´t happen because it´s shounen
I didn't know it was planned to be yaoi. Thank you for the info!
it was thanks to the editor that it didn´t become one. s/he said the story would be to good for BL and decided to turn it into shounen. i got the info from here, donßt know about the original source
maybe toboso-sensei makes a doujin, like some female authors *Cough*gravitation*cough*
but in the end, more people can enjoy it as shounen. imagine the faces of the male readers if sebastian and ciel would suddenly kiss or confess. half of the readers would be gone
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
Super Lazy
Member
7:11 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 149
Quote from ShadowSakura
Quote from veve
Quote from tartufo
Ain't it already happening?
Lolz! Same question.
Quote from ShadowSakura
Quote from ForteAtrox
No...
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
don´t forget the mangaka used to draw yaoi and kuroshitsuji was also planned as yaoi. it´s not really against the story *fufufufu* still it won´t happen because it´s shounen
I didn't know it was planned to be yaoi. Thank you for the info!
it was thanks to the editor that it didn´t become one. s/he said the story would be to good for BL and decided to turn it into shounen. i got the info from here, donßt know about the original source
maybe toboso-sensei makes a doujin, like some female authors *Cough*gravitation*cough*
but in the end, more people can enjoy it as shounen. imagine the faces of the male readers if sebastian and ciel would suddenly kiss or confess. half of the readers would be gone
Too good for BL? I hope the editor didn't mean the BL (and other mature genres) don't have good and/or deep plots. Their focus is another but they do have interesting plots.
It is difficult to change a manga genre once a serie is started and it gained fans. But imo Kuro is so goog that it would have the same number of fans whatever genre it was started in the begining. Just they would be different depending of the genre but no much different as a number.
Last edited by veve at 7:17 pm, Jan 15 2011
________________
Ruler of the Yaoi world
insomniac Kagehime
Member
7:19 pm, Jan 15 2011
Posts: 2707
Quote from veve
Quote from ShadowSakura
Quote from veve
Quote from tartufo
Ain't it already happening?
Lolz! Same question.
Quote from ShadowSakura
Quote from ForteAtrox
No...
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
I would be greatly disturbed if it did...
It'd totally go against the story of this manga.
don´t forget the mangaka used to draw yaoi and kuroshitsuji was also planned as yaoi. it´s not really against the story *fufufufu* still it won´t happen because it´s shounen
I didn't know it was planned to be yaoi. Thank you for the info!
it was thanks to the editor that it didn´t become one. s/he said the story would be to good for BL and decided to turn it into shounen. i got the info from here, donßt know about the original source
maybe toboso-sensei makes a doujin, like some female authors *Cough*gravitation*cough*
but in the end, more people can enjoy it as shounen. imagine the faces of the male readers if sebastian and ciel would suddenly kiss or confess. half of the readers would be gone
Too good for BL? I hope the editor didn't mean the BL (and other mature genres) don't have good and/or deep plots.
no, not that i think. to good to be only read by yaoi readers. it is better to let it be available for a larger audience without BL as for a much smaller audience with BL. it seems the story concept was really really good so it would be a shame if that compared less readers could enjoy it
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
