Login to add items to your list, keep track of your progress, and rate series!
Just before the start of the French Revolution, a commoner named Gerard pays a visit to a high-class brothel, where he sleeps with, and then buys the freedom of Jacques, a young noble sold into prostitution. Jacques looks down on commoners and Gerard has his reasons for hating the nobility, but theyíre thrown together once again when Jacques ends up being hired as Gerardís new houseboy. Jacquesí determination to make his own way in the world, and Gerardís surprising, quirky shows of kindness slowly bring the two together into a romance for the ages!
ジェラールとジャック Gérard et Jacques Gerard & Jacques Gerard and Jacques Gerard et Jaques Gerard&Jacques
You must login to comment for this series! Register an account.
It made me jump like a kid.
Gerard and Jacques
I heard lots of good things about this one when I was searching for a good BL manga to read. But it must be because of boredom that I ended up reading it. ButÖ
I DONíT ACTUALLY REGRET IT AT ALL.
PLOT: At the time I was reading its synopsis, I thought, ĎHey, would this be something darker like Kaze to Ki no Uta?í for having such heavy theme from the medieval times, or the times where rooms still use lamps for illumination. After all, prostitution is not something everyone should tolerate. Then, as I was flipping off its pages, I realized this would be different. I just find it odd at the first chapter. I think itís kind of fast-paced one. The rest, itís great. It never leaves me some plot holes within my mind. The flow of the storyís clear and understandable that made the manga enjoyable and easy to read. The setting, which is France and the time, which is somewhere before the French Revolution, it became more significant as the story goes by. Itís not just that the manga-ka have thought it would be something new if she would set the story hundreds of decades back. It really suits the story. The romance, however, is not that appealing to me that I would go blushing and tumbling and squealing, in the sense that I find it lacking of something. Something seems of like, ĎHow did Jacques fell in love with Gerard? Just because Gerard say something like that, he would go all pervy and stuff then saying heís already in love?í and ĎHow did Gerard slowly fell in love with Jacques as he was also trying to move on with his love for his wife?í. Well I think, Iíd become some kind of an airhead that I didnít get it all, but thatís just something that keeps on confusing me. But if what Iím saying as o now is just because of the idiocy in me, well, I would say the manga did made me all go ga-ga, like squealing when they all did that theyíve done. Gosh! I remember when I was about to finish this off and the feeling that it might end up like some kind of tragedy, I have actually skipped the other pages and checked whether itís gonna be something like what Iíve had Imagine. If you wanna know what Iíve found out, READ IT!
ART: ItísÖ nice. Well, I would care less to the art, since the plot itself has drawn me down to this manga. But the way the manga-ka have drawn Gerard in the cover and on those 2-page poster-like picture, I donít like it. Gerard looks like a pedo and a monster having this giraffe-like neck! Itís annoying.
CHARACTERS: I would like to congratulate the author for this. She has made all the characters useful. No oneís had ended up dull and lame. The way Gerard and Jacques progressed along the story, I strongly commend it. The way the characters have matured on how they think and react about things, itís awesome. Itís just different in a good way from those good-for-nothing shoujo-ish yaoi.
To end this, I would like to say that this is not just a typical BL manga where sexiness is its standout. The MANGA ITSELF, IS JUST THAT PLAIN GREAT. Read it. Iíll give it 9.5
Surprisingly Not Too Serious
The historical setting (French Revolution) and the inclusion of prostitution and rampant classicism may give you the impression that Gerard to Jacques is a dark, heavy tale. While there are some dark moments (and twisted characters) here, the storyline contains plenty of lighthearted scenes to keep you happily skipping along with Gerard to Jacques from beginning to end. Now, that may appeal to some of you....
...but in fact I think the lack of gravity turns this potentially great story into a mediocre one. Some major elements of Gerard's painful past receive just a light touch-up, even though they merit a more thorough explanation. The tone of the last chapter seems at odds with the heart wrenching episodes leading up to that anticlimax. And although the author made a valiant effort to explain the Reign of Terror and the political machinations behind that outbreak of violence, the Terror lacks any concrete presence in the storyline. So what we get is a bunch of characters sitting around and explaining, for several pages at times, what is going on with the Robespierre and his band of bloodthirsty executioners. The sense of danger brought on by the Terror is effectively blotted out - and it remains a distant thing, which muffles the realism of the story.
I do like the characters. Even the villainous ones - they are interesting and well-developed and I think their relationships occur naturally (and in Gerard and Jacques' case, rather touchingly). I'd like to point out, however, that there is a random time skip at a crucial moment in Gerard and Jacques' relationship that left me a little bewildered.
The weaknesses in Gerard to Jacques give me the overall impression that the story was rushed. Something like the mangaka had planned a more lengthy storyline but the editors cut the series short. Perhaps if the author had been given a few more chapters to unravel this story, we might have ended up with a true gem.
Okay, the exploding Jacques was very funny. But i'm sorry to say I didn't really enjoy this. Partly because it didn't suit my own tastes, but also because I didn't feel much with it, I couldn't get into the story. French history in manga, it just doesn't seem to work in this one. It's nothing like the real thing, nothing like real historical movies. Only the art and the names made it clear it was historical france, otherwise I really wouldn't have noticed it. And even that wasn't wondeful, because I really didn't like the art.
The only thing I liked was Jacques. It's a really stubborn and funny character with lots of energy and quite interesting. But that's all I liked.
For a moment lets just forget about wonderful art and what appeals to the eye and focus more on what we're looking to get out of the plot. This isn't your everyday normal yaoi. If the first couple of pages don't draw you in then the setting surely will. It's humorous and a bit understanding, not to mention cute and very light. And it's not too hard but not too soft, so if you're looking for a yaoi that grazes the top then hear you go. Also, the use of a hetro pair really describes missing points. Bravo, this is definitely a favorite of mines.
Plot: 9/10 Art: 8/10 Characters: 10/10
Although I liked this one very much, it made me feel like something was missing. But it definitly is a good and original read, I haven´t seen many manga with this kinda plot. What amazed me the most was that the author had a big knowledge of the French revolution, wich I find rather rare for some of historical manga. You could really see that Yoshinaga-sensei had put alot of thought and effort into it.
Read it, you will not regret it.
... Last updated on December 2nd, 2011, 12:07pm
I can maybe see why people like this, but it wasn't amazing for me. I found it very readable and it had a nice flow. That said, there were many boring parts for me. If you like history and politics, then maybe these parts wouldn't be so boring for you, but I find it tiresome. It also failed to make me *feel* anything for the most part. I just didn't connect with the characters and their emotions, and I felt as if I was supposed to. So, again, this was not a bad story at all, I just didn't really find it to be *that* great.
o___o This is the first manga i've read through without a break or getting distracted for quite a while... which says a lot (i am an easily distracted person). Anyway, at first i wasn't sure, historical manga are not my cup of tea generally, they're often depressing or too serious, but this was a perfect blend of historical fact, drama and comedy to make it inviting and addictive. I really enjoyed the art style as well, at first i was a bit doubtful - its not a style i usually fall for, but combined with the story and the occasional moments of humour the art is truly brought to life - its realistic without being a deterrent, yet has the ability to suddenly become entirely comical to help alleviate any pressure in the story. I also love the realistic aspect of the relationship, its not a love at first sight story, its not a gradually fall in love and live happily ever after story either, its progressive but takes steps backwards based on circumstance and the characters individual needs. Its very well done.
Highly enjoyable, well written, well drawn and with many elements of realism. This is not the bog standard yaoi, in fact i might even call this a diamond among in a sea of garnets.
it's has a really nice and sweet story, pretty art, and it is also historical <333 ^^ LOVE the characters and the love scenes!!! the first ch was alright. i got hook to this manga when Jacques became a servant where he can be alone with Gerard only in the library. i also find how Jacques fell for Gerard very cute and i enjoyed how Gerard teases Jacques through out the manga!!!!
... Last updated on February 14th, 2011, 4:01pm
not your typical yaoi
I loved the artwork in this one. It had beauty and character. This wasn't your typical yaoi with no real storyline and just sex. It is unique because of the setting. I love manga with good historical settings. The French Revolution was a great setting for this one. I get so tired of Japanese historical settings being over done. It was well done and not just sex for the sake of sex. The over all pace was good - so glad no attempt was made to cram it into a oneshot. You got to know and like the characters. I also liked the ending a lot. The author did a great job capturing the emotions of the characters. I highly reccomend this one.
... Last updated on August 22nd, 2010, 12:52am
awww soo geat!!
Well at first I didn't really want to reade it because of the cover but then I started it because I was bored. And after the first chapter I was totally absorbed in it!! The story has a great developpment and I love the characters.